All the tourists have returned doing what they do walking slowly down the Sidewalk Right in front of you even though some of the seats are wet the subway is still packed and i know new York Citys coming back good Morning And Welcome to Morning Joe. It is tuesday, september 14th. And i think Jimmy Fallon has really captured new York City. Oh, yeah. No doubt, willie. So first of all, i like Bill De Blasio. Come on p. I love Bill De Blasio. Sorry. And the jets, the Punch Line is always, willie, and, of course, a line lifted there from marty scorsese. Its a great special on netflix. Pretend its a city. Just walk around and pretend its a city like people actually go to work here. Love that it is. Listen, there is moisture on the seats in the subway. I can report. Theres strange smells emanating from those platforms. Its really happening. Its really coming back. Late Summer Humidity brings up some of those scents and reminds you of the greatness of new York City. Cant wait. Were coming next week again. Its wonderful to be in New York. Weve got a lot happening this morning with a Big Red Circle around Todays Date on the calendar in california. The state is deciding whether Governor Gavin Newsom should be removed from office with newsom seemingly surging. Republicans who wanted the recall in the first place are now claiming you guessed it Voter Fraud. What idiots. Lets just say undemocratic idiots. Speaking of false claims about it, former supporters of President Trump have plans to be back in washington for a rally defending the insurrectionists. How the Capitol Police are preparing for that. And in just a few minutes, dr. Anthony fauci joins the conversation. Were going to talk about Vaccine Mandates, what Booster Shots might mean for the fight against covid. Were getting ours today. And how the new School Year is going with many kids now back in the classroom for the first time in 18 months. A lot to talk to him about. I want to ask him about the potential of a Monster Variant and the Breakthrough Cases were seeing. Some of them are really bad. We have white House Reporter for the associated press, jonathan lemire, Katty Kay is with us and cofounder of punch bowl news, jake sherman. Today is the day. California voters will decide to keep Gavin Newsom or not as their governor. President Joe Biden was in california Last Night campaigning alongside newsom. Biden encouraged residents to vote no in the gubernatorial recall. And battling a bit of a cough, connected the newsoms top opponent in the recall with Donald Trump. You either keep Gavin Newsom as your Governor Or Youll get Donald Trump. Its not a joke. Republican governor blocking progress on covid19 who is also antiwoman, antiworker, Climate Denier who doesnt believe in choice. The choice should be absolutely clear. Gavin newsom. You have a governor who has the courage to lead and gavin, you have a governor who shares the states values. In gavin you have a governor who makes sure Donald Trumps dark, destructive, divisive politics never finds a place in california. We may have defeated Donald Trump, but we have not defeated trumpism. Trumpism is still on the ballot in california, and thats why its so important not just for all of us here, 40 Million americans strong in the nations largest and most populous state, but also to send a statement all across the united states of america that trumpism has no place here and trumpism will be defeated all across the united states of america because were better than that. Governor new som there. The leading republican Frontrunner Larry Elder appealed to his followers to use an online form to report fraud. Claimed to have detected fraud in the results of the california Recall Election. Results in Gavin Newsom being reinstated. When the link was live on his site, the Election Hasnt happened yet. Elder was still out campaigning. Hours after Nbc News contacted the Elder Campaign about the site, a disclaimer about his campaign having funded the site was added. In an interview with nbc yesterday, elder refused to say whether he would accept the results of the Recall Election. Whether or not you win or lose, will you accept the results of the Election Tomorrow . I think we all ought to be looking at Election Integrity, whether you are a democrat, republican or independent. Lets make sure the election is a fair election. Lets all work together to make sure that the results are valid and legitimate and everybody who Vote Shd Have voted. Lets all do that together. S. That a commitment to accept the results of the Election Tomorrow. Lets all work together to make sure that the election is a fair election. This is what many people feared after Donald Trump stoked the flames about the 2020 election that republicans would use that as a model for any election that looked like they were going to lose. The polling has Larry Elder and all the other challenges far behind. Gavin newsom has opened up some space. Now before the votes have been cast, many of them, before the ballots have been counted, claims of Voter Fraud to explain away a potential election loss. What whiners. What losers. I mean, these poor little snowflakes are going around every time it looks like theyre going to lose an election, they say, oh, the election got stolen. They cheated. Seriously . This is elemental. You tell your kids when they are playing a game to play as hard as they can play it and then when the game is over, shake the other Teams Hand and be a good loser. And here we have one after another after another republican just whining. It is i guess it is their strategy. They understand, especially in places like california, that their policies are just extraordinarily unpopular. They are on the wrong side of so many issues. They are on the wrong side of Vaccine Mandates. They are on the wrong side of Overturning A constitutionally protected right in the state of texas that 70 of americans say they dont want overturned. They are on the wrong side of issue after issue. They are on the wrong side of January 6th. Theyor the wrong side of investigating the insurrection. They are on the wrong side of just about everything. So what do they do, Katty Kay . They, of course, they act like the illiberal leader of hungary. A person a lot of conservatives are praising now. They love the fact that orbat shut down any criticism from The Press. Love that hes basically taken control of the courts. Love that its no longer a democrat. Its no longer a westernstyle democracy there. Thats what republicans want in california. Thats what republicans want across the united states. Elections are only valid if they win. Yeah, certainly what Tucker Carlson wanted when he went to hungary earlier this year. Its not what youd think of as an americanstyle democracy, whats happening in hungary or in poland for that matter either, but claiming that the election was rigged before the election has even happened has taken things to a new low in california, but it is exactly Donald Trumps playbook. He spent the whole year before the election saying this is going to get rigged. The same way he told his supporters from the beginning, The Press is the enemy of the people. Youre undermining the freedom of The Press. But it gives your supporters up for when you lose to be able to turn around and say, well, either the media was against us, thats what people used to say when they lost. Now they have taken it one step further. Candidates in the trump mode. The election was actually stolen from us. Youll not see the same outcry across california because hes so far behind in the polls. Interesting republican party in california is unlikely, i think, to behave the same way the trump supporters did on January 6th here in washington, d. C. , but its certainly a model if taken from Donald Trumps playbook. And i guess trumplike candidates are going to keep using that when they go into elections and start spreading it before the election happens so they can gear themselves up for the result afterwards. More news happening right now. Moments ago, democrats in the senate unveiled an updated Voting Rights bill. The freedom to vote act is backed by a Group Of Eight senators, including senator Joe Manchin of west virginia. The bill is an updated version of a framework released by Senator Manchin earlier this year. The legislation is split into three sections. Voter Access And Election administration. Election integrity and civic participatiOn And empowerment. Democrats want to act fast. Majority Leader Chuck Schumer said hell call a vote by next week. Republicanled war on democracy has only worsened in the last few weeks. Most notably, the governor of texas recently signed into law vile new Voter Suppression Bill that ranks as one of the most draconian and undemocratic. Partisans are sharpening their knives for a coming spate of vision gerrymandering. This is unacceptable. So the senate must act. I intend to hold a vote in the senate as early as next week on voting Rights Legislation. Time, time is of the essence. Of course, if theyre going to cure gerrymandering or at least do their best to fix it if theyre going to implement a lot of these other changes, democrats still need ten republicans to join them in moving the bill forward. And the fact that, you know, the reauthorization of the civil Rights Voting Act in 2006 almost passed unanimously but you cant even find one republican to vote for these Voting Rights Bills should tell us that were still, whether its Manchins Bill or somebody elses bill, were still a long way from this passing unless theres some major Filibuster Reform. Yeah, joe, at the Risk Of being yelled at on twitter all day, this is a press release. I mean, yes, its important that democrats got 50 of their own lawmakers around this compromise, which was done by Amy Klobuchar and Joe Manchin. They are still, as you know, 10 republicans short of getting this across the Finish Line in a republican conference where not one republican that ive spoken to or that ive found believes that anything like this is necessary. So theyre not even singing from the same song sheet. Theyre not working from the same set of facts, and unless there is some action to rework the filibuster which Joe Manchin and Kirsten Sinema have said theyre not interested in until their eyes bled, this is just going to be a vote that shows all democrats are on the same page but this is no closer to law in any shape or form. Jonathan lemire, is there any chance that after Joe Manchin is allowed to put out his bill and to do all the things that he thinks needs to be done and if the republicans run over him again, just like the republicans ran over him on the January 6th commission, that he will work with the White House and others to put together a Filibuster Reform package at least for civil rights bills that will do the same thing for civil rights bills that Mitch Mcconnell did for Supreme Court nominees . There is a chance, joe. Talks have intensified behind the scenes at the White House. Senior aides say that though no final decision has been made, theres growing momentum within the chorus of the West Wing and in the Oval Office to support some sort of Filibuster Change and work with those senators who have been resistant to that. Manchin chief among them but not alone. He often, as we know, is sort of the face of a group of more, quote, moderate democratic senators who have been resistant to perhaps, say, the size of the Reconciliation Package or any change to the filibuster. But, y as jake says, this is this plan here is a press release. It doesnt really stand any chance of actual passage. We have no weve heard from the president , both publicly and hes said privately to his closest advisers that he is not in support of a full abolition, a full removal of the filibuster, but is amenable to some sort of change, an amendment to it. A tweak to it. Perhaps making it a Talking Filibuster which makes it more difficult to use or use something sort of exception. Changing it for a certain topic. And as he has said, the Voting Rights, the greatest threat to the democracy since the civil war, and there have been discussions now, going to let this play out over a couple more weeks but then, yes, we may see more talks about trying to make that exception to get something out there to protect Voting Rights. They are also working on paying for these big, big bills they are talking about. Trillions of dollars. Democrats in the house presented a Plan Yesterday to pay for their Social Policy and climate Change Package by raising taxes by more than 2 Trillion, largely on wealthy people and profitable corporations. But this morning, the New York times reports that plan, quote, stopped well short of changes needed to didnt the vast fortunes of tycoons like Jeff Bezos and Elon Musk or to thoroughly close the most egreejuous loopholes exploited by highflying captains of finance. Senior house democrats opted to be more mindful of moderate concerns in their party than of its progressive ambitions. The focus on traditional ways of raising revenue, raising Tax Rates on income rather than targeting wealth itself. The times continues, the bill dispenses with measures floated by the white House And Senate democrats to Tax Wealth or close off avenues that the Superrich Have exploited to pass on a lifetime of gains to their heirs taxfree. Democrats caution the proposal is likely to change. This is just out of one committee as it makes its way through congress. So the top marginal Tax Rate is proposed to be raised to 39. 6 from 37 . But that, as you know, doesnt get at the way these superwealthy and corporations make their money and avoid taxes. And we see it every year. I dont understand whats going on when you have the people writing the Tax Bill for the democrats. They are concerned about moderates concerns. What . Do they want Jeff Bezos and amazon to keep paying Zero Dollars . Is that a moderate concern or is that actually a Lobbyists Concern . Because over the past few years, there are corporations that have paid zero taxes in a year and just over the past couple of years, that includes amazon, chevron, avis, delta, eli lilly, gm, goodyear, halliburton, honeywell, ibm, netflix, ox occidental petroleum, fedex, nike, On And On And on. Are moderates really concerned that those corporations may actually have to pay millions of dollars in taxes . Right now theyre paying zero. And billionaires are continuing to figure out how to pay little or nothing. Hedge fund titans are paying taxes at lower rates than their clerical employees, the people who chauffeur their bentleys. You think Thats Demagoguery . You think thats no, its not. Thats the fact. Billionaires capital, it doesnt get taxed. Workers wages do. And so now democrats in congress are saying, we need to raise the taxes on people who are working but leave billionaires alone as they continue to amass capital and continue to listen to me here. Listen to me here. Because everybody hates Income Redistribution. That makes you a socialist, doesnt it . If you are for a scheme that redistributes wealth. Well, let me tell you something. And the World Weve lived in over the past 40 years theres been the largest Income Redistribution scam in american history. And its been the Middle Class thats been looted while trillions keep flowing into the Bank Accounts of billionaires. Did you hear what i just said . Did you hear what i just said . This whole Income Redistribution thing we keep oh, you Cant Raise taxes on people. Because that will be Income Redistribution. Youre a socialist. Well, Guess What. The very people who are saying that, the very people who are funding Think Tanks that will say that, the very people that are paying lobbyists to get the message out to say that, the very people who are spending millions and millions of dollars on lawyers and lobbyists on K Street who are saying that. They are the people who have scammed you. They are the people whose monopolies continue to be untouched. They continue to be untouched all because they can buy the best lobbyists, they can buy the best lawyers, they can buy the best influencers on Capitol Hill across washington, d. C. , and across wall street. Please, please, democrats, do better than that. Tax capital. Take a dent on these super wealthy billionaires who keep accumulating, keep amassing fortunes. Because youre just i mean, when youre taxing income a little bit more, 2 here, 3 here, you are missing the target. If you want to make this country a fairer place if you want to get us back to where we were before where there wasnt just such massive divergence between the super wealthy and the rest of uyou have to rewrite your Tax Plan because that one is just lousy. Weve seen the super wealthy akimulate fortunes through capital. Capital accumulation thats not taxed or taxed at extraordinarily low rates. While people who work for a living, people who have an income keep getting taxed at higher rates every year. Yeah, its kind of stunning that this is not a bigger conversation here in washington, and amongst the democratic party that taxing dividends and taxing capital, taxing wealth rather than income is actually the way youre going to make some kind of dent on whats been rapidly growing