I dont favor gain of Function Research in china. Youre saying things that are not correct. Youre fooling with Mother Nature here. Youre allowing super viruses to be created with a 15 mortality. Its very dangerous. And is a huge mistake to share this with china and a huge mistake to allow this to continue in the United States. We should be very careful to investigate where this virus came from. I fully agree you should investigate where the virus came from, but again we have not funded gain of Function Research on this virus in the Wuhan Institute of virology no matter how many times youre parsing words. There was research ripped from the pages of qanon. Why is he doing this to himself . I dont know why he does. Its really strange. Its more than strange. Its disturbing. Its part of a bigger picture. Dr. Anthony fauci pushing back on saturday rand pauls allegation that the National Institutes of health had been funding the chinese lab in wuhan. Willie, we have been watching this now for six months. Its really strange that a guy that has a doctor at the front of his name for some reason seems to go further out there than anybody else. Here basically, you know, sounding like some qanon protagonist. Rand paul is a doctor. Dr. Fauci is the chief boogieman for Conspiracy Theories. We know this. Weve known this for over a year. There are all kinds of theories. We dont need to run through them again. But theyre not just in the darkest corners of the internet. They found their way on to prominent cable news shows where dr. Fauci is being called a criminal. There should be investigations into them and what you see in our culture now is that talk online and on Cable News Spill Over into congress where a United States senator is willing to take those ideas and those theories, run with them and confront dr. Fauci himself with that information. Those were extraordinary exchanges yesterday. Along with joe, willie and me, we have cofounder of punch bowl news, anna palmer, the host of nbcs Politic Nation and president of the National Action network, reverend al sharpton. And White House Reporter for the associated press, Jonathan Lemire is at the white house for us this morning. Good to you all. Great to have you all. Mika, i just got a sense last night when watching liz cheney that we were watching in One Way Or Another a piece of history. Its not being mellow dramatic. As a conservative, you look back to those moments where somebody steps into the limelight and leads a movement. I think about reagan in 1966. I think about Margaret Thatcher in 1975 in britain. And her address before the conservative party. She sort of sweeps away the lecturn. And shows everybody who is in control there. Liz cheney could well be that person in 2021, but the question is for what party because the party that shes a member of, that i was a member of, that Ronald Reagan was a member of, that party no longer exists. Its a party that, well, forget about ideology. Its a party thats antidemocratic and that refuses and is taking its position, its Future Position is being a party that will refuse to accept democrats winning elections if they dont like the outcome, they wont accept the Election Results is certainly, certainly what it seems if you look at arizona and you look at whats happening in House Of Representatives with the Republican Caucus. This was something incredible to watch. Ive been in a huddle with the forbes team over the past few weeks looking at women over 50, thousands of submissions of remarkable women who have done remarkable things. But this is different. To see her standing out there alone, republicans left, they left the hall because they didnt want to be, i guess, rebuked or embarrassed, or they were too weak to sit there and listen to the truth. House republicans are expected to vote this morning to remove her, to get her out of their way. Congresswoman liz cheney, from her post as conference chair. Gop lawmakers will meet Behind Closed Doors at 9 00 a. M. Thats when a member will need to bring up a vote of no confidence against cheney. The vote will be held by Secret Ballot and a simple majority will be needed to remove her from her Leadership Position. Last night, ahead of the vote, congresswoman cheney spoke On The House Floor. God has blessed america, mr. Speaker. But our freedom only survives if we protect it. If we honor our oath taken before god in this chamber to support and defend the constitution. If we recognize threats to freedom when they arise. Today we face a threat america has never seen before. A former president , who provoked a violent attack on this capitol, in an effort to steal the election has resumed his aggressive effort to convince americans that the election was stolen from him. He risks inciting further violence. Millions of americans have been misled by the former president. They have heard only his words but not the truth. As He Continuings to undermine our democratic process, sewing seeds of doubt about whether democracy really works at all. I am a conservative republican, and the most conservative of conservative principles is reverence for the rule of law. The Electoral College has voted. More than 60 state and Federal Courts including multiple judges the former president appointed have rejected his claims. The Trump Department of justice investigated the former president s claims of widespread fraud and found no evidence to support them. The election is over. That is the rule of law. That is our constitutional process. Those who refuse to accept the rulings of our courts are at war with the constitution. Our duty is clear. Every one of us who has sworn the oath must act to prevent the unraveling of our democracy. This is not about policy. This is not about partisanship. This is about our duty as americans. Remaining silent and ignoring the lie emboldens the liar. I will not participate in that. I will not sit back and watch in silence while others lead our party down a path that abandons the rule of law and joins the former president s crusade to undermine our democracy. As the party of rang, republicans are championed democracy, won the cold war and defeated the soviet communists. Today, america is on the cusp of another cold war, this time with communist china. Attacks against our democratic process and the rule of law empower our adversaries and feed communist propaganda that American Democracy is a failure. We must speak the truth. Our election was not stolen and america has not failed. I received a message last week from a gold star father who said standing up for the truth honors all who gave all. We must all strive to be worthy of the sacrifice of those who have died for our freedom. They are the patriots, Katherine Lee baits described in the words of America The Beautiful when she wrote, oh beautiful for heros proved in liberating strife. Who more than self their country loved and mercy more than life. Ultimately, mr. Speaker, this is at the heart of what our oath requires. That we love