Transcripts For MSNBC The Beat With Ari Melber 20240709

Card image cap

Think these are dangerous people. They need to be removed from their position of power. General milley needs to resign. If he does not resign, he needs to be fired. There is got to be accountability. The nations top Military Officer feared trumps mental capacity. One of them just two days after the deadly January 6th riot. We are 100 steady. Everythings fine but democracy can be sloppy sometimes. Today the pentagon said they have full confidence in milley backed up by the president. Did General Milley did the right thing . I have great confidence in General Milley. Milley denies this reporting. He stated, he regularly communicated with chief of defense around the world. The pentagon was worried trump would execute a coup. The chairman should be put on trial for treason. My goodness. Joining me now is congressman ted Lu And Daniel gibbs and julio castro. Thank you, for your question, i see it as a jab. What General Milley was referring to was a nuclear bomb. That would be a legal order. Those members do not carry out legal orders. John milley did the right thing by trying to prevent anybody carrying out illegal orders. At the same time the fate of the entire world should not be depend on one general. Thats why i see legislation for years for Senator Markee that would requires authorization before the president of the United States can initiate the first strike. Senator rubio wrote, its a dangerous precedent that could be asserted at any point in the future by General Milley and others. At the end of the day, the president was Donald Trump. Open secret there were so many people in office who considered trump a threat to security of our country and world. It should never have gotten to that point, the fact that he should never have been elected in the first place and we not only address what happened with Donald Trump but as Gavin Newsom reminded us Last Night after he gave a Speech Trump is gone from Office But Trumpism is not dead. We need to do what we can to stamp it out. His Big Lie and this fraud that lends itself to this unbalanced approach in our government. The dangerous president was Donald Trump. So that they are able to take the national Security Apparatus and turn it against our people. Kevin mccarthy really wanted accountability for the tactics of the January 6th community, he would remove Liz Cheney and adam kingsinger. Its easy to talk about this as a rear view but its very much of our president. There are threats on our homeland right now including Terrorist Groups and elected officials using ridiculous language to describe this. I asked Congressman Liu of how dangerous of this disconnect that we are seeing from electives. Its extremely dangerous. Credit to the biden administration for starting to look at whats going on when it comes to white Supremacist Extremism thats formenting in parts of the Republican Party. To hear Matt Gaetz talks about threats of our democracy is laughable. You have the president of the United States making that phone call. That Siren Call continues to blair. Capital police have asked for National Guarder support, are you worried . I am worried. Say one truthful sentence that the election was not stolen. Its a reason that we spend all our resources on January 6th plus now on september 18th, to protect the capitol and members of congress of this outrageous they need to tell the truth to their base. Do you think its that simple, dow think that Hearing It from representatives from members inside the gop is enough to undo, to counter act this false Maga Narrative of what happened on January 6th. I agree its apart of it but its the totality of the undoing that needs to happen. That allows that. Its also going to take frankly, republicans agree on a lot of times is for instance better civic education in our middle schools and high schools. These longer term investments we need to make in our democracy is going to take voting Rights Legislation that democrats need to get past the United States senate. Its going to take a lot of things to come. I want to bring you an excerpt of Mike Pence seeking advice from Dan Quell. Put it away, quell says, i know thats what i have been trying to tell trump, pence said. You have no power. Just forget it. What does it tell you that Dan Quell is his lifeline and what does it tell you that quells big argument to pences that you have no power. Dan quell, i suppose, Mike Pence there is a part of me feels little sorry for him but no, i dont. He knew what he signed up for when he joined Donald Trump and the fact that he was still trying to figure out well, is there a way for me to get out without totally ticking off my boss or maybe sub versing democracy. Representative lieu, you have to power . Having Dan Quell is not on my bingo card. We are in a position now where you have radical republicans, feed a Big Lie that somehow this election was stolen. More than ten months after the election, they still cant tell who stole the election or how it was done. Thats because the election was not stolen. Theyre making this up and i urge republican leaders to stop it because its going to increase a risk of further political violence. Secretary castro, you put all of this together and it begs a bigger question of the rail guards that are necessary for our democracy. You talked a little bit about civic education and you talked about voting rights. When we hear all this retrospectively, how do we make to never get to that point again . Folks need to show