inequality in this country. And you have had people like Warren Buffett over the years who have said this has to stop. Warren buffett one of the super wealthy people in this country has said youve got to go after wealth. You have to go after dividends because its just not fair that he is paying, as he says, less than his secretary is paying in terms of taxes. And when you keep fiddling around with the marginal rate on incomes going from 37 to 39 , youre just not going to get there. You will squeeze those people who are wealthier, who are taking back 400, 500, 600,000 a year. Those families. But youll not touch the billionaires who dont have income. Their money comes from their wealth and dividends on their wealth, not on their income. Whats the political calculus of democrats to say, we dont want to upset the moderates. We dont want to make amazon pay taxes. We dont want to make ibm pay taxes. We dont want to make these super corporations pay taxes. Well just raise taxes on Small Business Owners who make 400,000, 500,000. Well, so they would say they are forcing those businesses to pay taxes. Theyve raised at least marginally the corporate rate from 21 to i think 25 or 26. But, listen, i think its more of a vote counting problem, joe, than anything else in a and its frankly my estimation is the House Of Representatives where they only enjoy a fourseat majority, and any step out of line, so to speak, any step away from the Lower Common Denominaor can provide Vote Problems. They have Vote Problems everywhere. They have enough problems right now on things from Prescription Drugs to s. A. L. T. Deductions, state and local tax deductions. So many Trip Wires for Nancy Pelosi and Chuck Schumer that anything out of the mainstream, so to speak. Not out of the mainstream but currently envisioned Tax Plan, is just not going to fly, i think. And i want to say just one more thing here. Ive noticed in the last couple of months, and this bolsters your argument. Republicans are actually no longer even talking about raising taxes as being the central Focus Point of this plan because they realize, ive talked to a lot of republicans about it, that it no longer plays to talk about raising taxes. That the spending is actually the more potent political argument for republicans. So that bolsters your contention that this is actually no longer an unpopular proposition to be raising taxes on super wealthy and corporations. So that is new because for the last 20 years since you were in congress, i would say that the Tax Argument was a much more potent argument for republicans. If i were campaigning in any congressional district in any district across america, i would love my opponent, republican or democratic, to stand up and say, i dont think we should make amazon pay taxes. Hey, i really dont think we should make billionaires stop being able to build up their loopholes to continue this redistribution of income from Middle Class americans to the super wealthy. Jake, i saw you wanted to get in earlier as we were moving on to the next story when we were talking about Voting Rights, Joe Manchin and talking about exceptions to the filibuster. And the question i had asked was, why wouldnt we get to a point at The End where Joe Manchin and Joe Biden and democrats decided that, yes, they could make an exception for civil rights the same Way Mitch Mcconnell made an exception for Supreme Court justices. Yeah, so i just think that its a lot more im not saying that wont happen or that jons reporting was wrong. I think there is an increasing in the White House, increasing appetite to do something on the filibuster. I dont doubt that. I just think that it will be from a technical point of view, its very difficult to end the filibuster on one thing. On the legislative calendar and not for other things. Once theres a theres not a way in the senate rules from the people that ive spoken to who are pro Filibuster Reform even, to end the filibuster for civil Rights Legislation, not for other legislation. You said republicans changed the filibuster for nominees, they did. But thats on a different calendar. Thats the executive calendar, not the legislative calendar. Tough to explain. Probably doesnt matter for many people who care about Voting Rights. Its just a technical argument that i think once the filibuster is blown up and manchin understands this, and i think will come around to this argument. Once its blown up for one topic, it will be blown up for every topic. And on the Talking Filibuster, manchin has said hes not for changing the 60vote threshold. Hes fine with making people talk but at The End of that, he still wants 60 votes. Thats a distinction without a difference. If you make people talk but still need 60 votes to cut off someone from talking, its not a huge difference from what we currently have in the senate. So i just think the theres a long path, if theres a path at all, to changing the filibuster. All right, guys. Well obviously come back to this. Now to weather. Overnight Hurricane Nicholas Made Landfall along the texas coastline. The storm was downgraded to a tropical storm about an hour ago. But there is still major concern over flooding. Lets go to Meteorologist Bill karins for the latest on this. Mika, pretty incredible that weve had 19 storms make landfall in the last 17 months. And that includes ten hurricanes. So just a storm after storm after storm once we get into this hurricane season. This one did intensify after landfall. 95mileperhour winds recorded on the texas coast. This will actually have a Storm Surge probably around four to five feet. Not enough to do a ton of damage but still over 300,000 people without power right now. So let me show you the latest from the hurricane center. The storm is almost over the top of houston right now. We were very afraid of the Heavy Rainfall in the Houston Area. Especially this morning. But the storm shifted a little bit more to the east. For louisiana, that means all of the Heavy Rain is now heading towards you as we go throughout the next two to three days. The last Thing Louisiana needs because theyve been hit the hardest over the last two hurricane seasons. Flash flood warnings south of houston around galveston. The Flash Flood watch includes almost all of the southern half of Louisiana Into Southern Mississippi and alabama. About 10 Million people included. Look at the rainfall thats heading for New Orleans. Were expecting up to 10 inches of rain possible from Lake Charles to new iberia to New Orleans and Heavy Rains in southern mississippi and even alabama. This will be pretty incredible over the next couple of days as we watch the storm slowly drift towards the New Orleans area. It does not look like we have any problems whatsoever with the winds in these areas. The winds have been light as weve been going throughout the last, id say, the last 12 hours or so. Theyve been very light in areas especially louisiana. Look at Lake Charles only 20mileperhour gusts. The highest gusts are near the Houston Area around 40 to 50 miles per hour. Most of the Power Outages from houston southwards down to the coastal areas. I do not expect a lot of additional Power Outages as we go throughout the remainder of the storm. You can see on the latest close in radar, the Houston Area, the heaviest rain is over the next hour or two. But the poor people from Lake Charles to beaumont, its going to pour all morning long. Be very careful driving anywhere on Interstate 10 through louisiana during the Day Today. Just ridiculous, mika. The tenth Hurricane Landfall in the last 17 months in the united states. Crazy. All right, bill karins, thank you so much for keeping us posted on all of this. Still ahead on Morning Joe, a look at how security is being ramped up around Capitol Hill ahead of a far right rally this weekend protecting and rallying for the people who attacked the capitol. Plus, dr. Anthony fauci joins our conversation amid surging covid cases among children. Before we go to break, were excited for joes new podcast which debuted Today Way more joe, a side of him you dont see. And youll not believe who his first guest is going to be. Its a big get. Thats all ill say. Huge. Biggest in the 47 years that weve been doing this podcast every day. This is, i think, the biggest guest. But absolutely check it out. Listen to the Joe Scarborough Podcast on spotify, Apple Music or wherever you get your podcasts. Well be right back. We are hoping things will pick up by q3. Yeah. Uh. Doug . [ding] never settle with power E Trade. It has easytouse tools and some of the lowest prices. Dont get mad. Get E Trade and start trading today. As someone who resembles Someone Else. I appreciate that Liberty Mutual knows everyones unique. Thats why they customize your Car Insurance, so you only pay for what you need. Oh, yeah. Thats the spot. Only pay for what you need. Liberty, liberty, liberty, Liberty My Nunormal . Fewer Asthma Attacks with nucala. A oncemonthly addon injection for severe eosinophilic asthma. Nucala reduces eosinophils, a key cause of severe asthma. Nucala is not for sudden breathing problems. Allergic reactions can occur. Get help right away for swelling of face, mouth, Tongue Or Trouble breathing. Infections that can cause shingles have occurred. Dont stop steroids unless told by your doctor. Tell your doctor if you have a parasitic infection. May cause headache, Injection Site reactions, back pain, and fatigue. Ask your doctor about nucala. Find your nunormal with nucala. You booked a spacious vrbo summer home, with a pool big enough for the most epic cannon balls. But the Thing Theyll remember forever . The first of many vacations with their nephew. The time for getting back together is now. Find it on vrbo. In business, its never just another day. Its the big sale, or the big presentation. The time for getting back together is now. The day where everything goes right. Or the one where nothing does. With Comcast Business you get the network that can deliver Gig Speeds to the most businesses and advanced cybersecurity to protect every device on it all backed by a dedicated team, 24 7. Every day in business is a big day. Well keep you ready for whats next. Comcast business powering possibilities. Cases of pediatric covid19 are surging across the country. More than 243,000 child cases were reported last week. Making 500,000 over the past two weeks. Thats the backdrop as millions of children head back to school. Many of them walking inside a physical classroom for the first time in at least 18 months. Nbc news correspond Stephanie Gosk has more. Reporter with excitement and some fanfare, new York City kicked off a new School Year. Despite the masks, it feels like a normal first day of school. We even have the Marching Band here. Kids are a little nervous, Excite Bud Unlike last year, families do not have the option for remote learning. Everyone is back in class. On top of a Mask Mandate, there will be Air Purifiers in every classroom and social distancing of at least three feet when possible. Teachers and staff have to be vaccinated. Measures that have put some parents, especially those with unvaccinated little ones, at ease. I trust the school completely. They are ready for this. They need this. All the kids do. Rehema ellis found one third grader who may need some convincing. Just a little nervous. Are you nervous about what youre going to learn . Are you nervous about having to wear a mask . Reporter in New York, the opening of schools was timed to the enforcement of tougher vaccine rules. I just need to see your proof of vaccinatiOn And a photo i. D. Everyone who wants to eat inside go to the Theater Or Gym will have to show proof of vaccination. Were trying to be as prepared as possible and anticipating slowdowns at the front door but guests seem to be getting used to it. Reporter at this manhattan restaurant, tables are still getting filled. People are continuing to be increasingly comfortable with the extra safety. Reporter covid cases have started to dip but there are hot spots where hospitals are struggling like in idaho where in some cases, patients are waiting in conference rooms. Were just in a terrible time of the pandemic right now. And i would hate to see it get any worse. Reporter in pennsylvania, multiple schools have gone to remote learning. One district closing two of its schools dealing with a previously unimaginable number of students with covid. Around the country, the number of pediatric infections is high with some parents eager to vaccinate their young children. Vaccine approval for 5 to 11yearolds could come as early as this fall, according to the Cdc Director who shared this advice on the today show. Surround our younger kids by people who are vaccinated. Masking in the schools, ventilation, screening, testing. Those strategies work. Some new polling about this showing a majority of americans support President Bidens sweeping plan for large u. S. Companies to require employees be vaccinated according to the latest Morning Consult politico poll. 58 are in support of Vaccine Mandates for companies with at least 100 workers. But there say massive partisan divide. 82 of democrats support the Vaccination Requirement but only 33 of republicans do. Overall, most americans also support other major pieces of the President S plan to increase covid vaccinations. 62 of americans in this poll are in favor of encouraging states to require vaccination for all school employees. 60 support a Vaccination Mandate for most Health Care workers without the ability to opt out through regular testing. And 56 support the same rule for most federal workers and contractors. Meanwhile, floridas republican governor Ron Desantis says his state will punish County And City governments which require employes get vaccinated against covid19. Desantis Threatening A 5,000 fine for each violation, joe. Similar to what hes been threatening in School Districts that want to mask their kids. Yeah, hes microtargeting. Hes playing for the 30 . Hes doing what Donald Trump did in 2015 when he kept talking about the wall. Kept talking about immigration. If you looked at Donald Trumps immigration policies, 60 of americans opposed them. 30 supported them. But Donald Trump rode that all the way to winning the republican nominatiOn And then in 2016 snuck in to the presidency. And won the presidency. And you just look at the stories weve been talking about today. Ive been talking about how democrats and republicans are on different sides of so many issues. And usually its the democrats 60 side. Its the republicans on the 30 side, but mika, its getting clearer by the day that the goal is take minority positions, whether its on Vaccine Mandates, whether its on Mask Mandates, whether its on abortion in texas and stopping a constitutional right because of a procedure. Go ahead and take those positions. Win your primary. Then just try to figure out how you change the voting rules. And if things look bad, start screaming like Larry Elder in california. Start screaming and whining like a little snowflake, like all republicans do when they lose an election, and talk about it being rigged. Thats their new formula for running their political party moving forward. Not actually siding with scientists. Not siding with doctors. Not siding with their own family doctor, but instead, picking up bits and pieces from, oh, i dont know, facebook pages where their lies are maybe chinese conspiracy websites. But that is actually the path theyre going down. And theyll pay politically in The End. Its not only infecting our politics but its helping this Virus Spread because if theres just one person inspired by these politicians not to get the vaccine or not to mask, here you go. Joining us now, director of the National Institute Of Allergy And Infectious Diseases and chief medical adviser to the president , dr. Anthony fauci. Dr. Fauci, thank you so much for being with us. A lot to get to. We want to talk about children and the start of school. I just want to pull back a little bit about where this virus could go. Im hearing anecdotedly about Breakthrough Cases that are really serious that end up with people being on ventilators. These are people who were vaccinated but still got covid. What is the potential that this spirals beyond delta to Monster Variant . Well, theres always a Risk Of, as you get more circulation of virus in the community, that youll get enough accumulation of new mutations to get a variant that is functionally different than the ones were seeing now. Delta has the capability, unlike alpha, of transmitting extraordinarily readily and Effic Unitunitly from Person To person, thats the Reason Weve seen that surge that weve been through over the last few months where we went from 11,000 cases a day up to 150, 160,000 cases a day. One of the reasons why we want to make sure we get as many people vaccinated as we possibly can is that viruses will not mutate if they dont have the opportunity to spread and replicate. So the more dynamics of viral activity you have in the community, the greater opportunity you give to the virus to mutate. So its one of those things that youre vaccinating now to prevent the next mutant coming, the next variant from coming