For continuance inadvertently the yosemite fish patch is continued was left off the calendar it is being continued indefinitely and will be renoticed for the benefit of the public further on your calendars commissioners item 15 for case on rosie after a discretionary review it has been withdrawn and will not be considered on todays agenda i have nothing further you might want to take Public Comment. On Public Comment no items proposed for continuance. Seeing none, Public Comment is closed. Thank you. Commissioners that place us under consideration of the definite minutes for july 16, 2015 i have i have no speaker cards. Okay. Any Public Comment on draft minutes . Seeing none, Public Comment is closed commissioner moore we received an email regarding is an omission on the minutes i didnt receive a copy of draft minutes myself and no notification i hope other commissioners Pay Attention to the email and just want to bring it to our attention. We checked that theyre on is july 2nd and 16 that was requested by rose hill. Commissioner richards move to approve. Thank you, commissioners on that motion to do you want the minutes commissioner antonini commissioner hillis commissioner moore commissioner richards commissioner wu and commissioner president fong so moved, commissioners, that motion passes unanimously 6 to zero and places you on item 2 commissioner questions or comments. Commissioner antonini. Thank you. Im reading a very interesting book it was published maybe thirty years ago on chiropractor bucking will i the blind boss of San Francisco and about the period from the 18 percent 50s to 1890 among the things discussed with the consolidation act of 1956 that was the time when the city and county of San Francisco were consolidated into one unit and fortunately part of that San Francisco was extended to the line between what is now San Mateo County and sacking county was eliminated and the line for San Francisco county was established where it currently is and has by a do effects as we now realize were constricted in our land at that time that was lots of land that is now San Francisco and there was a fear that the smaller town for identification what is now San Mateo County would be a burden they especially\want to have to deal with instead of having a separate county in a straight decide for efficient to combine the two sometimes efficiency is a great thing but hindsight is always 50 50 but no way of knowing done at a state level and certainly something that what about revisited in the city any unincorporated county part of the San Francisco might not be the worst thing to pursue we ask we adjourn today unfortunately jim meekly could i think other commissioners want to make remarks and rosa are a was the leader of a wonderful institution it this i would have the skills in english for pupils and vocal training that was a wonderful thing she was a wonderful san franciscan for the Mission District so adjourn in here memory. Commissioner moore. Id like to ask that we close in memory of jim meekly could today he passed away on the evening of august 3rd and all of us including many of the people in the audience everybody knew jim he spoke passionately in front of that commission on many many issues effecting the community and very recently he spoke on an issue the 5 foot commercial retail space in the fulsome corridor he hope we find a way i dont have the the evidence will then show but to dedicate those 5 feet to the jim meekly could who was 5 feet jim was a Tireless Community leader in support ever everything south of market and spoke on the Entertainment Commission it was critical the continuation of ballets by the entertainment users would stay south of market he served on the chip council his hand is very, very visual in the selma western Selma Community he was a member of the San FranciscoNeighborhood Network for about his it was extremely important to collective speaking of the neighborhood in front of us he was a county organizer i personally like the word the chronicle they called him a Community Hero in 2011 pdr was big on his list the continuation of Small Businesses and the perpetuation of artists south of market jim was a supporter of the use in the family zone at this point was a quiet voice to help them really stand in front of of us with their support to be heard and i couldnt i could speak about him in so many ways we all remember him it was recently, i see him being here it is hard for me to know hes not here anymore. Commissioner richards. Yeah. Id like to piggyback on what commissioner moore said for those who want to look at jim it is an page 11 in the reporter and points on how i felt about jim we almost agreed on everything he came from a place it was hard to follow his heart he had the Community Spirit in mind im proud to call him a member of the lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgenders some times that was hard to deal with we spared on the garages on fulsome street and fortunately, we voted to put them on the alley he had a conversation he understood what i we were coming from i think where south of market the western selma a huge part of jims for not i appreciate adjourning the meeting in his meeting and commissioner antonini is good at drawing parallels from seattle in a good way and a challenging way that San Francisco is just a number of cranes in the sky and theres still like us struggling keeping a vibrant struggle and a new vibrant city so i have one related important question for the Zoning Administrator sanchez it is yesterday maybe even as of latin last night how old were you. I was 39. How old are you this morning. 