up and register to vote and get out and vote. Congress needs to do its job. I know Representative Lieu and so many have. We need to take this seriously. That is cancer on our democracy. We need to make every effort to combat it. I believe a lot of this also is about making sure that our youngest americans understand how precious our democracy is and know how it works and able to sip out truths from lies. Thank you all so much for getting us started. Coming up, powerful testimony from american gymnast about abuse and how the fbi let it happen . This is the largest case of Sexual Abuse in the history of americans sport. It truly feels like the fbi turned a Blind Eye to us. They allowed a Child Molester to go free for more than a year. Big news of the Employer Vaccine Mandate over Fox News. The failure of trumpism in the California Recall, is this a blueprint for democrats elsewhere . Stay with us. Blueprint for demo elsewhere . Stay with us doug . [ding] never settle with power E Trade. It has easytouse tools and some of the lowest prices. Dont get mad. Get E Trade and start trading today. At philadelphia, we know what makes the perfect schmear of cream cheese. You need only the freshest milk and cream. That one and the worlds best, and possibly only, schmelier. Philadelphia. Schmear perfection. Why Bother Mastering something . Why handtune an Audio System . Why include the most advanced active Safety System in its class. Standard . Because when you want to create an entirely new feeling, the difference between Excellence And Mastery is all the difference in the world. The lexus es. Every curve, every innovation, every feeling. A product of mastery. Get 1. 9 Apr Financing on the 2021 es 350. Experience amazing at your lexus dealer. The new Sensodyne Repair and protect with deep repair has the science to show get 1. 9 Apr Financing on the 2021 es 350. That the toothpaste goes deep inside the exposed dentin to help repair sensitive teeth. My patients are able to have that quality of life back. I recommend Sensodyne Repair and protect with deep repair. With less Moderatetosevere Eczema why hide your skin if you can help heal your skin from within. With dupixent adults saw longlasting, clearer skin and significantly less itch. Dont use if youre allergic to dupixent. Serious allergic reactions can occur including anaphylaxis, which is severe. Tell your doctor about new or worsening eye problems, such as Eye Pain or vision changes, or a parasitic infection. If you take asthma medicines dont change or stop them without talking to your doctor. Talk to your doctor about dupixent. Introducing xfinity rewards. Without talking our very own way of thanking you just for being with us. Enjoy rewards like Movie Night specials. Xfinity mobile benefits. And exclusive experiences, like the chance to win tickets to see watch what happens live. Hey its me. The longer youve been with us. The more rewards you can get. Like sharpening your Cooking Skills with a top chef. Join for free on the Xfinity App and watch all the rewards float in. Our thanks. Your rewards. If you dont agree with the party in power, you will be punished. You better get the Vaccine Or Dr. Joe biden is going to unleash the full force of the federal government against you and your Loved Ones and employers. You will be cancelled in society all together and shut out everything. Without Mask Resistance thats what is coming and coming soon. The question is where does it go from there . Where does it go from here . It goes to tucker carlsons employer. Biden is calling for weekly testing of workers who do not get vaccinated. The memo also detailing Foxs System for staffers to tell their company the vaccination status. Over 90 of employees are fully vaccinated. Thats a good thing. Health experts are clear. Vaccines work. Evidently so do mandates. Fox hosts are so in confusion about both. The New York Times reporting on today on hospitals across the south reaching crisis levels. Over 95 of icu beds are occupied. I want to get to all of this with two experts when we are back in 60 sengds. Seconds. Seconds one, two one, two, three only pay for what you need with customized Car Insurance from Liberty Mutual nothing rhymes with Liberty Mutual. Only pay for what you need. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Music playing. Theres an america we build and one we explore one thats been paved and one thats forever wild but freedom means you dont have to choose just one adventure you get both. Introducing the Allnew 3row Jeep grand cherokee l jeep. Theres only one. Joining me now is juanita and dr. Ebony hilton, a Associate Professor at the university of virginia. Its great to see you both. Juanita, you heard me talk about the hypocrisy on fox. Here is one more. You have no right to board a plane if you are unvaccinated. I believe by the way the 1964s civil Rights Act brought through the constitution and the Commerce Clause it was so we can recognize the right of americans to enjoy interstate travel. Juanita, your reaction to that comparison there . Its laughable. Come on. Really . This Fox News host is going to invoke the civil Rights Act . What . I cant even wrap my head around this. The irreputable harm they have done. To find out 90 of fulltime fox employees are vaccinated. My first Reaction Hearing that is i know you are lying. This cant be the truth especially when you have their hosts get out there everyday and make arguments like this one . When their audience is suffering. The data backs it up. Only in the summer, the polling showed that Fox News viewers were 20 points less likely to get vaccinated than msnbc viewers, cnn viewers and abc viewers. We can only imagine what its translating across the country. Fox has really committed to driving this life forward, all for ratings and at the cause of human lives. Its inhumane. Dr. Hilton, of Course Juanita gets it totally right there that the hypocrisy comes at a cause. I mentioned the stress at the icu, what are we seeing on the South Doctor . Very concerning. I would not call It Hypocrisy if it was cavalistic. 