and again thats yet again another reason, besides protecting the health of the people who are getting vaccinated, protecting the community. You dont want to see more variants coming in because then it would, in many respects, negate some of the very positive protection that you get from the vaccines. Isnt it also about protecting our children under 12 who still cant get the vaccine . The delta can spread among children. The transmissibility, as you just said is far worse than the first phase of covid. It really, really, it spreads quickly and its an incredibly terrible experience if its survivable. How do we address this with children going to school, even if they are wearing masks. Is that enough at the rate were going . Well, you just said something that is really one of the fundamental principles of Vaccine Protection of the community. When you have vulnerable people who either are not yet eligible for vaccines, the way many of our children, 11 years old and younger, who are in the school system, they are vulnerable. The way you protect the vulnerable is to surround them by people who are vaccinated. Be they teachers, personnel in the school, students in the school, who are old enough to get vaccinated. For example, those who are 12 years old and older. Thats a fundamental public Health Principle of how you protect vulnerable people is you surround them with vaccinated people. Dr. Fauci, its willie geist. Good morning. I want to ask about boosters. There was that new study that came out yesterday. Im sure you saw published from Public Health experts in america and Around The World that said boosters at this time for otherwise healthy people are not necessary and they went so far as to say may be unethical given the fact so many places in the world still need all these doses of the vaccine. What is your position on boosters right now. Should healthy people, not people who are at risk, who do need the boosters, but should otherwise healthy people be getting the booster . Yeah, willie, thats a great question. And with regard to that article, thats a controversial article that i actually disagree mostly with. There are a couple of aspects that get conflated in that article. Certainly, if you have countries, low and middle income countries that dont have any vaccine and you make no attempt to get them vaccine and only focus on boosting individuals who are in your own country, that is not the right thing. And i disagree with that. However, you can do both. The way were doing in this country. You can have a program to give booster, in this case, third shots for people who have gotten the Twodose Moderna and pfizer vaccine. You can get them boosted if you put a considerable amount of resources and effort into getting low and middle income people vaccinated. And thats exactly what were doing. I dont have the time or you to go over all the things being done, but they are being done. So dont conflate those two. Once you separate those two and say, okay, lets look at now the rationale. If you look at the data, the data are strongly suggestive in this country, and more than just suggestive in israel that you have a waning of immunity among people across age groups, not just the very, very elderly. You have clearly waning of immunity against infectiOn And clearcut indication of waning of immunity against severe disease. So what were trying to do right now is have a plan that, by the time we get to the middle of september, the september, the week of september the 20th, we will have a plan to vaccinate people who are having that waning immunity. The part about that plan thats important, it will be contingent upon the fda analyzing the data, not only from the united states, but from israel and other countries to determine if its appropriate and scientifically sound to do it. So when you have people objecting to the plan to do it, they tend to leave out that nothing is going to get done until the fda analyzes the data very, very carefully the way they do and make a determination from a regulatory standpoint of, should we be giving the boosters . Myself as a scientist who have seen some of the data, i believe when you look at that data carefully, theres going to be a decision to actually give the boost as opposed to not giving it. Thats interesting. That document, that article got a lot of attention yesterday. Interesting to hear you contradict it there point by point. Dr. Fauci, apologies for a Question Youve answered so many times offer the last year but i think it needs to be driven home. I know so many otherwise rational smart people that i talk to that say im healthy. Im this age. Ive never been sick. I dont need to get the vaccine. What do you say to those people . What is the clear case that you make to people who just dont think, you know, theyre not reading crazy Conspiracy Theories even. They just think, i dont want to put this in my body because i dont need to. What do you say to them . Well, there are two aspects of that and two approaches you take. First of all, the personal approach. It is true that young, healthy people have less of a chance of getting severely involved in the sense of getting infected and have a severe outcome. Theres No Doubt about that. But if you look across the country and you look at the hospitals, you see there are plenty of young people who get severely ill. Weve had 650,000 deaths in the united states. So although the odds are in your favor, you are not completely exempt from getting seriously ill. Thats one component. The other compont that in many respects is equally important is that it isnt all about you. If you get infected, even if you dont have any symptoms, it is likely that you will pass the virus on to Someone Else who might pass it on to Someone Else who might have a severe outcome, leading to hospitalizatiOn And even death. So youve got a look at it that youre not in a vacuum. Youre part of society. And do you want to be part of the component that propagates the virus and propagates the outbreak . Or do you want to be part of the solution . So, a, you should be worried about yourself because your health is important, as is the health of your family. But you are a part of society. And you do have some responsibility as a member of society. Dr. Fauci, the back and forth you just had with willie was both interesting and informative, as usual. My question is one that i think is on the minds of a lot of americans, and it is this. Is this the fight against this virus virus, our Real Forever War . I dont believe it needs to be. I mean, obviously, we will always be challenged by emerging and reemerging infections. We have very good vaccines right now. The virus will mutate and get new variants if we allow it to circulate and propagate itself. Thats one of the reasons why when you do have the capability of really smashing this virus, lets do it. If we do it, and i believe we can and will do it, you dont necessarily have to look at the fact that youre going to be struggling with this virus indefinitely. Weve had formidable viruses that weve eliminated. Things like polio. Things like measles in this country. We can do it if we put our will and all of our resources, which we are doing, to do that. And im not only talking about the united states. Im talking about getting the world vaccinated within a reasonable period of time. Dr. Fauci, we know that the virus travels when people move around the country. The democratic congressman from virginia has a Bill Proposing that people traveling within the united states on airplanes and trains should either be vaccinated or provide proof of a negative covid test. This is common practice now in europe. Ive just been traveling all over europe. You cant get on a plane without having some sort of proof youre negative. It seems to be crazy that a year and a half into this, i can still get on a plane to boston, california, and nobody is going to check me. Do you think that needs to change . Thats under consideration, certainly. I mean, i have been asked that questiOn And actually got some play in The Press when i made the answer. I think that if, in fact, it is seriously considered, its on the table. Were not there yet. In fact, if you look at the Sixpoint Program that the president came out with a couple days, what we were talking about with travel was doubling the fines of people who, in fact, are traveling and dont get tested. I believe that the idea about requiring vaccination for travel is something that is on the table for discussion. It has not been decided yet. Dr. Fauci, good morning. Its jonathan lemire. Let me get an update on the vaccines for children. We know, of course, that, you know, ages 12 and under have yet to receive approval to get the shot. Can you walk us through the timeline as to what youre hearing when that may be available for kids 5 to 12, but also those younger than 5, which seems to be further down the road. Yeah. It isnt a question of hearing, its a question of what the facts are. The facts are that we have, right now, the data being accumulated, theres two separate companies that are doing it. Pfizer and moderna. Pfizer is a bit ahead, maybe a few weeks ahead in the testing. End of september, beginning of october, there will be enough data in the testing of kids 11 to 5, in the sense of getting safety and data. It may take a few weeks to get that. We assume, and i believe itll work out this way, that by the time we get to the midfall, october or so, that we will have the capability of giving vaccines for pfizer. Moderna, as i mentioned, just a couple of weeks behind. Theyll get enough data probably by The End of october. If they go for an eua, itll likely be the beginning of november. What youre talking about is 11 to 5 somewhere in october november timeframe. Those who are younger than that will be a little further down. Because when you do a study, you do an age deescalation study. Start with 11 to 9, 9 to 6, 6 to 2, and 6 months to 2 years. Dr. Fauci, im sure youve answered this before. Forgive me for repeating the question. Do you have a percentage in mind of americans that need to be vaccinated before we reach a point to really suppress this virus and actually be on the winning side of things . Is it 80 . Is it 85 . Is it 90 of americans . Joe, we dont know. You know, any time you give a number, someone will poke holes in it. What i think is as close to the truth as you will get, youll know it when you see it. We should get, we, us here in the united states, should get as many people vaccinated as we possibly can. When we get to the point where it is that critical number that we are not sure of what it is, youre going to see the level of infections plummet very, very low, and maybe even disappear. Take, for example, measles. Measles is a highly transmissible virus. One of the most, if not the most, highly transmissible virus. You need a Vaccination Percentage of over 90 in order to get to that Herd Immunity with a virus essentially not being able to find a vulnerable targ target. Then you have a disappearance of infection. Im sorry i dont know what the number is, but it likely is going to be pretty high because we have a very transmissible try virus. Dr. Anthony fauci, thank you so much for coming back on the show this morning. We appreciate it. Coming up, secretary of State Anthony begin Blinkens Defense of the withdrawal from afghanistan. What he had to say on Capitol Hill yesterday. Plus, an urgent warning from apple. The company is advising all users to update their devices after researchers found a new Security Flaw that could impact iphones, ipads, macs, and apple watches. Morning joe is coming right back. Back welcome to allstate. Phone Notification where you can pay a little less and enjoy the ride a little more. Now, get new lower Auto Rates. Youre in good hands with allstate. Click or call for a lower rate today. Discover card i just got my Cashback Match is this for real . Yup we match all the cash back new Card Members earn at The End of their first year automatically woo i got my money its hard to contain yourself isnt it . Uh huh well let it go woooo get a dollar for Dollar Match at The End of your first year. Only from discover. As your business changes, the United States Postal Service is changing with it. With ecommerce that runs at the speed of now. Next Day And Twoday shipping nationwide, and returns right from the doorstep. Its a whole New World out there. Lets not keep it waiting. This is renae. Never heard of her . Its probably because shes not an influencer. Shes more of a groundbreaker. Just look at the way shes reshaping and reimagining her 4 Acre Slice of heaven. Its not hard to tell shes the real deal. Renae runs with us on a John Deere 1 Series Tractor because out here you Cant Fake a job well done. Nothing runs like a deere. Hear Renaes Story at deere. Com. Its my wokeuplikethis migraine medicine. Its ubrelvy. One dose can quickly stop my migraine in its tracks within 2 hours. Dont take with strong cyp3a4 inhibitors. Most common Side Effects were nausea and tiredness. Ask about ubrelvy, the anytime, anywhere migraine medicine. Beautiful. Sort of beautiful day in new York City. Top of the hour. Live look at new York City on this tuesday, september 14th. Jonathan lemire and Katty Kay are still with us. John ing the conversation, we have Msnbc Contributor Mike Barnicle is here. And pulitzer prizewinning Columnist And Editor of the Washington Post and political analyst, Eugene Robinson joins us. Good to have you all back today. Willie, we have to start with the biggest news of the day. Breaking banners. In new York City, breaking banners about as big as John Glenn orbits the earth. This is massive. Its a birthday. Happy birthday, alex. Think theyll let him out of the booth ever . There he is. No. Thats where he has been sitting since covid began. Let me tell you something about akor. Akor has been sitting there since the first case of covid escaped a lab, was found in a Bat Market or whatever. Hes been there i was 25 when this all began. [ laughter ] you look terrific. Dont look a day past 26. We love you. Happy birthday. Alex has been in the captains seat, youre right, every single day since this began with the mask on. I dont think people appreciate it. You look at these boxes. There are seven of us right now. Theres somebody in there running air traffic control, and his name is alex corson. It is not easy to pull off, and he does a great job. Really, weve been when covid first hit, nobody was going into 30 rock. Hardly anybody. It was a ghost town. You couldnt. Every day, alex went in. Every single day, talking about the iron man, unbelievable. Happy birthday. He is our iron man. Well call him akor. Thank you so much for everything you do. I dont know where to begin, willie. You know, sometimes i josh because im a Joshing Kind of guy. Oh, boy. I say that the Red Sox and the yankees are going to be fighting for fourth place. I never really expected that to be the truth. But these toronto bluejays, i mean, theyre the 27 yankees, the 1972 as. Theyre the big red machine. These guys, its like the line in butch cassidy, the sundance kid, who are those guys . They just keep coming. Yeah. They came into New York last week and swept four games, burying the yankees chances to bury the division, if they werent buried already. Theyre good. Weve been talking about this in New York this morning with john and mike, its a race for the Red Sox and yankees to decide who goes up to canada and plays in what im going to call skydome. I know its the Roger Center or whatever it is, but play in toronto, mike, a Onegame Playoff to get into the playoffs. The player there, vladimir, the mvp of the american league, incredible, the way he has pulled that team in the past month right up into, i think, you know, theyre going to crush everyone in the fall. The other aspect of whats going on in major league baseball, and a Hat Tip to larry Bear And Gabe kapler and the san francisco giants. How about those giants . I dont know anybody Who Saw that team coming. No. If you look at their roster, they dont seem to have the talent of the dodgers or maybe even, frankly, the padres. Padres who are ten plus games back at this point. Yet, theyre the first team. Last night, they clinched a playoff spot. Assured of at least a Wild Card. 2 1 2 Game Lead for Home Field Advantage throughout. Certainly, mike, our Red Sox, another loss on the West Coast Last Night, now dropped into a tie with the yankees. Playing the bluebluejays. Yankees have been struggling, willie, but the remedy came to the bronx yesterday. There are a few things in this uncertain time we can count on. Death, taxes, and the yankees beating the twins. They did yesterday. The twins, 50 lead in the first. You didnt break a sweat. No. I saw 50. Oh, its the twins. Well win. The Twins Cant do it. If you look at the National League Wild Card race, it is insane. You have the Dodgers Way up. Then the reds have the second spot followed by the padres, cardinals, phillies, and mets, all with legitimate spots to sneak into the second spot. Its exciting. The mets yankees game on Sunday Night was absolutely crazy. A great Wild Card game. I do want to go back to the giants organization. We talk a lot about the east coast. We dont get to stay up and see what the giants and the dodgers, the padres, the angels do every day and the other teams on the West Coast. Man, that giants organization, just one of the best. They won the World Series in 10, 12, 14. They keep coming back at you. You have to look at them and the cardinals organization, even though the cardinals arent having a great year this year. Every year they i do want to talk to the two Red Sox fans on the set there, though, and just ask, what is wrong with our defense . What is wrong with our team . Whats going on . Well, the first thing thats going on is the fact that there are so many unvaccinated players on the Red Sox team. I dont understand how you can have postgame conferences, talking about, we did this for the team and hope the team wins, when you dont get vaccinated to protect your teammates. That bothers me. Its bothered me for a while. Thats been part of their problem. Theyve had, like, nine, ten Covid Guys taken out of the lineup, taken off the team, and replaced by literally minor leaguers. Its depleted an already bad bullpen even further. Youre right, the defense has been abysmal. Im not going to play schwarber, who is playing a new position at first base. He is one of the bright spots for the Red Sox recent weeks. Booted a routine Ground Ball that ended up leading to the mariners scoring three runs and winning that game. Theyre just sort of a mess right now. It seems like, with a few exceptions, devers has been hitting, renfroe is good, but it is a team wide slump. Theyre in trouble right now. Their schedule to close the year is pretty soft, but the fear is they might be a few games out and wont have enough time to make up the ground behind the surging bluejays. Then perhaps even the yankees. Last note on baseball, mika, then were turn it over to you. Scary moment on citi field in queens. Errant flow. Hits the umpire in the face. Oh hes okay. A spin move. A nice play on the ball. The errant Throw Right in the side of the face, catches the umpire. Got treatment for a bloody cheek but stayed in the game. Wow. Nice. Not even close. Glad hes okay. Cardinals beat the mets, 70. 