Us threatens to bury the deal. If israel doesnt speed it up, an expert close to the know tend to group explain to us possible reasons of these bad luck. And most of the, these really government is injuring this deal with various maneuver and trying to avoid repeating that your lot shall lead deal that with see them release prisoners. There is no international movement. The pressure is real into implementing an exchange deal. Some sources they told r t that how much is interested in a car in stalemate. The bodies of Israeli Citizens can be used as a bargain shape with israel. And while tug of war continues, the end of golding families suffering is nowhere inside. This is the grave of habit of golding in his hometown cemetery. The grave is here, but the bodys not nobody knows when or if it will be returned home for a proper burial reef nationality resulting from israel and garza so many thanks to as for your company here in o. C international, its always appreciated. Public schools, you know, he was with the latest episode of the 362 and no deductible the according to the president and ceo of ancestry. Com, around a 30000000 people around the world have taken a dna test. And more than 50 percent of the test or ancestry kits, but what happens it to your dna after you get the results you are seeking. Sky. Now, heres an on this edition of 360. 00 view. Were going to look at the rise in popularity of the dna industry and what industries are purchasing and using your dna information. Lets get started. The dna has come a long way over the years. Well, it might be fun to swab for 23 and me to see your family history. These ancestry dna companies have also led to solving crimes. International course might work some so on a tells us some of the biggest mysteries to solved by dna. Well, scotty, it was the kid not being that gripped the globe. A british girl was missing from a family of a case ending port to well, 16 years ago. Modeling. Mccain was just 3 years old. A polish woman julia 1st dina began claiming to be modeling. She began posting photos in february, saying she has a spot in her right eye and a beauty mark on her cheek for assembly the missing mccain. Girl. The biggest claim julia said, details of her child who did not add up, leaving her to believe that she was abducted as a thought here. Even making these claims in appearance on the tv show, dr. Phil. Madeline has this defect in the iris, and you have that same a phenomena, right . Im sorry. Say thats always afraid of. Now i love us. My mother, when i ask her for dna before this whole situation, when i ask her for some fixtures from her pregnancy, so charged with fixtures like mid fi or flights of. And she was just going to finally do like god, her dna results the test. So sees 100 percent, paul is not my the lean mccain. The missing girls parent take on gary mccain and their children have refused to acknowledge julia under claims throughout the entire ordeal. Dna was the answer to a cold case hunting the united states, a string of california rates and murders was attributed to the golden gate here, the case was eventually sold for and that gets later when the may from ancestry websites led to the rest of joseph james the on zillow, the 72 year old, was a former police officer, and during the time of the crime scene 19721980. In 2018. Investigators reviewed the reveal the angelo much the dna of a relative who have taken a non so street test. He must have rested without incident. A local news stations spoke to one of the golden state victims. Shortly after his arrest. I absolutely remember it. I remember the heat of his breath on my neck. I remember his voice. I remember the weight of his body and his knife. I remember i remembered all too much. Mary wart was just a teenager in june 1979. When she fell victims to the golden state, the tutor, she was a slip in her california home. When in the middle of the night, a month in a ski mask, answer her bedroom holding a knife to her throat, tying up her hands and feet and raping her. I dont care these old, im curious, feeble. He, i do care that he sits and lives with it until the day he dies. He just needs to die with the weight of all of the pain of all of the families. The long wants to taylor is responsible for 12 homicides, almost 50 rates on 120 home burglaries and currently spend remote spending multiple life sentences increase on all through the technological power of the me. For 36 of you, im presenting solano back to use good. Wow, lots of information to process there. Thank you so much bucks on it. Now to help us discuss is criminal offense, attorney joseph toley. Joseph totally has over 15 Years Experience practicing criminal law in california and has been certified as a criminal law specialist, but a california board of legal specialization. In addition, mr. Tow, it has been recognized by the National Trial lawyers as a top 100 trial lawyer. Thank you so much for joining us to. Thank you for having me. This is a really interesting topic. You know, if someone chooses to have their dna or genetics tested for personal reasons, what protections are offered to the sample given . Well, youre basically at the mercy of these companies and you have to read the fine print. If the company slips in there, you know, were going to