11 times less likely to die with the vaccine. If you are looking at per capita, the top five states in the nation right now for new hospitalizations and deaths for covid, literally every single one of those five states is literally by trump. We know what had to happen for that to happen. And so we are seeing, if you are in a state thats led by republicans, if you are in mississippi or florida, you are ten times more likely to die from covid. Its not just adults. When we are looking at children, your challenges are four times likely to be infected. If you are in those schools that have a ban or not mandate masks or vaccines, your child is three times likely to die. Thats what the Republican Party are doing to their base. We look at their families, governor Kents Sister in law died from covid. Joe henson, his wife died from covid and the next week he was at an antivax rally. They are following the science. Does this become a Losing Battle For Republicans and to the point that dr. Hilton was making, do they care . Absolutely a Losing Battle For Republicans. Not only that poll shows it but we saw it in the Referendum Yesterda California with the fail in recall effort. It failed. They do not compare. Dr. Hilton just mentioned theyre willing to sacrifice their own and we know that applies to their broader base of voters. Not only friends and families theyre willing to sacrifice but its their voting base. They have a cap of what they recognize under the Party Leadership of trump they rhetorc is so harmful. No, they dont care. We have republicans running against Vaccine Mandates, and against things we know families are losing their Loved Ones over this pandemic. Theyll lose. Well talk about the California Recall for those of you have not gotten enough of that story. Dr. Hilton, the Washington Post reported a grim milestone of 1 in 500 americans have died from covid19. How critical are Vaccine Mandates to help turn numbers around . Its absolutely critical. At this point if we are looking at literally the number of deaths we had in 2021 verses 2020, we are outseeding ourselves. Its interesting actually to see whos dying and leading to the death of their own base. There was a six to eight times likely chance you are going to die from covid19 if you were black verses white back in april 2020. We are now seeing that number is being twice as likely. I am not saying thats a great thing, we should not have racial health disparity. Its not because black people are dying less but its because white people are dying more. It comes as a cost because we are not seeing the older population dying at the higher rates we are seeing. Its the midrange group. We are seeing 30 or 40yearolds are leaing behind children. We are looking at 120,000 children left to now raise themselves. When you have a vaccine that can keep you alive and keep you out of the icu or being from the ventilator and keep you at home to be able to see your children is simply not worth it. When you read those stories is hard to comprehend. Thank you both. Still to come, Trumpism Trumped Californias recall. New action from the doj, texas Wages War on reproductive rights. And hearing from gymnasts on abuse and the Fbis Failure to act. Stay with us. E and the fbis fao act. Stay with us [triumphantly yells] [ding] dont get mad. Get E Trade. Like many people with moderate to severe Ulcerative Colitis or crohns disease, i was there. Be right back. But my symptoms were keeping me from where i needed to be. So i talked to my doctor and learned humira is the 1 prescribed biologic for people with uc or crohns disease. And humira helps people achieve remission that can last, so you can experience few or no symptoms. Humira can lower your ability to fight infections. Serious and sometimes fatal infections, including tuberculosis, and cancers, including lymphoma, have happened, as have blood, liver, and nervous system problems, serious allergic reactions, and new or worsening heart failure. Tell your doctor if youve been to areas where certain fungal infections are common and if youve had tb, hepatitis b, are prone to infections, or have flulike symptoms or sores. Dont start humira if you have an infection. Be there for you and them. Ask your gastroenterologist about humira. With humira, remission is possible. Regina approaches the allelectric cadillac lyriq. Its a sunny day. Nah, a stormy day. We see a close up of the grille. An overhead shot. She drives hands free. Along the coast. Make it palm springs. Cadillac is going electric. If you want to be bold, you have to go offscript. Reserve your lyriq september 18th. Welcome to allstate. Where you can pay a little less and enjoy the ride a little more. Now, get new lower Auto Rates with allstate. Because better protection costs a whole lot less. Youre in good hands with allstate. Click or call for a lower Auto Rate today. Dont you just love the look on the kids faces. Yea, that look of pure terror. No, no, the smile. And that second right before the first