1 2 game out for second and a Wild Card spot. My daughter will be in a bad mood. Shes a mets fan. Getting to the news. President biden was in california Last Night campaigning alongside Governor Gavin Newsom ahead of todays rare special election. Biden encouraged residents to vote no in the states gubernatorial recall. Connected newsoms top opponent in the recall as Donald Trump. Keep Gavin Newsom as your Governor Or Youll get Donald Trump. Its not a joke. Republican governor blocking progress on covid19. Who is also antiwoman, antiworker, climate ddenier, wo doesnt believe in choice. The choice should be absolutely clear. Gavin newsom. You have a governor who has the courage to lead. In gavin, you have a governor who shares the states values. In gavin, you have a governor who makes sure Donald Trumps dark, destructive, divisive politics never finds a place in california. Todays election could have farreaching implications. Nbc News Correspondent Jacob Soboroff has more on whats at stake. Reporter the president doing Fire Damage in northern california. One of the many Crises Governor Newsom has faced during his term. Including covid, inequality, and rising violent crime. You think this is a republican recall and only that, that there arent unhappy people in california . Everybody is upset with everybody in the last 18 months. Nobody is denying that. This is a republican recall, backed by the rnc. Reporter every voter will get two questions to vote on. Should Gavin Newsom be recalled from the office of governor . Who should replace him . Across the state, ballots have been cast for weeks, mostly by mail as we saw at l. A. s processing center. Millions of ballots from the recall will be passing through this building because each and every California Voter is getting a mailin ballot. The leading gop challenger, Larry Elder, raised concerns about the Election Integrity and wouldnt commit to accepting the results. Whether or not you win or lose, will you accept the results of the Election Tomorrow . I think we all ought to be looking at Election Integrity, no matter whether youre a democrat, independent, or republican. Reporter turnout in the election will be key. 23yearold long Beach Resident Camilla switched from democrat to republican for the vote. Do you get the sense the governor understands how hard life is for you and people like you . No. Sorry. Its upsetting. Its really upsetting. I dont mean to get emotional, but he has no idea. Reporter the race itself could hinge on struggling voters like camilla who share that sentiment. It sounds like youre going to vote to recall the governor. I am. I am. Reporter newsom understands campaigning against what he sees as an undemocratic republican recall may not be enough. Inequality is worse in your state than anywhere else in the united states of america. Do you blame people for wanting a change in leadership . Well, i just got here 2 1 2 years ago. Reporter democrats have been in power here over ten years. Yeah. Over two decades, weve led the nation in terms of some of the challenges. Lets bring in national political correspondent for Nbc News and msnbc, steve kornacki. Steve, would love to get your odds on baseball, the playoffs, who is going to win the World Series, but well do that later. Lets talk right now about the recall. About two, three weeks ago, the race seemed much closer than it ever should have been for any democratic candidate in a state that Donald Trump only got 34 in in 2020. What are the polls looking like now . They look different, joe, than a couple weeks ago. Youre right. Three weeks ago, a month ago, you know, we were looking at this thing and starting to say, geez, you know, is something going on here . Of course, for recall supporters in a state like california, that would be monumental. Biden won this by 30 when Gavin Newsom got elected in 2018 for the first im. Margin was 25 points in the state. If you look at all the polls in the homestretch of this campaign, there have been eight polls in the last week of this campaign. The average is newsom surviving this thing by 14 points. No on the recall by a 14point margin. Yeah, i went back and looked at the only successful Recall Campaign in California History for a governor. That was back in davis, the democrat, was recalled, and Arnold Schwarzenegger became the governor. The week of that campaign, the average was 16 points for the recall. Of course, it did end up passing by 10 points. Schwarzenegger became governor. At least from the standpoint of polling, this looks dramatically different than 2003. This looks favorable for newsom. We know polls havent always been right lately. Yeah, certainly. It certainly is the case in the cases where Donald Trump is running. Steve, everybody at the table wants to ask you a question, but before we get there, got a chance to ask you a general question. For a little context. Its such a democratic state. When i was growing up, it was a state where Richard Nixon came from. It was a state where ronald reagan, of course, was governor. Republicans at least had a 50 50 chance of winning. We remember Pete Wilson being blamed for turning the state blue permanently. What are the demographics of that state that make California A Plus 20, plus 25, Plus 30 state for the democratic party . Youre right. The evolution of california. I mean, we used to talk about a long time ago, Orange County, south of los angeles, was the cradle in ways of the modern conservative movement. Orange county voted for biden by almost ten points in the last president ial election. Thats one of the aspects that changed in california. The big picture story, demographic change. If you went back to the last republican to win california in a president ial election, that was george h. W. Bush in 1988 over michael dukakis. Last republican to carry the election. The California Electorate was 82 white. It is now under 50 . It is down to 49 . You know, california is the most diverse state in the country. The white share of the vote has come all the way down from 82 to 49 . It also, as i say, you look at Orange County and one of the things youre seeing in a place like Orange County is the white vote itself has shifted certainly along educational lines. White voters with college degrees, higher income. Theyve been drifting away from the republican party, adding to things for the republicans in california. Viewers guide for tonight. Every voter, every eligible voter in the state of california got a mailin ballot. A bunch of those have been sent in. There is inperson voting today. People tune in tonight at 10 00 and waiting for the returns to come in. Its a little like the 2020 election. Republicans are more likely to vote in person. Maybe the mailin is more democratic. Be careful for the early numbers. How should we be watching this as it comes across . It is interesting tonight. Basically 11 00 p. M. Eastern, the polls will close in california. The way they do it is probably it might be a little different because its just a Recall Election. Might make it easier to count. I dont know. Probably 11 20, 11 30 tonight, the board where we have california and all the counties is going to light up like a christmas tree. Whats going to happen is every county is going to release all of the mailin ballots basically that were received, basically until about right now. Youre going to have millions of votes. Theyve been counting them up. Theyve been processing ballots. Theyve been getting ready. They just have to release them. Thats the first Thing Youll see. Thatll cover probably more than half the vote in california pretty quickly. Youre right, there is a difference between the Mailin Voting and the same Day Voting in california, though it is not as dramatic as weve seen elsewhere. If you look back at 2020 in california, the first reports we got from the major counties, about 11 30 at night, something like that, numbers there were about five or six points more friendly for biden than the final numbers were. This could be the kind of thing, if the polls are right, were going to see it in the early releases. Well see this is clearly trending toward Gavin Newsom. Youd need to see the sameday results come in to make sure no shocking thing is happening there. If the polls are right, this will be callable tonight. The Flip Side is if you have a surprise, and if this ever became a close race, we havent really nationally had a nationally significant close California Race in this new era of Mailin Voting out there. Brace yourselves for that if it ever happened. Itd probably take a month. Gene robinson has a question for you. Yeah. Steve, a lot of places, a lot of states, this would be Hope Fles hopelessly confusing. You have two questions on the ballot. Do you have to mark both . If you say no, recall, then do you still have to pick somebody to replace him if he does get recalled, that sort of thing. On the other hand, california is used to the Ballot Initiatives and complicated ballots. I remember when i used to live there long ago, even then it was you had to be used to a complicated ballot to vote in california. Is that still the case . Do you expect the California Voters will take what would be confusing elsewhere in Stride Today . Yeah. It is interesting. One part of it is extremely simple, yes or no on the recall. As you say, the other part is about 50 candidates in the replacement race. The variable on this, and the chance democrats have taken in this thing, and the polling suggests itll pay off for them, but the risk democrats have taken is ignore the second part. Dont even participate. Dont give it any oxygen. Dont vote in the Replacement Election. Just vote against the recall. Well kill the recall. Thatll be that. The risk theyre taking, obviously, if the recall ever were to pass in that Replacement Election, simultaneous Replacement Election comes into effect, it is a much smaller pool of voters. Were expecting millions of fewer votes in the Replacement Election because the democrats are boycotting it. Larry elder has sort of consolidated the republican side of the vote in that thing. Conservative commentator Larry Elder would probably be favored in that phase of it. 2003, when the republicans succeeded in recalling Gray Davis as governor, democrats played it differently in 03. There was an Insurance Policy in the replacement race. The Lieutenant Governor at the time, democrats message in 03 was vote against the recall but also vote so there is another one. They voted for arnold for governor, so 0 for 2 on that one. Polls in general. We talked about the Recount Polls in california. We had a poll on earlier, the last hour, about mandated vaccinations. It was, you know, the usual. It was 60 democrats are for it. 30 republicans are against it. That flips on most issues. 30 democrats. 60 republicans. When you pull these polls apart, the negative, against, is it based on policy . Is it based on ideology . Is it based on pure Hatred And Distrust of The Other Side . The most interesting poll i saw on this was an openended question to folks supporting the recall in california. It was, why do you want to Recall Newsom as governor . Majority, between 50 and 60 , the answers were in the covid related realm. The biggest single one, if you remember this, was that dinner that Gavin Newsom had. The french laundry. The fancy restaurant. Everybody sitting there close quarters, indoors, no mask, while he is imposing these mandates on the state and obviously giving lots of public talks about that. That was the most single cited thing. There was the business closures, burdens of mandates. That was the issue, that picture, that story is what galvanized the Petition Drive for this thing. Still when you ask the openended question, that comes back the most. Steve kornacki, thank you very much. Well be watching today. Some other news now. A California Man who police say had a bayonet and a machete in his truck was arrested yesterday after being pulled over near the Democratic National Committee headquarters in washington after midnight. Nbc news reports craig had a 44yearold From Oceanside was booked on suspicion of possession of prohibited weapons, according to u. S. Capitol police. At the arrest, police say the machete was on the seat of the pickup truck, which was decorated with a swastika and other symbols. Craig had allegedly expressed white Supremacist Ideology and told police he was, quote, on patrol. Family members told Nbc News he was diagnosed with schizophrenia years ago and is not well. In iowa, School Districts once again have the power to enact Mask Mandates after a federal judge temporarily blocked a State Law banning them from doing so. U. S. District Judge Robert Pratt issued a restraining Order Yesterday that stopped the enforcement of a Mask Mandate ban and in an opinion he wrote it substantially increases the Risk Of several children with Health Conditions being infected with covid19. In response, republican governor Kim Reynolds issued a statement, vowing to repeal the decision, saying that it took away Parents Ability to decide whats best for their child. And apple is issuing Emergency Software updates to fix a Security Vulnerability in his products after researchers uncovered a flaw that allows hackers to infect anyones devices with highly invasive spyware. Researchers at the university of Torontos Citizen Lab discovered the Security Issue from an attack on a saudi activists iphone. They believe the spyware came from israels nso group, an infamous hacker for hire firm. The vulnerability could affect all major apple devices. It is the first known instance of an attack that doesnt require the victim to click on a link or open infected files. Experts say such attacks are limited to specific targets. Apple users should get an alert to update their software soon. Take them up on it. Still ahead on Morning Joe, well be joined by one of the lawmakers who questioned secretary of State Anthony Blinken Yesterday about the u. S. Withdrawal from afghanistan. Representative abigail will be our guest. And Joes Podcast drops today. Hear his conversations with Great Names in music, movies, sports, and so much more. Go to spotify, Apple Music, or wherever you get your podcasts. Youre watching Morning Joe. Well be right back. When you were young vo this is a place for ambition. A forge of progress. A unicorn in training. A corner to build a legacy. A vision for tomorrow. A fresh start. A blank canvas. A second act. A renewed company culture. A temple for ideas. And a place to make your mark. Loopnet. The most popular place to find a space. Wealth is breaking ground on your biggest project yet. Worth is giving the people who build it a solid foundation. Wealth is shutting down the office for mikes retirement party. Worth is giving the employee who spent half his life with you, the party of a lifetime. Wealth is watching your business grow. Worth is watching your employees grow with it. Principal. For all its worth. Music playing. Theres an america we build and one we explore one thats been paved