sell your Genetic Information or you, by signing up with us, you give us license to use this. However, we want including cooperating with Law Enforcement and then you, your choice is either to go through the process and if youre curious, you know, you want to do it or, or to not do it. I see lots of options, but i have to wonder how accurate are the commercial dna services. So thats part of the problem here. Is it were talking about this mix of, you know, the criminal law world with the, with the, with the commercial world of, you know, your, your genes. But in a court room, you know, you can, you can cross examine witnesses experts in order for evidence to come into a court room. It needs to past past scientific muster. There, theres a certain legal test that, that the information is scientifically valid. However, in these commercial genetic testing labs, theres no such regulation. So its not designed to provide forensic analysis in court room cases. So its really up to the lab and theres, theres no true regulation of, of whats going on right now. Were, were in the early days of genetic testing, and after the sample is given, whos property is it . It would depend on what the Licensing Agreement is or what the agreement is. Again, we all buy things every day. We buy computers, we buy cellphones, we sign up for facebook, we sign up for instagram, twitter, and in a lot of these things, you know, take talk assignments for this. And all of the services have spike provisions in there. Really theyre, theyre saying look, even if the app isnt on, were going to listen to you. We can sell that information. I mean, we, in the last decade signed up for almost 24 hour monitoring by these, the corporate um, you know, corporate corporations. So here its the same thing with genetic testing. Again, theres no regulation right now. Um, the based on whats going on with the Law Enforcement, you hear a Law Enforcement found this, you know, this suspect or theyve got leads by doing this. Well, thats because theyre allowed to do it. So presumably, these companies are working hand in hand with Law Enforcement because theyre able to do so. Maybe you can help clarify this for me. What are the differences in labs between dna, which is tested by commercial services, or by Law Enforcement and criminal cases. Theres no regulation, so its not the same regulation would bring standards that would bring protocols. And in court theres, theres a test, its called the kelly fried test and its a so it kind of governs what evidence can come into a court room. But before the person who wants to introduce that evidence can presented in court, if the other side objects, then the, the proponent of the evidence has to prove to the court judge this a scientific merit. This is widely accepted within the scientific community. So they dont have to prove that this is the best methodology out there, but they have to prove that its widely accepted and that most scientists within that Peer Community would accept these results. Whereas with these private companies, its literally private companies and the, the labs are not set up in the same way that a lab would be set up for a forensic case in a criminal case. Now, back in 2020 the Investor Firm blackstone acquired ancestry dot com. Weve actually heard relatively little about this acquisition. Since, are you concerned about the security of the data . Which and history dot com owns considering . And blackstone has more than 230 other companies who would find the dna very valuable. Yes, i think youve hit the nail on the head. This is, this is a huge privacy concern. And a lot of times people, you know, and in my experience dont understand privacy, the 4th amendment. I, what do those people youd say, okay, here, give me your wallet. They say, what do you, what do you want . My wallet for one, im going to show it to everybody in the room. Im going to walk around the park this afternoon and just let everybody touch and feel, look through your wallet. People would instantly say no. If you said, hey, give me your cell phone, hey, whats wrong if you have nothing to hide . What are you worried about . But you know, i think kind of putting uh, giving an example where the rubber meets the road is, is really, really critical here. And, you know, again, our, our conversations are being monitored and then thats being sold to people who want to sell a stuff by internet corporations. And it could be the same thing here, where people imagine if theres, you know, predispositions towards diseases or certain types of entertainment, or, you know, we, you could be, you can have your, your genome basically cracked and hacked and they can study it with, with all the money that these, these investor groups have, i mean were talking about deep, deep pockets and they can start specializing, you know, selling data for commercial purposes, not based on your, your web browsing history, but based on your genetic code. I mean think about that. Interesting. Thank you so much, joseph tali. Now after the break, were going to continue this discussion and look at the ethics of dna being collected commercially being used in a criminal process. The, to take a fresh look around. Theres a life kaleidoscopic, isnt just a shifted reality distortion by power to division