tear comes. What . pizza on a bagelwe can all agree with that. Do you want a hug . Emergency planning for kids. We cant predict when an emergency will happen. So thats why its important to make a plan with your parents. Here are a few tips to stay safe. Know how to get in touch with your family. Write down Phone Numbers for your parents, siblings and neighbors. Pick a place to meet your family if you are not together and cant go home. Remind your parents to pack an emergency supply kit. Making a plan might feel like homework, but it will help you and your family stay safe during an emergency. As astronauts entered the ship. The Threeday Trip will be the first mission on space without astronauts. Msnbc is going to have live coverage on this historic launch and is expected around 8 00 p. M. Eastern time. Trumpism, california voters rejecting the gopled push to recall Governor Newsom. It was not close. It was around 70 of the ballots counted. A big victory for newsom. Newsom saying this. I said this many, many times on a campaign trail. You know you may have defeated Trump But Trumpism is not dead in this country. The real Warning Signs is their failure to slow maga candidates. There are moderate republicans running. Elder had all the oxygen. Dynamic that can spell trouble for purple states. Joining me now, is sochi. Your main take away from this race. This is an embarrassment for trumpism. They saw what newsom did. This is just an example of how Maga And Trumpism is not as strong as it was before. They lost the 2020 election. They lost this recall that california spent millions of dollars on. Potentially states like virginia and new jersey, if anything, this shows how strong the democratic party is and governors are. And how this is looking pretty bad for trumpism moving forward. I would be a Bit Worry and its a huge win for Governor Newsom. He ran on covid and the race was about covid. He mandated mask wearing and cut Covid Protocols and states like Abbott And Desantis who are not taking those steps. I want to read you this piece. Sochi, based on your analysis. Do you think republicans look at what happened in california think okay, we need to rethink our primary strategy. Do they not have the leverage over maga weighing necessarily to do that. There a distinction . The moderates dont control the maga base. Only Donald Trump does. We have seen them trying to primary moderate republicans in a number of states. No, they dont have control over that. I think if they did, you would not see this recall necessary happening in california. You would not see Donald Trump going off and holding rallies. You would not see republican leaders bowing to Donald Trump going and visiting him at maralago. This is a Big Red Flag for republicans. When are they going to take a hold to the party and send a message to the american people. I want to pull up some exit polls. The pandemic was the top issue for california voters saying it was the most important in determining their votes. As you know newsoms handling of covid brought this Recall And Part of what helped him win. How do democrats then plan for that . I think it will show up in 2022. Healthcare is top of mind for voters. They are right in the last midterm election. Thats how democrats won. Healthcare and the economy. Those were the two top issues. Contrast that with republicans who were not. It seems like democrats can make that case with whats happening in texas and florida and you know florida well, there are covid cases that are skyrocketing there and things are not getting better any time soon. Healthcare will be on the ballot but really the pandemic will be on the ballot of a dynamic that played out. A few weeks left, the numbers at that point is not looking promising for newsom and all of a sudden whether or not latino voters have been engaged in this election. You know this is like part of the cycle that you go through every election where all of a sudden people tune back in and its a huge swath of the electorate. Newsom did win latino vetoes by 88 points in latinos heavy district. Whats the lesson there of Investment And Messaging . I have to give it to Governor Newsom and the state of california. The democratic party knows how to mobilize voters and turn them out. They know you need to invest in latinos around. You know this very well. Many president ial elections, you end up showing up to latino to the doors of latino families asking for their votes when you dont have a relationship with they will. You saw Joe Biden invests in them early on and you see outside groups building back together. They are talking to them directly about why president bidens agenda works for them. Thats what Governor Newsom has done. I do think this is a lesson. If you talk to latino Voters Year around, not just in an election year, you can win them over and theyll mobilize and vote. This is a big lesson for democrats. All right, as always, thank you. Ahead a major move from the doj trying to fight a War On Reproductive Rights in texas. First, allegations that the fbi turned a Blind Eye on Sexual Abused victims. Thats next. Xual abused victims thats next. Doug . [ding] never settle with power E Trade. It has easytouse tools and some of the lowest prices. Dont get mad. Get E Trade and start trading today. Here you go, let me help you. Hi mr. Charles, we made you dinner. Ahh, thank you ready to eat . Yes i am we did it again. Verizon has been named americas most reliable network by rootmetrics. And our customers rated us 1 for Network Quality in america