and one thats forever wild but freedom means you dont have to choose just one adventure you get both. Introducing the Allnew 3row Jeep grand Cherokee L jeep. Theres only one. When traders tell us how to make thinkorswim even better, jeep grand Cherokee L we listen. Like jack. He wanted a streamlined version he could access anywhere, no download necessary. And kim. She wanted to execute a preset Trade Strategy in seconds. So we gave Em Thinkorswim web. Because platforms this innovative, arent just made for traders theyre made by them. Thinkorswim trading. From td ameritrade. Welcome to allstate. Where everything just seems to go your way. Youre in good hands with allstate. Click or call for a lower Auto Rate today. Welcome back to Morning Joe. Beautiful sunrise over the united States Capitol at 7 28 in the morning. Secretary of state Antony Blinken will testify before the senate foreign Relations Committee Today that answer questions about the u. S. Withdrawal from afghanistan. Yesterday, Secretary Blinken appeared before the house foreign affairs committee, defending himself against fierce criticism from republicans. Did the President Biden work with the Coward President of afghanistan work with intelligence about taliban . What the President Said to then president ghani in private is what he said in public. I absolutely wonder if you are complicit in this, as well. I find it hard to believe that President Biden would do that without you being aware of this. These are things we deserve to know better answers, have better hearings on this. I do not believe a word that youre saying on this. Simply put i do not wish to hear from you. Simply put im not yielding you a moment of time. The time as expired. So has gentlemans time has expired. The secretary can answer the question. I cant ask a question. You did. I dont want to hear from the secretary. The gentlemans time expired. When he steps in front of the camera, thats what he does. Although i deeply appreciate any and all efforts of the State Department personnel on the ground to rescue american citizens, for you to try to ride the coaltails of the 13 service members who gave their lives is shameful. It shows the american people how out of touch we are. Im not riding coattails. The Men And Women Of My Department were at the gates. Its not a question. And its a statement, not a question. Make no mistake, mr. Secretary, the biden administrations egregiously inept withdrawal has left america and the world a much less safe place. Do you take any responsibility, Secretary Blinken, for this disastrous withdrawal, or do you still want to call it a success . Congresswoman, im responsible for the decisions that i make. Im responsible for the actions of the State Department. Im responsible for looking at any lessons to be taken from those decisions and those actions. Im also responsible for being accountable for those decisions and actions. But can you and if you let me finish, please. Its my time the way im accountable is doing exactly what i am doing today, which is to you and through you to the american people, to hold myself accountable on decisions. We made the right decision in ending americas longest war. We made the right decision in not sending a third generation of americans to fight and die in afghanistan. Lets bring in former cia caseworker, democratic Congresswoman Abigail Spanberger of virginia. She sits on the committee you saw there and joins us now. Good morning. Did we get any Answers Yesterday . You were in the hearing. I know you had questions. There was a lot of grandstanding. More lctures than questions. Did you get satisfactory answers from the secretary . Yesterday was the start of the conversation. I think what you depicted in the part, the clips we just saw, were a lot of the grandsanding, grandstanding, not an effort to get answers, just media clips. From democrats and republicans, we had thoughtful, detailed questions. You know, frankly, were looking at whats happened within the past six weeks, whats happened since the beginning of the year when the administration came into the presidency, and weve been looking at the last 20 years. Yesterday was, i think, a first step forward in what i hope will be many more hearings as we conduct congressional oversight. Certainly, one Days Conversation about our 20 Year War and the challenging departure from afghanistan will not be sufficient. Your district is home to Fort Picket, which currently houses about 5,000, i believe, correct me if im wrong, 5,000 afghan men, women, and children who were evacuated from that country. How many more people do you sense are still in afghanistan who would like to come out and arrive somewhere like Fort Picket . We know there are a handful of americans left. We need to get a better number on that. Also afghans, wartime allies, people who worked with us or people, frankly, scared to live alongside the taliban. Throughout the world, we have individuals at different Lily Pad locations who are waiting to go through the process to file for their sib or confirm their Paperwork Or P2 eligibility. And i from their perspective, ideally move on to the united states. There are endangered afghans who made it out of the country who are potentially going to be processed for relocation in other countries, not just the united states. Certainly, other allies throughout the world have offered to take endangered afghans. And i do know that there continue to be folks on the ground in afghanistan who worked in concert with, Side By side with american service members and american organizations, ngos, and some of them continue to be in very, very deprave danger. Congresswoman, i listen to your questioning yesterday, and you asked the secretary specifically about videos that youve seen and received, testimony youve seen and received about the condition of certain Women In Afghanistan. Women who might have been singled out for assassination, discrimination, et cetera. How much leverage do you think the u. S. Still has practically, and how much political capital is it prepared to extend in order to try to ensure that womens rights are protected in afghanistan . Frankly, the early signs arent good, right . Women are told they have to stay home. They Cant Work alongside men. They cant get into taxis with men. Some are being treated far worse than that. What do you think the u. S. Can do and is prepared to do now . So i think this is a bit of a moving target. I think, and this was the crux of my question, i was concerned by some of the testimony of the secretary and, you know, others from the administration, that are still kind of giving the benefit taliban. My question really was based on, is it appropriate to still give them the benefit of the doubt, and if not, how do we move forward . How do we advocate for the rights of Women In Afghanistan . How do we protect those who entered schools and entered University And Set about being part of the government because we were there as a stabilizing factor and advocating for them to do that. I think at this point in time, itll been incumbent upon the united states to work with allies and regional partners to continue that advocacy, but i think first and foremost, we have to be eyes wide open about the reality on the ground, which is why i asked the secretary if he has seen these disturbing videos and photos and accounts of whats happening in afghanistan currently. Congresswoman, i want to talk about a couple things. First, i want to discuss the insults, the shouting, those insulting him, saying everything he did and said was a lie. And then demanding the Secretary Of State not respond. I was shocked at the lack of decorum, the lack of respect for the institution of congress, the lack of respect for the institution of the state. And instead of getting to the facts, you had a lot of people that were just verbally prancing around and posing for the cameras. Are most im just shocked. Does that happen a lot in your committees . I can tell you, we impeached bill clinton. You know, we nailed his people to the wall rhetorically, but we always were respectful of the armed services committee. Our chairman demanded it of us. You know, the challenge here is some of the antics that you saw yesterday in the Blinken Hearing are Part And Parcel of, you know, theres a few folks on that committee that are there for the antics. You know, i have children, as you see in this picture, and sometimes you just have to you know, i could go back home if i wanted to listen to someone being a petulant child, though, my children, lets be clear, do not behave like that. Its preening for the camera. Its not respecting the constitutional duty of oversight. Were supposed to be asking questions, and there is, in fact, assertion that you dont even want to hear an answer. Its a fiveminute speech. You can do that elsewhere. The secretarys time is valuable. Our time is valuable. And the american peoples time is valuable. We want answers. There are many questions that i still need answered from the secretary, from this administration, and, frankly, because it is about looking backwards, what happened in the past. It is also about helping to ensure that were moving forward. I will say, one of the most spectacular questions that we heard during the hearing came from my colleague, Congressman Castro of texas, who remarked on the fact that, in the 9 11 commission review, that one of the findings was that there were so many State Department officials who were not in confirmed positions. So many Bush Administration officials hadnt actually received senate confirmation. And Congressman Castros comment was, like, this was a learning of something that went wrong back in 2001, and here we are with about half of the numbers of confirmed State Department officials compared to where we were in 2001 because we have one senator who is standing in the way of confirmation of these an array of under secretaries who are vital to being able to move forward on the mission related to things that katty was talking about. Such as, you know, ensuring we can work with our regional partners to advocate for women and girls. Ensuring the department is handling afghanistan and regional equities are well staffed. These are the sorts of things were supposed to bring forward in these hearings. Some people did it very, very effectively. Some people were there just for the clicks and the i dont know, the celebrity of it, which is not the job. That is not the duty. No, its not the duty at all. Its disrespectful of the institution of congress. And everybody else involved. Gene robinson has a question. Gene . Congresswoman, what did you despite all the preening and all the showboating that you heard from The Other Side of the aisle, i know you dont think youve gotten enough, but did you get a start from Secretary Blinken, and do you understand better the biden Administrations Policy in the way the withdrawal was handled . Is that still somehow opaque to you . No, i think that across the conversatiOn And, frankly, on both sides of the aisle, some people asked some very, very good, foundational questions. So i think we were able to get very good foundational questions thats a strong point moving forward. Some of the historical analysis and assessments of, okay, when the administration came in in january, what were you moving forward with . You had a deal. Did you have a plan from the prior administration . What were the inputs they were dealing with . So i did think it was a very good starting point. The secretary, i think, answered the questions in detail. You know, even if you didnt like the answers to the questions that he gave, i think he gave very good, detailed answers. Certainly gave us some kind of initial steps forward that have caused a lot of us to have some follow up. Im pleased, particularly in my district. I represent Fort Pickett, where there are 5,000 evacuees, could be up to 10,000. There are particularly questions that i have had. Ive engaged directly with the administration. To be able to speak of those evacuations, those evacuees in my district directly with the secretary, you know, he gave good initial answers. In some of the cases he said, we dont know yet. Ill have to get back to you. I think this signals it needs to be a continued conversation. Frankly, it is still an evolving process. For those of us who are particularly focused on looking forward, you know, the conversation continues. And the further we get into the future, i think, a little bit more clarity well have looking back on what went right, what went wrong, and how we mitigated risk or how we could have done better or, frankly, a greater clarity about the situation that this administration had taken over. In fairness, clarity about the situation this prior administration had taken over and clarity about the situation that the administration before that had taken over, right . Theres 20 years worth of decisions and pivot points, and that will be a longer process. I thought yesterday was a very good firsttuning into portions the senate hearing, which i hope will be additive to what we began yesterday. From there, we should continue the process of oversight, which is our constitutional Duty And Something that is so, so vitally important. Congresswoman spanberger, thank you very much for coming on this morning. Thanks for everything you do. Coming up, its almost mind boggling to think about all the huge stories over the past 13 years. Our next guest is doing exactly that with a collection of columns covering some of the most Hot Button Issues in america. Author George Will joins us with his new book next on Morning Joe. You probably think visa is a credit card company, huh . But its actually a network. Connecting just about everyone to just about everyone else. It can open eyes with a cup of Coffee And Change minds on what makes a business, a business. And it is working to connect everyone, everywhere. So, meet visa. A Network Working for everyone. Helen knew exercise could help her diabetes. But she didnt know what was right for her. No. Nope. No way. But then helen went from no to know with Freestyle Libre 14 day, now she knows what activity helps lower her glucose. And can see what works best for her. Take the mystery out of your glucose levels, and lower your a1c. Now you know. Freestyle libre 14 day. Now covered by medicare for those who qualify. Freestyle libre 14 day. Hey google. Ive lost count of how many Asthma Attacks ive had. But my nunormal with nucala . Fewer Asthma Attacks. Nucala is a oncemonthly addon injection for severe eosinophilic asthma. Not for sudden breathing problems. Allergic reactions can occur. Get help right away for swelling of face, mouth, tongue, or trouble breathing. Infections that can cause shingles have occurred. Dont stop steroids unless told by your doctor. Tell your doctor if you have a parasitic infection. May cause headache, injectionsite reactions, back pain, and fatigue. Ask your doctor about nucala. Find your nunormal with nucala. Tech every customer has their own safelite story. This couple was on a camping trip. When their windshield got a chip. They drove to safelite for a sameday repair. And with their insurance, it was no cost to them. Woman really . Tech thats service you can trust. Singers safelite repair, safelite replace. In business, its never just another day. Its the big sale, or the big presentation. The day where everything goes right. Or the one where nothing does. With Comcast Business you get the network that can deliver Gig Speeds to the most businesses and advanced cybersecurity to protect every device on it all backed by a dedicated team, 24 7. Every day in business is a big day. Well keep you ready for whats next. Comcast business powering possibilities. 