with no real opinions. Fixtures designed to simplify will confuse really once a better wills. I mean, just as a chosen for you, fractured images, presented to this, but can you see through their illusion going underground can known in vietnam, america was the vietnam war last, its almost 2 decades and dragged in numerous countries. Not any terms we have now, and then you can just say now what did go on empty hundreds of thousands of american troops who was sent to the country to back the south vietnamese on me and the american soldiers murdered, resist as most loosely down, entire villages and spread dangerous chemicals and even lee by all right, did the americans ever fully acknowledge what they did on the vietnamese veterans ready to forgive . Yeah, yeah. Yeah. Thats that way. Its too late. But you know, look forward to talking to you all that technology should work for people. A robot must obey the orders given by human beings, except were so shorter to conflict with the 1st law show you alignment of the patient. We should be very careful about visual intelligence at the point, obviously, is to place a trust rather than ship the job. I mean with artificial intelligence, we have so many with the in the a robot must protect his phone, existence was on the welcome back. You are watching the 360 view. Im a scouting now hughes. Were going to continue our discussion about the value of dna in a criminal court with our guest criminal defense attorney and joseph tali. Joseph, thank you so much for continuing this conversation. You know, i wonder officers can submit dna samples obtained by g. D, match and family tree dna to the only genealogy websites which allow Law Enforcement access to the databases in court. Should dna obtained by commercial services be made accessible and criminal proceedings. So again, theres, theres a push in full to everything and as the years go on we will, this is not figure it out completely, get better at it. So here theres a lot of cold cases, evan solve, i think, the, the brian cobra or case where he is accused of stabbing for College Students in wisconsin. That was solved by genetics. So there, theres a lot of old, you know, cold cases. The brings piece to, to the families, and the bring security to society. On the other hand, were having these, these corporations sell us out or, or be very, very invasive. Again, people wouldnt want to give up their cell phone. Why would they want to give up their, their genetic code . Um, even if you have nothing to hide, its not really whats, what, whats on you. Its really about where it is going and whos going to have it. Can you trust that person . Can you trust that person to act ethically . Do you think that person cares as much about your privacy as you do . Do you think the person cares about the genetic privacy that you have, or the privacy that you have in your own genes in a testing has lied to conviction, but can also prove innocence. Therefore, for someone who is innocent, what did they be favorable to dna testing if they were being charged criminally . Is certainly yes. We have the innocence project, which for decades over a decade now has fried in is innocent people, people who are actually innocent. They didnt do it and genetic testing has freed them. On the other hand, we havent seen some of the, the down sides of the invasion into privacy just yet. And maybe the technology hasnt been there. So that the, you know, people who are holding this could have use it. Again, information has power and getting Genetic Information about someone could lead to having an immense amount of power over them. So, you know, the secret to life is balance. And we have to balance here, privacy versus all the, the wonderful uses that genetic unlocking can bring versus the detrimental benefits or the detrimental, the downsides. So for instance, theres privacy, theres lack of consent. We have accuracy and reliability concerns. And we have instances where this could not only be used against one person, but could be used against people, you know, Group Genetic groups the, what is genetic discrimination . And how do dna testing factor in . So imagine if the Law Enforcement has an incomplete profile and they say, well, we know the killer, the robber, the burglar, the rapist, has, you know, it is a, is a male, is of this racial group. Then the police could go to a certain area and kind of use that as a pretext to kind of start shaking down members of that group, whether they have probable cause or not. Well, you know, we know its this certain group. Theres only, uh, lets say, you know, one percent of that population in this city. Lets go to, you know, where the population is concentrated, and, and start, you know, doing a shakedown, so to speak, that that would be the concern is, is this a craze all over the world, or just in the west . Its happening all over the world. So its generally speaking, i do lots of commentary on, on legal analysis, you know, Supreme Court cases, how, what i tell people is that if you had a bed, you know, i dont have a crystal ball. But if you had a bed bed on the ruling coming down on the side of the concentration of power and less rights to the people, more power of the corporations, more power to the government. Thats the, thats the 40 year trend