Schmigadoon! Cast Keegan-Michael Key as Josh Skinner; Cecily Strong as Melissa Gimble; Fred Armisen as Reverend Howard Layton; Kristin Chenoweth as Margaret/Mildred Layton; Dove Cameron as Betsy McDonough; Jaime Camil as Doc Lopez; Alan Cumming as Mayor Aloysius Menlove; Ariana DeBose as Emma Tate; Ann Harada as Florence Menlove; Jane Krakowski as Countess Gabriele Von Blerkom; Martin Short as the leprechaun; Aaron Tveit as Danny Bailey Network TV Series Review It’s not really a place where the wind goes whipping down the plain, or where Old Man River just keeps rolling along. You never hear the clang, clang, clang of the trolley or follow the yellow brick road. But for afficianados of classic musicals, the quaint town of Schmigadoon just might feel, and sound, as though it’s made up of your favorite things.