47 past. The u. S. Capitol Police Chief Yesterday gave congressional leaders an Intelligence Briefing about the upcoming demonstration at the capitol dubbed the justice for j6 rally. In support of those jailed for activities during the capitol insurrection. Nbc news reports new security cameras have been installed around the complex perimeter, and there is an increased presence of police officers. Well be watching that. Lets bring in Washington Post columnist George Will. His new book out today is entitled american happiness and discontents, the unruly torrent, 2008 to 2020. George, in it, you write about the kind of divisiveness that led up to the January 6th attack on the capitol. In fact, ill quote from it. It has been well said that the united states is the only nation founded on a good idea, the proposition that people should be free to pursue happiness as they define it. In recent years, however, happiness has been elusive for this dyspeptic nation, in which too many people think and act as tribes and define their happiness as some other tribes unhappiness. As a quintessentially american voice, that of robert frost, said, the only way out is through. Perhaps the information, the reasoning, and i hope the occasional amusements in this book can help readers think through and, thereby, diminish our current discontents. George, talk about the unruly torrent over the last 12, 13 years. As you were putting these essays together, what was your biggest takeaway of your own writings over that time and where we are today . Well, im struck by the fact, joe, that were arguing about things that are hard to put down on pieces of paper. What legislation would diffuse this . In the 19th century, we argued about whether one set of human beings with own another set of human beings, and whether slavery should extend into the territories, and what to do with public lands. Big issues that you could address with the law. I think today so much of our bitterness is issues that wouldd by the law. I think people feeling con did he condescended by other people. Im also struck, joe, by the fact that some cultural changes are rippling in disturbing ways. Somewhere along the line in the last 20 years, the Noun Parent became the verb parenting, and twoparent. We now have the idea that perfectionism will produce wonderful children for everybody, but its going to be like woebegone where all children are above average. Then theyll be raised by parents who protect them from all risks who convince them theyre all special, and they get to college and they feel threatened by because theyve been raised by riskaverse parents and have never had to fail which is part of whats called growing up, so they get to colleges and then they demand safe spaces and they become exquisitely sensitive to microaggressions. The problem is what happens on campus doesnt stay on campus, it leaks out to a larger society where everyone is exquisitely sensitive, constantly unhappy, and we now have a nation in which a large number of people are only happy when theyre furious, so far as i can tell. A long time ago there was a Radio Program called fibber, mcgee and molly. Molly would say to her husband, if it makes you happy to be unhappy, be unhappy. It seems like a lot of americans are like that today. We had a psychiatrist on a few weeks ago. One of my favorite segments over the past couple of months, because he was speaking to me and millions of parents over the past 20 years, and said stop bubble wrapping your children. Stop stepping in, stop trying to take away all of the inconveniences, all of the difficult situations. Let them suffer consequences, and when they go off to school, they wont be frail emotionally. Theyll understand that by facing those challenges and walking through them, youll get to the other Side And Youll be stronger for it. It sounds exactly like what youre saying. Exactly. The country seems to me to be addicted to hysteria. May i say something about the fence around the capitol . That an obscenity. It tells the world that the united states is like a Banana Republic in which the government is worried about arrestive tank regimen at the edge of town. The idea that we have to envelop the epicenter of the american government, the united States Capitol building, in this fence to protect it from what . This communicates to the world and to our own nation that we are somehow a fragile people and a fragile country. This Country Wasnt made by fragile people, and it is not fragile. And that obscenity of a fence should be taken down by noon today. George, in this collection of columns and essayessays, you ra not for the first time, our obsession with President S, making them larger than life, bigger than they are. Its an important job, everyone knows that. But there seems to be no end to our intensity in terms of coverage of President S. Partly its a function of new modern communications first radio which had a bigger effect on our politics than even television did, with roosevelt and others. But television brings President S into our living rooms constantly all day long. The idea that the presidency should be the direct translation of the public mood into law goes all the way back to andrew jackson, i suppose, but its been exacerbated in modern times so that today the entire constitutional architecture has been skewed, and the separation of powers badly damaged by President S who believe that they can, to take one recent example, come out and say, i am impatient about the vaccine resistance, and, therefore, im going to exercise powers that i dont think he really has, ordering Vaccine Mandates. Look, the President S exaspiration is understandable. Vaccine resistance is irrational. But the fact is President S do not have police powers. Those belong to the states, and the states can order mandates, President S cant. And we just have to understand the constitutional government requires patience. And president ial impatience is not a constitutional factor. George, you are a conservative. You are one of my very favorite conservatives. But i wonder if what future do you see for conservatism . It seems to me that the forces that are ascended in our politics are progressive on the one Hand And Populist on the other, and not conservative like yourself. Whatever populism is conservatism isnt. Populism believes that everything is clear, known to the public and should be directed into the policy and not be refined in the constitution. That is the antithesis of conservatism. Gene, there is no place for conservatism in the republican party right now because we have an absolutely unique situation. We have a republican party who are they wont say this are frightened of their voters. And because theyre frightened of them, they dont much like them. Because they dont like them, they dont respect them. Its a very tensionridden relationship between the republicans elected officials and the republican base. Until the republican party gets back to something like the principles that made it a vibrant force in the 80s and 90s, conservatives are, as i say, orphans. All right, the new book is american happiness and discontents the unruly torrent 2008 to 2020. George will, thank you so much for your insights and analysis today, and congratulations on the book. Still ahead, senate democrats are out with new voting Rights Legislation this morning. Majority Leader Chuck Schumer is pushing for a vote, but will any republicans be on board . Plus the latest on the Flood Threat from tropical storm nicholas. Parts of texas could see more than a foot of rain as the storm moves inland today. Morning joe is coming right back. G right back burke ive seen this movie before. woman you have . burke sure, this is the part where all is lost and the hero searches for hope. Then, a mysterious figure reminds her that she has the farmers home policy perk, guaranteed replacement cost. And that her home will be rebuilt, regardless of her limits or if the cost of materials has gone up. woman thats really something. burke get a whole lot of something with Farmers Policy perks. Wait, i didnt ruin The Ending, did i . woman yeah, yyou did. We are farmers. Bumpadum, Bumbumbumbum Ice Cream is like whooping cough, its not just for kids. Whooping cough is highly contagious for people of any age. And it can cause violent uncontrollable coughing fits. Ask your Doctor Or Pharmacist about whooping Cough Vaccination because its not just for kids. Ask your Doctor Or Pharmacist about whooping Cough Vaccination i was injured in a car crash. Because its not just for kids. I had no idea how much my case was worth. I called the Barnes Firm. When a truck hit my son, i had so many questions about his case. I called the Barnes Firm. It was the best call i couldve made. Your case is often worth more than insuran call the Barnes Firm to find out i couldve made. What your case could be worth. We will help get you the best result possible. The Barnes Firm, injury attorneys call one eight hundred,est resul Eight Million i know, New Yorks coming back we got the rangers, yankees, mets, nicks and nets we cheer for the giants and pray for the jets i know New Yorks coming back were already complaining about the cold we all hate Bill De Blasio and i know New Yorks coming back we got the nypd and the mdny when i tried out they said you seem more like a Post Office Guy i know New Yorks coming back all the tourists have returned doing what they do walking slowly down the Sidewalk Right in front of you even though some of the seats are wet the subway is still packed i know new York Citys coming back ah, good morning, and welcome to Morning Joe. It is tuesday, september 14, and i think Jimmy Fallon has really captured things. First of all, i like Bill De Blasio, come on. I love Bill De Blasio. And the jets, the punchline is always, willie, and of course a line lifted there sort of from that Marty Scorcese Friend leibovitz, pretend its a city, pretend its a city. Like people actually go to work here there is moisture on the seats of the subway, i can report, there are smells emanating from the platforms. Its coming back. The scents remind you of a great new York City. It is wonderful to be in New York. We have a lot happening this morning with a Big Red Circle around Todays Date on the calendar in california. The state is deciding whether Governor Gavin Newsom should be removed from office with newsom seemingly surging. Republicans who wanted the recall in the first place are now claiming you guessed it Voter Fraud. What idiots. Oh, my god. Lets just say undemocratic. Featuring false claims about elections, former President Trump has plans to be back in washington for a rally defending the insurrectionists. How the Capitol Police are preparing for that. With us we have white House Reporter for the associated press, jonathan lemire, Washington Editor Katty Kaye is with us and jim sherman. Today is the day. California will decide whether to keep Gavin Newsom their governor or not. President biden encouraged residents to vote no in the state gubernatorial recall, and battling a bit of a cough, connected newsoms top opponent in the recall with Donald Trump. You can keep Gavin Newsom as your Governor Or Youll get Donald Trump. Its not a joke. A republican governor blocking progress on covid19 who is also antiwoman, antiworker, climate denyer, who doesnt believe in choice. The choice should be absolutely clear. Gavin newsom. You have a governor who has the courage to lead and, gavin, you have a governor who shares the states values. In gavin you have a governor who makes sure trumps dark politics never have a place in california. We may have defeated Donald Trump but we ever not defeated trumpism. Trumpism is still on the ballot in california, and thats why its so important, not just for all of us here, 40 Million americans strong in the nations largest and most populist state, but also to send a statement all across the united states of america that trumpism has no place here, and trumpism will be defeated all across the united states of america because were better than that Governor Newsom there. Meanwhile, as mika mentioned, the leading republican frontrunner, Larry Elder, appealed to his supporters to use an online report to claim detected fraud in the results of the reelection in terms of Gavin Newsom being reinstated as governor. The only problem is the Election Hadnt happened yet. No results yet and elder was still out campaigning. They contacted elder about the site. A disclaimer about who funded the site was added. Elder repeatedly used to say whether he would accept the results of the Recall Election. Reporter whether or not you win or lose, will you accept the results of the Election Tomorrow . I think we all ought to be looking at Election Integrity, whether youre a democrat, independent or republican. Lets all make sure the election is a fair election, so lets all work together no matter what the results are to make sure the results are valid and legitimate and everybody who voted should have voted. Is that a commitment to accept the Results Tomorrow . Lets all work together on both sides of the aisle to make sure this is a fair election. This is what everybody feared after Donald Trump stoked lies about the 2020 election that all republicans who thought they would lose the polling would use fraudulent elections as the excuse now. Before the votes have been cast, before the ballots have been counted, claims of Voter Fraud to explain away a potential election loss. What whiners. What losers. These poor little snowflakes are going around. Every time it looks like theyll lose an election, they say, oh, the election got stolen. They cheated. Seriously . This is elemental. You tell your kids when theyre playing a game to play as hard as they can play it, and then when the game is over, shake the other Teams Hand and be a good loser. Here we have one after another after another republican just whining. I guess it is their strategy. They understand, and especially in places like california, that their policies are extraordinarily unpopular. They are on the wrong side of so many issues. They are on the wrong side of Vaccine Mandates. They are on the wrong side of Overturning A constitutionally protected right in the state of texas that 70 of americans say they dont want overturned. Theyre on the wrong side of issue after issue. Theyre on the wrong side of January 6. Theyre on the wrong side of investigating the insurrection. Theyre on the wrong side of just about everything. So what do they do, Katty Kaye . They, of course, act like the illiberal leader of hungary, a person that a lot of conservatives are praising now, and they love the fact that orbon has shut down any criticism from The Press, love that hes basically taken control of the courts, love that its no longer a democrat, its no longer a western democracy there. Thats what republicans want in california, thats what republicans want across the united states. Elections are only valid if they win. It certainly is what Tucker Carlson said when he went to hungary. Its not what you would think about as an american democracy, whats happening in hungary or poland, either. But claiming the election is rigged before the election has even happened is taking things to a new low in california, but is, in fact, Donald Trumps playbook. He spent the whole year before the election saying, this is going to get rigged. Its a bit the same way he kept telling his supporters from the beginning, The Press is the enemy of the people. Youre doing the same thing, undermining the freedom of The Press, but when you lose, it lets you turn around and say the media was against us. Thats what people used to say when they lost. Now theyre taking it one step further, candidates in the trump mode, the election was actually stolen from us. You wont see the same kind of outcry in california because hes so far behind in the polls, and the california libertarian interesting republican party in california is unlikely, i think, to behave the same Way Trump supporters did on January 6 here in washington, d. C. Its certainly a Model Theyve taken from Donald Trumps playbook. And i guess trumplike candidates are going to keep using that when they go into elections and start spreading it before the election actually happens so they can give themselves up for the result afterwards. Up next well stay in washington for the fight over Voting Rights. There are new developments this morning on the push for Election Integrity. What it might mean at the Ballot Box next november. But first, lets go right to bill karans for serious weather headed for texas. Now its headed for louisiana again today, mika. This time they made it to barely a hurricane category, one Status South of the Houston Area, and the storm is currently located over houston. The winds went on shore, knocked out power to about 300,000 people in texas, now all the Heavy Rain is headed to louisiana. We have 3 Million people under a flood watch. Very dangerous drives this morning on Interstate 10, especially, from houston all the way towards New Orleans. The new update from the hurricane center, the wind is now at 60 miles per hour and i hadnt seen additional Power Outages. But look at all the bright yellows and reds on this map. There is a lot of Heavy Rain in louisiana. Look at these numbers. Weve had eight landfalls already this year. We had 11 landfalls and tropical storms last year, so 19 total. On average we have three a season. We should have six in two years, not 19. So much damage has been taking place along the gulf coast. We still have tropical storm warnings from houston to galveston to Port Arthur and beaumont. Winds are not that bad right now, so very minor additional damage. Im not expecting any Wind Damage in beaumont or louisiana. Its all a big huge rain story, and the story is going to be how slowly this thing moves. Today about 250 miles. Watch out this evening, New Orleans, thats when the Heavy Rain is expected for you. Then tomorrow it drifts about 115 miles, and even into thursday, this storm is going to linger in this area, and thats why we can see bands and bands of rain in the New Orleans area. The forecast calls for upwards of 10 inches of rain from Lake Charles to New Orleans. Of course, these are the same people still recovering from only ida two weeks ago. There are still 100,000 people in louisiana from that storm, and now they have to deal with this today. Well keep you tuned in to that all Day Today and tomorrow on Morning Joe to let you know how it is in areas of louisiana. Other stories out there, washington, d. C. , it feels like the middle of summer. Hot and humid today. Well have more Coming Up