that were in right now. And based on peoples believes in Walking Around the street and i dont see that ending any time soon. I dont see being a concern of people. I see people accepting it, accepting and accepting it. However, it, at some point, i think it might be a situation where, you know, eating a Sleeping Giant is awakened. Isnt this data being harvested from the 3rd world like it is here in the west and for what purpose . So i think that it is very possible for a more sophisticated, wealthy western corporation to go in to a 3rd world country and work with corrupt leaders, corrupt dictators, who sell out their population for money to these corporations. And then we have the situation that were talking about here. Here we have a very good bill of rights, a very good constitution. You know whats left out of it after you know this, these last 4 years of judges and the Appellate Courts kind of striking it down. But in 3rd world populations and in 3rd world countries, they dont have the constitution that we have and they dont have the mentality of, of, of concepts, of individual liberty. So, um i, i cant speak to any certain countries by name, but i could say that youre really raising an important point that weve seen what corporations do with respect to mining. Weve seen with what corporations do with, with respect to raw materials, with respect to populations in terms of their labor. So this really is a recipe for disaster. And i think that, you know, the important point that youre bringing up is that this is not only a National Discussion for us. This is a global discussion for all of humanity. What regulations or oversight would you suggest need to be established in order to protect individuals in the future . I think we would have to deal with the right of privacy again as the tendency of people in power, whether it be government or corporations is to abuse power in it. And its to grow that power as well. Once you have power, you want to keep growing it. So i think a good model actually is, is our constitution because it says, listen, you cant stop humans from wanting more or acting in their own self interest. So the best way to deal with that is to pick these individual groups against each other so that you have checks and balances. So i think we need rigorous scientific standards. And if we are going to use genetics in, in court, then those labs need to be regulated to the same standard as a forensic lab would be, lets say, in, in, in a county or federal department where theyre responsible for testing evidence and, and bringing it into court so i think, you know, regulating the labs, regulating privacy and perhaps a global bill of rights for all of humanity, recognizing the right to their privacy in terms of their own genetics. Do you honestly believe any of the suggestions will ever be put into place . We either yeah we, we either do that or we have a tier any creeping in more and more and maybe instead of tip toeing, itll start walking and then, you know, jumping then then leaping. So were, were either going to, uh, regulated, or its going to uh, put a chokehold on us and im talking about the whole world. And thank you so much, joseph, totally for joining us to mankind is curious, especially when it comes to information about himself. We look to find out more about our past. Hopefully it will give us answers to questions. We speak about ourselves in the present and possibly help us in the future. Where does my temper come from . Why am i allergic to shellfish . Why do i have warranty or when everyone in my family has bred here, i think most looked a commercial and you get a sites all for innocent reasons. But just like with Everything Else in the present day, once something is deemed extremely valuable, there was an open invitation for corruption. Sadly, something as innocent as wanting to find out your genetic disposition or background can now be used for other purposes. Without any disclosure to the individual. The lack of trust people have not only for the money hungry corporations, but the government, only age and the fear individuals have for the commercial dna industry. Once we realize how powerful our dna information can be. Sadly, we are already behind and creating standards of regulations to protect privacy and individual rights in regards to their own dna. And just like with Everything Else deemed to be lucrative and hold power. I doubt the government. Does it any hurry to correct . Im sky now using this has been your 360 view of the news affecting you. Thanks for watching the the on the bus can do. I just need to get them with key at the washington state. The girls, the computer says to phone up, send this to you for the list of all but huge, but they use the the following x. This from a response begins evacuation a french and a you citizens from nisha, which is being overwhelmed by a cruise and flaw sleep. The russian capital once again comes on the ukranian throat attack using the same building. In most schools. 15 International Business center, which was struck 2 days ago and left a single payments in dollars to the i. M. S. And a new strategy to the dollar wise the economy. Thats according to the 120 in government. If they do that, settlement to the washington face institution, the is very welcome