according to j. D. Power. Number one in reliability, 16 times in a row. Most awarded for Network Quality, 27 times in a row. Proving once again that nobody builds networks like verizon. Thats why were building 5g right, thats why theres only one best network. Riders, the lone wolves of the great highway. All they need is a bike and a full tank of gas. Their only friend . The open road. I have friends. [ chuckles ] well, he may have friends, but he rides alone. Thats jeremy, right there were literally riding together. He gets touchy when you talk about his lack of friends. Can you help me out here . No matter why you ride, progressive has you covered with protection starting at 79 a year. Well, were new friends. To be fair. Eh, still. Hey google. We gave new Zzzquil Pure Zzzs restorative herbal sleep to people who were tired of being tired. Ive never slept like this before. Ive never woken up like this before. Crafted with clinically studied plantbased ingredients that work naturally with your body. For restorative sleep like never before. Today a powerful and incredibly hearing on capitol hill. Simone biles and Ali Raisman testified of the abuse they suffered at the hands of larry nassar. Damming evidence of the fbi mishandling the case. This is the largest case of Sexual Abuse in the history of american sport. It feels like the fbi turned a Blind Eye to us. I dont want another young gymnast or any individual to experienced the horror that i and hundreds of others have endured before and continuing to this day, of the larry nassars abuse. It comes too late for hundreds of women and girls exposed to sexual predator. I cant tell you how horrifying it is to meet young girls who look up to me, who watched me compete in the olympics and tell me that they went to see nassar because of me and my teammates because they wanted to see the olympic doctor. And i guess in his office, Nassars Office he had photos of us and so they went to see him because they thought it was so cool to have the same doctor as us. And so thats been one of the hardest and devastating parts for me is so many survivors suffered with guilt and shame. These women testifying after years of Public Criticism over everything from their performances to what they have said about their own Mental Health and their facial expressions. Now after years of being silence, maroney of a striking indictment of the Fbi And Everyone who was supposed to protect these young athletes. They chose to lie about what i said and protect a serial Child Molester rather than protect not only me but countless others. I was naked and completely alone of him on top of me molesting for ours. I cried at the memory over the known and there were dead silence. After that minute of silence, he asked, is that all . The truth is my abuse was not enough and they want to cover it up. Not only to minimize my abuse but silence me yet again. They allowed a Child Molester to go free for more than a year. What is the point of reporting abuse if our own fbi agents are taking it upon themselves to bury that report in a drawer. Joining me now is nancy erica smith. We all watched that and we say how does that happen and what does accountability look like from here on end . It was heartwrenching. Law enforcement in the United States including the fbi have a horrible record of not protecting children and women. Very little accountability in Law Enforcement in the United States and especially in the fbi. Juries have repeatedly found the fbi dealt with discrimination and sex cases in their own offices. And the law requires everybody who comes in contact with these kinds of allegations on behalf of children to report it, not only to other Law Enforcement, local Law Enforcement but to Child Protection agencies, none of these people have been prosecuted and they never are. This happens all the time in america and its shocking and horrible. There is no accountability. Langerman just got fired, he was the Head Officer that maroney went to. Abbott, the head of the office he retired. Hes collecting a taxpayer pension today. All of us are paying his pension after he sacrificed these young girls to a pedophile in order to advance his own career. He was seeking a job with the olympic company. Its just disgraceful. So i think what i am hearing from you is that you dont anticipate any criminal charges . I dont anticipate them. If they are coming, they are really, really late. They should have happened a long time ago. I want to get your thoughts on something else. Aly raisman discussing the lasting impact on survivors. I dont think people realize how much experiencing a type of abuses not something that one just suffers in the moment. It carries on with them sometimes for the rest of their lives. Your thoughts . Thats absolutely how my clients feel. Its a lasting hurt. Even hearing this today, many, many women who are survivors of abuse or sexual assaults are hurting. We continue to hurt all of us until we change this. We Cant Change this until we change Law Enforcement and i mean a deep signifiCant Change in Law Enforcement. I think a lot of people watch these incredible athletes who in their own way have a tremendous amount of power and they think if they were not believed then what happens to all of the survivors who dont have the public platform, who dont have the accolades. What does it tell us broadly of the way and we as a Society Treat survivors . Well, it tells us that we value men phenomenally more and men even a pedophile are more valued than women and children. Take