here on Morning Joe. E Coming Up hee on Morning Joe. [sfx radio being tuned] welcome to allstate. [band plays] a place where everyone lives life wellprotected. And even when things go a bit wrong, weve got your back. Here, things work the way you wish they would. And better protection costs a whole lot less. Youre in good hands with allstate. Click or call for a lower Auto Rate today. My nunormal . Fewer Asthma Attacks with nucala. A oncemonthly addon injection for severe eosinophilic asthma. Nucala reduces eosinophils, a key cause of severe asthma. Nucala is not for sudden breathing problems. Allergic reactions can occur. Get help right away for swelling of face, mouth, Tongue Or Trouble breathing. Infections that can cause shingles have occurred. Dont stop steroids unless told by your doctor. Tell your doctor if you have a parasitic infection. May cause headache, Injection Site reactions, back pain, and fatigue. Ask your doctor about nucala. Find your nunormal with nucala. Hearing is important to living life to the fullest. Thats why inside every miracleear store, youll find a better life. It all starts with the most innovative technology. Like the new miracleearmini, available exclusively at miracleear. So small that no one will see it, but youll notice the difference. And now, miracleear is offering a thirtyday riskfree trial. You can experience better hearing with no obligation. Call 1800miracle right now and experience a better life. Wow, thats a low price. Wow, thats a low price. Huh. That is a low price. Whats a low price . Thats a low price. Im going to get it. Ahh, thats a low price. Can you let me shop . Hmm, thats a low price. Im gonna get it. At amazon, anytime is a good time to save. And there you have it woah. Wireless on the most reliable network nationwide. Im gonna get it. Wow big deal . We get unlimited for just 30 bucks. Sweet, but mine has 5g included. Relax people, my wireless is crushing it. Thats because you all have Xfinity Mobile with your internet. Its wireless so good, it keeps one upping itself. Switch to Xfinity Mobile and save hundreds on your wireless bill. Plus, save up to 400 when you purchase a new Samsung Phone or upgrade your existing phone. Learn more at your local xfinity store today. Democrats in the senate unveiled an updated Voting Rights bill. The freedom to vote act is backed by a Group Of Eight senators, including senator Joe Manchin of west virginia. The bill is an updated version of a framework released by Senator Manchin earlier this year. The legislation is split into three sections, Voter Access and election administration, Election Integrity and civic participatiOn And empower. Democrats want to act fast. Majority Leader Chuck Schumer says hell call a vote by next week. The republicanled war on democracy has only worsened in the last few weeks. Most notably, the governor of texas recently signed into law a vile new Voter Suppression Bill which is the least democratic in memory. They are providing vicious gerrymandering which further divides our politics. This is unacceptable. The senate must act. I intend to hold a vote in the senate early next week on voter legislation. Time, time is of the essence. And if youre going to cure gerrymandering or at least do their best to fix it, if theyre going to implement a lot of these changes, democrats still need at least ten republicans to join them to move the bill forward. In fact, the reauthorization of the civil Rights Voting Act in 2006 almost passed unanimously, but you cant even find one republican to vote for these Voting Rights Bills should tell us that were still whether its Manchins Bill or somebody elses bill, were still a long way from this passing unless there is some major Filibuster Reform. Yeah, joe, at the Risk Of being yelled at on twitter all day, this is a press release. I mean, yes, its important that democrats got 50 of their own lawmakers around this compromise, which was done by Amy Klobuchar and Joe Manchin. They are still, as you know, ten republicans short of getting this across the Finish Line in a republican conference where not one republican ive spoken to or that ive found believes that anything like this is necessary. So theyre not even singing from the same song sheet, theyre not working from the same set of facts, and unless there is some action to rework the filibuster which Joe Manchin and Kyrsten Sinema have said until their eyes have bled that theyre not interested in doing, then this is just going to be a vote that shows that all democrats are on the same page, but this is no closer to law in any way, shape or form. Jonathan lemire, is there any chance that after Joe Manchin is allowed to put out his bill and to do all the things that he thinks needs to be done, and if the republicans run over him again, just like the republicans ran over him on the January 6 commission, that he will work with the White House and others to put together a Filibuster Reform package, at least, for civil rights bills that will do the same thing for civil rights bills that Mitch Mcconnell did for Supreme Court nominees . There is a chance, joe. In fact, talks have intensified behind the scenes at the White House on this very subject matter. Senior aides ive talked to say that though no final decision has been made, there is growing momentum within the corridors of the West Wing and in the Oval Office to support some sort of Filibuster Change and work with those senators who have been resistant to that. Manchin is not alone, there are others. He is sort of the face of the more moderate democratic senators who have been resistant to say the size of the Infrastructure Package or the filibuster. As jake said, this is a press release. It doesnt really stand any chance of actual passage. We have heard from the president both publicly, and he has said privately to his closest advisors, that he is not in support of a full removal of the filibuster but is amenable to some sort of change, an amendment to it, a tweak to it, perhaps making it a talking point, or chaning it to a certain point. The Voting Rights is the greatest change to democracy since the civil war. There have been discussions now to let this play out over the next couple weeks. Then yes, i think we may see more talks about getting something out there to protect Voting Rights. While theyre working on that, theyre also talking about how to fund these big plans. Billionaires have avoided paying taxes for years. Will that change with this new legislation . That discussion is next on Morning Joe. Joe. Limu Emu Doug got a couple of bogeys on your six, limu. They need customized Car Insurance from Liberty Mutual so they only pay for what they need. What do you say we see what this bird can do . Woooooooooooooo. We are not getting you a helicopter. Looks like were walking, kid. Only pay for what you need. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. I became a Sofi Member because i needed to consolidate my credit card debt. I needed just one simple way to pay it all off. It was an easy decision to apply with sofi loans, just based on the Interest Rate and how much i would be saving. There was only one that stood out and one that actually made sense and that was sofi personal loans. It felt so freeing. I felt like i was finally out of this neverending trap of interest and payments and debt. Johnny 76 steelers. Ray 78 team was better. Ray we argue like its our job, but Medicare Advantage . Interest and payments and debt. That we agree on. Johnny 98 of the folks who use it give it. Johnny ray . High ratings. Ray cause its Got Record low premiums. Johnny they check in with me at home, gave you a ride to the doctor. Ray then covid showed up. Johnny but Medicare Advantage showed up too ray with that telehealth thing. Johnny food delivery. Ray i bet you like that. Its times like these that show who you can count on. Johnny if youre waiting for me to say i count on you. Announcer Medicare Advantage. Twenty six million seniors count on it. Democrats in the house presented a Plan Yesterday to pay for their own Social Policy and climate Change Package by raising taxes by more than 2 Trillion largely on wealthy people and profitable corporations. But this morning the New York times reports that plan, quote, stopped well short of changes needed to dent the vast fortunes of tycoons like Jeff Bezos or Elon Musk or to close the loopholes that aim to go for the merely rich rather than the fabulously rich. Senior house democrats opted to be more mindful of moderate concerns in their party than of its progressive ambitions. They focused on traditional ways of raising revenue by raising Tax Rates on income rather than targeting wealth itself. This is on one committee as it makes its way to congress. That doesnt get at the way the super wealthy and corporations make their money and avoid taxes. And we see it every year. I dont understand whats going on when you have the people writing the Tax Bill for the democrats saying theyre concerned about moderates concerns . Do they want Jeff Bezos and amazon to keep paying Zero Dollars . Is that a moderate concern or is that a Lobbyists Concern . Over the past few years, there are corporations that have paid zero taxes in a year, and just over the past couple years that includes amazon, chevron, avis, delta, e. I. Lily, honeywell, netflix, salesforce, u. S. Steel. Last Year Archer daniels, fedex, nike, On And On And on. Are moderates really concerned that those corporations may actually have to pay millions of dollars in taxes . Because right now theyre paying zero. And billionaires are continuing to figure out how to pay little or nothing. Hedge fund titans are paying taxes at lower rates than their clerical employees, and the people who show off their bentleys. Do you think Thats Demagoguery . No, its not. Thats a fact. Billionaires capital doesnt get taxed. Workers wages do. So now democrats in congress are saying we need to raise the taxes on people who are working but leave billionaires alone as they continue to amass capital and continue listen to me here listen to me here because everybody hates incumbent distribution. That makes you a socialist, doesnt it . If youre for a scheme that redistributes wealth, well, let me tell you something. In the World Weve lived in in the past 40 years, theres been the largest Income Redistribution scam in american history. And its been the Middle Class thats been looted while trillions keep flowing into the Bank Accounts of billionaires. Did you hear what i just said . Did you hear what i just said . This whole Income Redistribution thing we keep oh, you Cant Raise taxes on people. Because that will be Income Redistribution. Youre a socialist. Well, Guess What . The very people who are saying that, the very people who are funding Think Tanks that will say that, the very people that are paying the lobbyists to get the message out to say that, the very people who are spending millions and millions of dollars on lawyers and lobbyists on K Street who are saying that, theyre the people who have scammed you. Theyre the people whose monopolies continue to be untouched. They continue to be untouched all because they can buy the best lobbyists, they can buy the best lawyers, they can buy the best influencers on Capitol Hill across washington, d. C. And across wall street. Please. Please, democrats. Do better than that. Tax capital, take a dent on these super wealthy billionaires who keep accumulating, keep amassing fortunes. Because youre just when youre taxing income a little bit more, 2 here, 3 here, youre missing the target. If you want to make this country a fairer place, if you want to get us back to where we were before where there wasnt just such massive divergence between the super wealthy and the rest of americans, youre going to have to rewrite your Tax Plan. Because that one is just lousy. Katty kay, weve seen the super wealthy accumulate fortunes through capital, Capital Accumulation that is not taxed or taxed at extraordinarily low rates, where people who work for a living, people who have an income keep getting taxed at higher rates every year. Yeah, its kind of stunning that this is not a bigger conversation here in washingtOn And amongst the democratic party that taxing dividends and taxing capital, taxing wealth effectively rather than income is actually something youre going to make some kind of dent on what has been incredibly rapidly growing inequality in this country. Youve had people like Warren Buffett over the years who have said this has to stop. Warren buffett one of the super wealthy people in this country have said you have to go after wealth, you have to go after dividends because its just not fair that he is paying, as he says, less than his secretary is paying in terms of taxes. When you keep fiddling around with the marginal rate on incomes going from 37 to 39, youre just not going to get there. You will squeeze those people who are wealthier who are taking back, you know, 400, 500, 600,000 a year, but youre not going to touch the ones who dont have income. Coming up, for those fleeing the country is just half the battle. Many face challenges once theyre out, and thats where our next guest comes in. That discussion just ahead on Morning Joe. Ahead on Morning Joe. I order my groceries online now. Shingles doesnt care. I keep my social distance. Shingles doesnt care. I stay within my family bubble. Shingles doesnt care. Because if youve had chicken pox, youre already carrying the virus that causes shingles. In fact, about 1 in 3 people will develop shingles, and the risk only increases as you age. So what can protect you against shingles . Shingrix protects. Now you can protect yourself from shingles with a vaccine proven to be over 90 effective. Shingrix is a vaccine used to prevent shingles in adults 50 years and older. Shingrix does not protect everyone and is not for those with severe allergic reactions to its ingredients or to a previous dose. An increased Risk Of Guillainbarre Syndrome was observed after vaccination with shingrix. The most common Side Effects are pain, redness, and swelling at the Injection Site, muscle pain, tiredness, headache, shivering, fever, and upset stomach. Talk to your Pharmacist Or Doctor about protecting yourself with shingrix. Shingles doesnt care. But we do. After decades of big pollution liars, climate change deniers, and outofcontrol fires were almost there. Congress is close to passing a clean Energy Plan that tackles climate Change Head on by creating millions of goodpaying jobs in the fastest growing industries. We can lower utility bills for Families Today while protecting the planet our children inherit tomorrow. Congress, our window to act is closing and once it does, it may never open again. Act on climate change, now. man my ex is dating a pisces. woman in van set your intentions. man sitting crystals up. woman cleanse and find your magic. Let it go huh, huh let it go some breaking news just in to us from the associated prss, the kremlin said vladimir putin is going into isolation because of issues within his inner circle. The covid drive in russia has lacked than other countries. 