39 plus one. Happy birthday. clapping. oh. Commissioner moore. Happy birthday i want to comment on a memo updating us on 620 mission the colleague wrote a very good summary on the status of us trying to monitor the rooftop on those building the addressing of all the issues before checking no complainants and indeed it is operating as planned and as a good thing so thank you colleague grove that is a very good report. Commissioners, if theres nothing further we can move on to to Department Matters item 3 directors announcements. Good afternoon, commissioners sarah jones im acting planning directing director awhile john ram racked in italian. Item 4 past events of the board of appeals and the Historic Preservation commission. Good afternoon, commissioners and happy birthday Zoning Administrator at this weeks land use hearing the assessor dwelling unit in district 3 and 8 we are heard to permit a dwelling units in district 3 and 8 for july 16th and voted 4 to 2 to approve the modification at first Land Use Commission to supervisor kim introduced 3 amendments that apply to both ordinances they prohibit the conduction of adus while the tenants have been displaced in 10 years it passed and to shortterm rentals this amendment passed to supervisor wiener voting against it and prohibited the condominium conversion or fractional ownership to be used as rentcontrolled units and reich it for vinyl sales sxh voted against it the third was for your review and consideration in a duplicated file at this weeks hearing the ellis act prohibition as the the adus apply to all the adus for the retrofitted use they were referred to the xhuks Commission Supervisor cowen made an amendment to require the department to monitor the adus and require applicants to indicate in their complications whether or not they intend to use the shortterm rentals along with supervisor cowen were recommended to the full board next the Land Use Commission was the seery in the south of market district this was sponsored by supervisor kim the ordinance will allow the accessory use for the Live Performance in the western south of market be mixed use the Planning Commission heard the item on july 16th and recommended approval at the lufgs supervisor wiener spoke in favor and doovment the eating and drinking establishments to provide eating and drink no comment by a unanimous vote it was recommended to the full board and the balance report was continued to september 1st at the full board of supervisors the legalization informative secondary dwelling units passed it is Second Street for dproupg allowing the existing restaurants to open a second location with the conditional use and pass it is second reading the prohibition on the proposed quarter special use passed its second reading a public hearing on the negative declaration for the landfill open landfill in the county was continued until september 29th and a public hearing for the tentative math was heard this appeal last filed based on a chartering of the issues that the Planning Department should have been brought up during the process after a short hearing the appellant was not here the vote as upheld for the map and finally both the adu ordinance for into districts 3 and 8 passed their First Reading there was 3 introductions last week the first one was for new restaurants and bars in the north beach special district supported pie Julie Christensen and to allow the dialog light displays and sponsored by the mayor and the new citywide transportation sponsored by 3 supervisors that concludes my presentation. Thank you. Before the deserve gets into his summary of the board of appeals those people standing in the room need to find a seat or go to room 416 that is an overflow room youll view those premiers otherwise youre creating a fire hazard thank you thank you. The board of appeals meet last night first there was two appeals related to the project on 1050 valencia the permits for excavation for the valet that goes go the go sidewalks to power the building and the items were not heard two other items presidio avenue was before you the discretionary review at the beginning of the year the board the commission didnt take discretionary review it went to the board of appeals and last night it was approved and lastly on b street that was before you a couple of years ago was brought before you browner inform question of at the hearing the commission took doctor and wanted to commission to work with the staff to reduce the awe illustrate the stair penthouses and reduce the railings that was appealed to the board of appeals after this hearing and the board upheld a permit during the addenda review that he came back with the points they increased the height because of the type of mechanic equipment that was required this was something that was i believe dictated by the review of the permit and dbi our staff approved that and there were concerns by neighborhood we suspended the permit for the addenda i request a release the suspension i issued that was appealed bit the neighbors last time it was uphold and for the concerns of the change that was made during the addenda process ill continue to work with the project manager half a revised to from the 14, 6 now between 11 foot two and 12 foot 8 theyve worked as much as they can and ways to further minimize it and mr. Pacheco served as the legal assistant has moved ton to increase under and victor has a long history of the board of appeals and many of us may have encountered hes a wonderful guy to work be he left last week. Commissioners on behalf of the kroerntd that was a brief meeting at the Preservation Mission on university street the old ladies home was issued for landmarking and commissioners, if theres nothing further well move on to to