a listen to officer wray. I want to be crystal clear, the actions and in action of the Fbi Employee detailed in this report are totally unacceptable. These individuals betrayed the Core Duty that they have of protecting people. Beyond that admission, what is it that you want to see next . I want to see massive over haul of Law Enforcement. I want to see the end qualified immunity for Law Enforcement officers who break the law including not investigating and reporting Child Abuse and crimes against women. I want to see women higher than Law Enforcement. I want all new policies. I want accountability for a change in Law Enforcement. Nancy, i guess my question, what would it take to have this was an incredibly emotional and powerful hearing. The eyes of the nation is on these women. It would seem if not now, when . I agree. Congress should immediately stop qualified immunity for Law Enforcement officers immediately. Our taxpayers pay Law Enforcement officers should be suggested to the same law to the rest of us, they should be hold accountable when they dont protect us. And All The Young girls who followed them after miss maroney in 2015 reported it. How many girls were continued to be raped and abused by this man . All of them. Its the fbis fault. Its just outrageous. There should be a lot more accountability and prosecutions and a total overhaul of Law Enforcement and an end to qualified immunity. No one is above the law and certainly Law Enforcement should not be. Nancy erica smith, thank you so much. Thank you. Ahead of the department of justice made a major move to block texas antichoice law. Thats next. Antichoice law thats next. In its class. Standard . Because when you want to create an entirely new feeling, the difference between Excellence And Mastery is all the difference in the world. The lexus es. Every curve, every innovation, every feeling. A product of mastery. Get 1. 9 Apr Financing on the 2021 es 350. Experience amazing at your lexus dealer. I order my groceries online now. Shingles doesnt care. I keep my social distance. Shingles doesnt care. I stay within my family bubble. Shingles doesnt care. Because if youve had chicken pox, youre already carrying the virus that causes shingles. In fact, about 1 in 3 people will develop shingles, and the risk only increases as you age. So what can protect you against shingles . Shingrix protects. Now you can protect yourself from shingles with a vaccine proven to be over 90 effective. Shingrix is a vaccine used to prevent shingles in adults 50 years and older. Shingrix does not protect everyone and is not for those with severe allergic reactions to its ingredients or to a previous dose. An increased risk of Guillainbarre Syndrome was observed after vaccination with shingrix. The most common Side Effects are pain, redness, and swelling at the injection site, muscle pain, tiredness, headache, shivering, fever, and upset stomach. Talk to your Pharmacist Or Doctor about protecting yourself with shingrix. Shingles doesnt care. But we do. Limu Emu Doug got a couple of bogeys on your six, limu. t care. They need customized Car Insurance from Liberty Mutual so they only pay for what they need. What do you say we see what this bird can do . Woooooooooooooo. We are not getting you a helicopter. Looks like were walking, kid. Only pay for what you need. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Finding new routes to reach your customers, and new ways for them to reach you. Is what business is all about. Its what the United States postal service has always been about. So as your business changes, were changing with it. With ecommerce that runs at the speed of now. Next Day And Twoday shipping nationwide. Same Day Shipping across town. Returns right from the doorstep, and deliveries seven days a week. Its a whole New World out there. Lets not keep it waiting. The doj is seeking an Emergency Halt on texas restrictive new Abortion Law calling it, quote, an unprecedented scheme to deny women and providers the ability to challenge it in court. The doj arguing the law is structured to evade Judicial Review and also enables private people to sue anyone who provides a prohibited abortion. The 19th reporting this has created a chilling effect, causing some providers to stop working in texas. The doj also asserting the law is unconstitutional as well as harmful, highlighting women desperately seeking abortions out of state since the law went into effect, including one minor, raped by a family member, traveled eight hours from galveston to oklahoma for an abortion and another patient, quote, facing violence at the hands of her husband who is selling personal items to scrape together the funds she needs to discreetly leave the state. Joining me now, melissa murray. Melissa, talk me through what the doj is trying to do here. The department of justice is seeking either a temporary Restraining Order or a preliminary injunction that would block the law from being enforced while its constitutionality is being litigated. This is a critical step. This is typically what happens in these challenges to Abortion Laws. It hasnt happened here because of the scheme, the Enforcement Scheme that texas has put in place where it has delegated the enforcement of the law to private citizens. The doj noted in its request for a temporary Restraining Order and preliminary injunction that that was one of the reasons why the United States was uniquely situated to pursue a tro or preliminary injunction here because the state has purposely tried to evade other