20 have been fully vaccinated. The russian leader is, quote, absolutely healthy. Putin is fully vaccinated with Russias Version of the vaccine, mika. And here in the united states, the husband of a California Nurse who died of complications from covid19 more than two weeks ago has now died after battling the disease himself, leaving behind five young children, including a newborn. Dovvy mesias was 37 and Daniel Mesias was 39. The couple leave behind five children, ages 7, 5, 3, 2 and three weeks. Dovvy mesias was unvaccinated. She said she did so because she was pregnant, her sisterinlaw told Nbc News. It was unclear if daniel was vaccinated. The cdc urged all pregnant women to get vaccinated, two weeks before Dovvy Mesias death. Daniel mesias wanted to wait before naming their newborn daughter. Their now threeweekold daughter remains unnamed. All five of these children are being cared for by their grandparents. On Capitol Hill today, Secretary Of State Antony Blinken will testify before the Senate Committee to answer questions about the u. S. Withdrawal from afghanistan. The day after he did the same before the house foreign affairs committee. While there is still concern for those who remain in afghanistan under taliban rule, the last member of afghanistans jewish community has been evacuated from the country, but one jewish organization is urging the biden administration to get more people out who are at risk. In a usa today oped, Rabbi Berkowitz of the jewish Family Service draws stark comparison of people in afghanistan under the taliban and the horrors the jewish people went through during the holocaust. He says it is a moral duty to help those left behind. Rabbi berkovitz joins us now. I appreciate you being on with us. First of all, tell us about the people that your organization has heard from. Youre hearing directly from them, people who are scared and who are telling you what is behind their fears. Can you share that with us . Sure, absolutely. Thank you for having me on. We have 123 people, roughly 73 of their are children that have been left behind. They are in hiding. They are moving from house to house to really play hide and seek, a deadly game with the taliban, trying to stay safe. Theyre running out of money. They are reporting to us that they are seeing witness to execution in the streets, theyve witnessed beatings, and obviously that is really tremendously increasing the fear. Theyre afraid to go out. If they go out, theyre afraid theyll be caught, and its untenable for this to continue. We are just working with 123, but we know there are hundreds of thousands of people that are there. So, now, are you talking specifically about americans or afghans who worked with the united states of america, or how broad does this group of people go in terms of what you are saying is our duty . Yeah, i am talking specifically about people who worked with coalition forces, people who worked for the united States Government. These are people who we are responsible to. We made promises to them. We have put them at risk, and we have an obligation to help get them out. We need to really cut through the politics of this, we need to work together as a country. I believe firmly we need to have a person, a czar, appointed specifically to work with those people left behind to work with coalition forces. Were talking about people to work with coalition forces and their families who are at risk because they worked with coalition forces. I was at pentagon last week and talking with Admiral Kirby and other folks there that theyre trying, theyre doing everything they can, working with this sort of precarious relationship with the Taliban And Qatar stepping up to try and get people out. What more should the administration be doing . What are you seeing that is lacking . Well, we know theyve gotten a couple flights out, because thats been widely reported that theyve gone to qatar. The concern, or the question i have, is if theyve done that, why cant they do more . They need to create a safe passage, they need to not only get people to the airport, they need to get them out of the airport. If they need to work with a third country to get processing, we should do that. If they need to create vetting in that third country, they should do that. If they need to significantly increase the number of people doing that vetting and providing those visas, they should do that. I think we have the capacity as a country. Were the united states. However, i dont think were putting a Point Person in charge who is working im talking again about a czar of some kind who is working with all the different departments to really work through the work streams to make sure there is somebody managing the diplomatic side across all the countries. There is someone managing communication with the families. We have people who are getting fake messages from the taliban trying to get them to come out of hiding. Thats not tenable. We need to help folks actually get to this country. In addition, we have a family who is in hiding in pakistan because when the embassy closed, the embassy destroyed their passports and they never returned them. So they had to sneak across the border into pakistan, but the u. S. Embassy in pakistan has yet to return or to reissue some travel papers. Again, were talking about their afghan passport, let alone some sort of united States Documentation at this point. I think there are many fronts that this could be done. Rabbi berkovitz, could you give our audience an idea of what its like to try to help some of these families in afghanistan with no american contact and no american presence on the ground in a talibancontrolled country . How do you even begin to do that . One of the things i think we really need is a way and i think the united states is well positioned for this to help people understand the difference between fact and fiction. There is a tremendous amount of rumors. We get these messages of people in fear here that this is happening or that is happening. Were trying to determine what is real and give them actionable information or tell them its not happened. And i think the united States Government could really help with that effort as well. Right now its a coalition of really just people like our organization, like myself, like my colleagues really just trying to communicate what is real. People are very afraid, and theyre more and more afraid each day that passes, because whats happening is the taliban is going to their former homes and ransacking them. What that means is they Cant Return to their homes because they know theyre being tracked, and they feel like time is running out. I think that we need a Point Person really coordinating all of these efforts across all the various departments. I think its been a great effort thats been done so far, but its efficient it is necessary but not sufficient. Rabbi, just to clarify, the taliban had at one point said that they would not be taking reprisals against people who had worked with the coalition forces. From what youre Hearing Today in afghanistan, that doesnt seem to be the case. Youre hearing that the taliban is taking reprisals and is acting dangerously towards people who worked for the coalition, that their lives are at risk because they worked with the coalition. Is that correct . Absolutely. We utterly cannot listen to the word of the Taliban And Trust that thats whats happening. Theyre trying to gain standing on a world stage, but our folks are sending us voice messages, text messages, photos. We have pictures of the dead, we have video of people being beaten on the street, women being attacked and beaten and slashed. Under no circumstances would i believe that the taliban is saying anything close to true, and that is because they served with coalition forces. If they served with coalition forces, theyre being thrown in the back of trunks of cars and driven away. Thrown in the back of trunks of cars and driven away and not heard from. So we know that what theyre saying is utterly not true, which is why we need our government to really put a Point Person in place, and that Point Person can then communicate with us, because we and all the other folks that are like our organization are just trying to understand what is happening, what is the plan, whats the status of various visas that are in place, who is coordinating all of these efforts, how can we get people to the airport safely, how can we get them on these planes which we know are taking off. Secretary blinken said yesterday they have appointed a person in charge, or theyre about to, to manage womens issues. I think thats extraordinarily important. We need a Point Person specifically to manage all areas of the operation to get people out of afghanistan. These are our allies. These are people who served as interpreters. These are people who put their lives at risk because of us, to save and to help save our own military on the ground. We owe it to these people. They feel betrayed if we dont. We as a country have to really question our integrity if we dont really step up. Thats not to say there hasnt been tremendous efforts being done, there has, it just needs to be more, it needs to be more coordinated. I would suggest that that Czar Report to the White House directly. It is clear that there is just too much on Secretary Blinkens plate. I also want to call on all of those who will be in the Hearing Today to ask really concrete questions. Stop with the politics, stop with the point scoring, and lets just try to actually do whats right. Lets hold up our moral obligatiOn And lets help get our allies into safety. Rabbi will berkovitz, thank you very much for coming on the show this morning. We really appreciate it. Up next, the leading republican looking to replace Governor Gavin Newsom in todays Recall Election is already claiming Election Fraud . Really. Well talk about a new renewed call to hold those pushing bogus election claims accountable. Keep it right here on Morning Joe. Keep it right here on Morning Joe. Tech every customer has their own safelite story. This couple was on a camping trip. When their windshield got a chip. They drove to safelite for a sameday repair. And with their insurance, it was no cost to them. Woman really . Tech thats service you can trust. Singers safelite repair, safelite replace. Hey lily, i need a new Wireless Plan for my business, but all my employees need something different. Oh, we can help with that. Okay, imagine this. Your mover, rob, hes on the scene and needs a plan with a mobile hotspot. We cut to downtown, your Sales Rep Lisa has to send some files, like asap so basically i can pick the right plan for each employee. Yeah i shouldve just led with that. With at t business, you can pick the best plan for each employee and get the best deals on every smartphone. Finding new routes to reach your customers, and new ways for them to reach you. Is what business is all about. Its what the United States Postal Service has always been about. So as your business changes, were changing with it. With ecommerce that runs at the speed of now. Next Day And Twoday shipping nationwide. Same Day Shipping across town. Returns right from the doorstep, and deliveries seven days a week. Its a whole New World out there. Lets not keep it waiting. My plaque psoriasis. The itching. The burning. The stinging. My skin was no longer mine. My psoriatic arthritis, made my joints stiff, swollen. Painful. Emerge tremfyant™. With tremfya®, adults with moderate to severe plaque psoriasis. Can uncover clearer skin and improve symptoms at 16 weeks. Tremfya® is the only medication of its kind also approved for adults with active psoriatic arthritis. Serious allergic reactions may occur. Tremfya® may increase your Risk Of infections and lower your ability to fight them. Tell your doctor if you have an infection or symptoms or if you had a Vaccine Or Plan to. Tremfya®. Emerge tremfyant™. Janssen can help you explore Cost Support options. Ive lost count of how many Asthma Attacks ive had. Tremfya®. Emerge tremfyant™. But my nunormal with nucala . Fewer Asthma Attacks. Nucala is a oncemonthly addon injection for severe eosinophilic asthma. Not for sudden breathing problems. Allergic reactions can occur. Get help right away for swelling of face, mouth, tongue, or trouble breathing. Infections that can cause shingles have occurred. Dont stop steroids unless told by your doctor. Tell your doctor if you have a parasitic infection. May cause headache, injectionsite reactions, back pain, and fatigue. Ask your doctor about nucala. Find your nunormal with nucala. Why bother mastering something . Why handtune an audio system . Why include the most advanced active Safety System in its class. Standard . Because when you want to create an entirely new feeling, the difference between Excellence And Mastery is all the difference in the world. The lexus es. Every curve, every innovation, every feeling. A product of mastery. Get 1. 9 Apr Financing on the 2021 es 350. Experience amazing at your lexus dealer. Welcome back to Morning Joe. As California Voters go to the Polls Today to decide the political future of Governor Gavin Newsom, the leading republican in the Recall Election Larry Elder is already claiming newsom won, but fraud was detected in the results. The Election Hasnt taken place yet. When elder was asked about this by Nbc News, he repeatedly refused to say if he would accept results of the election. Similar to what we saw leading up to the 2020 election, when Donald Trump was asked again and again if he would accept results if he lost. As of this morning, he still has not. Yeah. Ahead of the 2020 election, News Week Editor in chief Tom Rogers wrote lawyers should be held accountable by State Bar associations for helping to push his false claims. Now ahead of todays Recall Election, tom is calling for more penalties against those attorneys. The new piece is cowritten with former senator tim worth. Tom joins us now. Tom, this is part of the framework of the legal system, that lawyers need to be held to account as well, especially if they do corrupt work. How would this work. How is it not working. What still needs to happen . Thanks for having me, mika. It is clear it has become a central Organizing Principle of republican Politics Today to get people convinced that election results shouldnt be believed, and lawyers who are the foot soldiers in these efforts need to be held responsible with the most severe consequences. Bar associations didnt heed warnings that they ought to caution people before the electiOn And you saw what happened. Last month we had a terrific opinion out of a federal judge in michigan who sanctioned nine of the trump lawyers, including Sidney Powell and Lynn Wood for participation in putting forward lies to try to create a record to me. They wanted a record what state legislatures used to overturn elections in swing states. Not only sanctioned, the judge referred all nine of those cases to the underlying Licensing Board in the states where those lawyers are licensed to practice law saying disbarment proceedings should be considered by those State Bars. Thats an important decision. The issue is that these lawyers licensed in texas, georgia, nevada, michigan, there are devout republicans at the highest levels of bar disciplinary boards and Bar Associations. It is clear whether the disbarment proceedings which should go forward are going to happen. And what needs perhaps to be added in framework, is there legislation to make sure that lawyers like this are held accountable. And this is happening now, we are hearing percolations of it in california. I mean, are we looking at a trend, and what are you concerned about there . Well, this needs to be dealt with at the State Level with State Bar associations and disciplinary boards. New york is showing the way, the Appeals Court and Grievance Committee and New York Bar Association has begun disciplinary proceedings against former mayor giuliani for his participation in the January 6th riots among other things, so there clearly are states taking these responsibilities very clearly. Weve got to make sure all lawyers of integrity, and i am a lawyer, i dont believe thats oxymoron, all lawyers of integrity in these states need to step up and make sure disciplinary proceedings go forward. Disbarment is actually a result. Because 2020 was just a warmup for 2024. And while we have federal legislations being considered to deal with some of these things as you talked about earlier, the filibuster needing to be overturned by no means sure to get federal results, and the state legislatures controlled by republicans are setting up apparatus to overturn legitimate election results again and lawyers again will be the foot soldiers in those efforts. If the most severe consequences arent imposed, there wont be the disincentives against doing these things come the next election. Editor at large at newsweek. Good to have you on this morning. We have a few moments left for final thoughts. Willie geist. Im going back to the interview with dr. Fauci a couple hours ago. He said something, Mike Barnicle, about the unvaccinated. Laid out health risks, even if youre healthy of not having the vaccine, and then went on to say something larger. Quote, it isnt all about you. Youre not in a vacuum. Youre part of a society. Making the case that you dont want the vaccine, okay. But what about the kids, what about the teachers, what about the people in your community. And we had a dreadful example of what happens when people ignore advice to get vaccines. Mika just presented the story of the young woman in california pregnant, doesnt get vaccinated. Shes now dead from the virus. Her husband died from the same virus that we are all threatened by two weeks later. They left five young children now being cared for by grandparents. Get vaccinated. The grandparents say the kids are running around saying where are mom and dad, where are mom and dad, they cant understand theyre not coming home. One just three weeks old. That story is so sad. I think about what the rabbi said, a case for why america needs to carry on helping allies. Lets hope the Secretary Of States get some of that on in the senate when he is testifying. Thank you all. That does it for us this morning. Stephanie ruhle picks up coverage right now. Hi there, i am Stephanie Ruhle live at Msnbc World headquarters in new York City. It is tuesday, september 14th. This morning, we are following several major stories. Overnight, two of the fda top vaccine experts arguing against the need for Booster Shots now, despite a push from the White House to roll them out in the next few months. This as we get shocking new infection numbers among children. In our nations capital, tony blinken back in the hot seat. The secretary of State Set to testify before the senate in the next hour after a day of grilling from house members over the chaotic exit from afghanistan. The congressman who led that hearing will be here soon. And moments ago, we got the latest report on inflation, the rise in prices may be starting to cool down. Hallelujah, praise the lord. We have to start in the state of california where today is election day. 40 Million people are waking up to a rare recall and they have until 8 00 p. M