general Public Comment at this time, members of the public may address the commission to the public that are within the subject matter jurisdiction of the commission except agenda items. With respect to agenda items, your opportunity to address the commission will be afforded when reached in the meeting. Each member of the public may address the commission up to three minutes. I do have two speaker cards. Great, thank you. Georgia and john. Good afternoon, commissioners i have been here before talking about the alterations that are demos in noah valley ill talk about that but i think interest is something that is happening because of that those alterations that are demos a lot of those buildings are doing huge excavations called iceberg calm unfortunately, the area that is taking a hit the mid block open space heres one overhead please this is under construction now you can see all the cement back there because it dug down they have the basement area there the living space the bonus room and this well and upstairs this is all cement this is the close thing to see and the finished one i saw earlier in open house and it is just a patio mates like the easter rabbit grass you get in our Easter Basket that is kind of what is going on this is the blow back of the excavation were losing when i and you call the traditional mid block open space in our residential neighborhoods because in part because of the excavations the marketing is where theyre making the yard part of the house not a william thing you feel nature but well have this sort of extension of the house to charge for this is something ive noticed what i my suggest is the following the 311s needs more details and the plans in the 311s need more detail on the front of the 311 show the Square Footage of the increase sometimes hidden in the plants but hard to find i think the neighbors and you guys need to see that i think youre doing residential guidelines all those things have an are sort of should be looked at introduce the residential guideline performance so any incision you somehow put a hold on the alterations until your staff has the residential guidelines before you and before the neighborhood so we can see what the new residential guidelines are thank you. Good afternoon, commissioners im john your consortium id like to directing your attention this afternoon to the 2050 bryant project in the mission and in particular the proposed categorical exemption from the battle man review the exemptions are intended for projects that clearly are in substantial compliance with the zoning and overall zoning and continued of the district 2050 bryant is the simple largest parcel in the lou lou it is supposed to be a district intended to promote and vibrant mix of used for the formally Industrial Zone area tha this is what it says in our planning code when i look at the numbers youre getting a project that demolishes 65 feet of pdr space existing and provide none in a new project and instead would 98 percent residential now no literate human being in that room in the city or any court can look at those numbers and say therefore this project promotes and a a vibrant use and maintains the vibrant uses clearly clearly this project is a complete opposite of the u zoning is supposed to succeed and deliver we are on the table we dont bluff if this categorical exception is approved by this commission and huldz by appeal in by the board well take it to court it is claerlz not in substantial compliance well take to court we want to set an example that exemptions are not handed 80 out to developers their supposed to mean something the damage is real rule are your 5 m an amendments theyre the best parts of e. R. s but in a month or so clearly there is such a thing some of the pdrs can be are you presently employed and housing built there is objective a mixed use alternative not before you the reason is because theres a categorical exemption that was proposed you turn that project done and make them do it right well talk about a real project there thank you. Any other general Public Comment that is. Good afternoon, commissioners my name is holly friedmans on july 23rd you heard from several of my potrero hill neighbors that stood before i and asked to stoop the explosion without the necessity support of infrastructure im here today to echo those words and ask once again for you to act now a little bit about me, im a Public Transit riders since ive lived in potrero hill my daily continuity from covet to downtown is 50 minutes from thirty minutes thats because of the increase in the number of people using that route and the partial roadway mta add the new line the 55 bus that serves east and west from mission to mission bay not serving the residents when work in San Francisco and ged need to get downtown or need transit for outside of the city to live here in addition that committee the commission reviewed many eirs for Housing Development in potrero hill most of the eirs included transit studies those transit studies youve read recently that have been presented before you that transit is got a grade of f and failing im really trying to understand why the Commission Finds that acceptable and where intersections are currently at a failing grades of f im concerned that this is deteriorating the air quality and the safety of the pedestrians last time i stood before the commission in june, i was here to discuss the eir and provided my comments for 1601 mariposa street is a across from jackson park and surrounds live oak schools many of the commissioners here spoke felt improvements theyd like to see in that development those include the benefits for the potrero hill residents i want to make you windfall