mechanisms of traditional review. Right. And attorney general garland spoke about the longterm effects of a law like this. Take a listen. This kind of scheme, to nullify the constitution of the United States, is one that all americans, whatever their politics or party, should fear. If it prevails, it may become a model for action in other areas by other states and with respect to other constitutional rights and judicial precedents. So, melissa, he used the word scheme, same word you use, which is exactly what this is and he posited that it could apply to other rights. To which other policies could we see this applied . I think if progressives are trying to play hard ball, youd see in a lot of Blue States the similar private Enforcement Delegation for the enforcement of Gun Control laws or things like that, or to limit the opportunity for individuals to exercise their second amendment rights. You can imagine this working on a lot of different levels. It doesnt solely have to be about abortion. This idea of private enforcement can apply in a lot of different contexts. I think attorney general garland is exactly right, its a slippery slope. If we go down it here, whats to say we wont decide to pursue it in other areas where it may be more advantageous for others with different political leanings. I was talking to a leader in texas who worked specifically on funding for abortions in the Rio Grande Valley and she contended that people have known this is coming and people on the ground have been preparing for what the lived reality of this is going to be as it plays out in the courts and that they all know that the Mississippi Case is happening just sort of right in the shadow of this. For you from your legal perch, where does this Fight Go from here beyond this injunction . This case is going to go back to the Supreme Court in some fashion. It will likely go back to the court probably roughly contemporaneously with the courts hearing oral arguments in that Mississippi Case, which is slated to happen in this upcoming Supreme Court term. But right now there will likely be a series of interlocutory appeals from the doj and then well have the rest of the Enforcement Actions if the law is continuing to be enforced happening on the ground in texas. So this is not the last well hear of this. I think we have a long road ahead. Maybe the court will forestall all of this by deciding the Mississippi Case in some fashion, but theres a lot here to dig into for the next couple of weeks and months. You heard some of the stories that i was sharing that the doj chose to share about, you know, women traveling across State Lines for abortions. There were stories about minors seeking parental consent. Explain to us from a legal Vantage Point why those stories are necessary to make a compelling and cogent argument. Well, its actually very unusual in this doj brief. Typically in a tro or preliminary injunction you want to establish if you haves movent that you are likely to prevail on the merits and there will be irreparable harm if the Tro Isnt granted. So i think those stories go to the irreparable harm on the ground to the women in texas who will be foreclosed from getting the care that they need. To have this being made by the department of justice, usually these kind of claims are made by providers. It is unusual to have the force of the United States speaking on behalf of pregnant persons in texas who are trying to exercise their constitutional rights. Supreme Court Justice Amy Coney Barrett made headlines for saying the Supreme Court justices arent, quote, partisan hacks. Your take. Well, i certainly hope that thats the case. I think her statement is probably undermined somewhat by being on the same podium as Mitch Mcconnell while she was making it, so the optics of it werent fantastic. But i think the sentiment we hope is one that we all can subscribe to. All right. Melissa murray, as always, thank you so much for your time. That does it for me. Be sure to watch my show this weekend, American Voices On Saturdays And Sundays from 6 00 p. M. To 8 00 p. M. Eastern right here on msnbc. The reidout with Joy Reid is up next. Joy . Good evening. Thank you very much, alicia, have a wonderful evening. Good evening, everyone. We begin tonight with a message to republicans. Okay, we get it covid is the precious and you love it. You love covid so much you want it to spread into schools, in the office, in the walmart, on the Cruise Ships and at the club. That great spongy ball with the red spikes, you want it pumping through your veins with an ivermectin chaser. Why do you love it so much . We have absolutely no bloody idea. But heres the thing, you weirdos. Everyone else, Everyone Else hates covid. It is ravaging classrooms and hospitals across the nation like in Southern Illinois where Zero Icu Beds are available. Similar shortages are happening all over the south, including in alabama where a Mans Family said he died after being turned away from 43 hospitals. While in south carolina, 20 children need critical care due to covid19. You see this beautiful couple . They both died in their 30s from covid, leaving behind five kids, including a newborn daughter. So yeah, the rest of us hate that this is happening. Even the pope. The pope hates covid too, and he loves everybody. He also says get vaccinated. You, you republicans seem to be aokay with covid running wild. And then you came for california. Trying to boot a democratic governor from a

© 2024 Vimarsana

comparemela.com © 2020. All Rights Reserved.