Rookie cast members involved in ‘big altercation’ With the Season 37 cast members unveiled through a forum thread and various The Challenge insider Instagram accounts, there have also been spoilers arriving about eliminations, DQs, and replacement cast members. In addition, there’s been a Challenge showmance or two in the rumors, but also a bit of drama seems to be occurring with rookies versus veterans, or in this case, rookies versus rookies. Based on Challenge insider Gamer Vev’s tweet on May 26 (below), rookie cast members Corey Lay and Hughie were involved in a “big altercation” and needed to be “separated by security.”