our country more. That we love her so much that we will stand above politics to defend her. That we will do everything in our power to protect our constitution and our freedom that has been paid for by the blood of so many. We must love america so much that we will never yield in her defense. That is our duty. Thank you. So willie, freedom only survives if we protect it. We must speak the truth. The election was not stolen. America has not failed. And if Donald Trumps attempt to undermine democracy as liz cheney said on the floor of the peoples house last night, she simply said, i will not participate. That had the feel of a political eulogy. It sounded like liz cheney was standing there remembering a party that no longer exists, talking about the cold war and Ronald Reagan and the bushes and Everything Else that came afterward and reminding conservatives none of whom were in the room they walked out except for Congressman Ken Buck in colorado perhaps in shame, they didnt want to be confronted with her message, that she was reminding them of what it meant to be a conservative, rule of law was at the top of the list. And anna palmer, as you listen to that, you cant help but think who else is with her. Really in their hearts. Most of them are going to vote against her at 9 00 a. M. This morning. Knock her out of her Leadership Position. But i think part of the reason they didnt want to hear that message is because they know that shes right but they cant afford to come out and say it in public and dare cross donald trump, despite the fact that what shes standing up for is a free and Fair Election. Saying that it was not stolen. Joe biden is president. And donald trump is lying to you. Yeah. I think she gives voice to where a lot of actual House Republicans are when they talk privately to you they dont agree with what the former president is doing. But i think theres two calculations that House Republicans have made. Theyre making the point that, one, in the shortterm it is not good for them and their individual political gains to go up against this president. Theres a real fear of the fact that donald trump might support primary challenger. And the second is that her speaking like this is not helpful to them gaining the majority in 2022. I think the political calculation is very simple along those two lines. The big problem for House Republicans is that liz cheney is going to speak like this. Shes untethered. She wont be part of the leadership. Have anything trying to reign her in. And she we have been talking to folks, i expect her to continue to speak like this plainly, loudly, on these same Talking Points for the weeks and months to come which will be a major problem for republicans. Jonathan lemire, in February Of 2016 i wrote a column for the Washington Post and in it i talked about when donald trump feigned ignorance of the kkk and when he feigned ignorance of david duke and even pretended he didnt know who david duke was. At that point, it had become evident that the Republican Party was going all in for him. I asked the question at the end of that column in February Of 2016, is this where the party of Abraham Lincoln dies . And time and time again over the past four years, i thought the Republican Party would turn away from donald trump, was wrong time and time again. And now this is where weve gotten where liz cheney stands alone On The House Floor supporting the basic proposition that republicans should not embrace a big lie that they know is a big lie. That Rudy Giuliani admitted in Federal Court was a big lie. That Donald Trumps administration admitted it was a big lie when they said it was the safest the most honest election, words to that effect ever run. And yet there is Liz Cheney Standing On The House Floor alone because republicans cant be seen with her telling the most basic of truths that every trump judge that was appointed to the Supreme Court, every trump judge that was appointed to the circuit courts, every trump judge that was appointed to the District Courts all said the same thing. There was no widespread voter fraud. Joe biden won this election. And yet for her simply repeating that truth, shes there alone making this declaration of conscience. It is incredible, joe, that we are here. What liz cheney stood up for last night is the foundation of our democracy. The idea that we have fair and free elections and that we honor their results. And if you lose power, you step away from power. That is set in the very beginning. That is set from the very beginning of this constitution and this republic. And now that is under fire. And she defended the very basic principle and she stood, as you said, alone. And there have been so many moments where the Republican Party could have walked away from the big lie. They could have walked away from donald trump and they had their chance. It looked like for maybe 24 hours they might have. When january 6th happened. The insurrection at the capitol. The violent mob in Donald Trumps name stormed the citadel of democracy. Lives were lost. And for 24 hours or so, it looked like republicans might use that as their breaking point. And at least a lot of them, if not all of them, would walk away from donald trump. Those who have are absolutely in the minority. And his power over the party seems to have only grown in recent weeks. Even though he lost. The party has lost control of the house and the senate. But the Republican Party, the vast, vast majority of them are tethering themselves to him. And even if hes not a candidate again and theres real questions about that but what he stands for. His followers. Trumpism. And part of what he stands for is not telling the truth and not honoring the results of an election. So liz cheney, yeah, as anna said, shell be bounced quickly and quietly today. Shes not going to go away. Sh still going to tk out. There are a few other republicans, senator kinzinger, romney who join her in that but they are without question outnumbered and the others, the republicans who have tied themselves to trump, who keep propagating the big lie, they are only growing in number and they have complete sway over where this Republican Party is going in the 2022 and 24, making us all wonder will they ever honor the result of an election again. Well, and that was the point that bob gates brought up on the show that one election is not going to fix trumpism and what has happened to this country and that our place around the world is going to be viewed on how we handle things moving forward, do we slip back. Latest piece for new York Magazine is entitled liz cheneys liberal are missing the piece. Support for democracy ought to be separated from policy outcomes. Republicans should not succumb to the temptation of siding with the would be awe her to tear ran merely because he promised to advance their policy goals. Hell undermine the constitution but give us low Capital Gains taxes and friendly judges is not a morally defensible tradeoff. Democracy is the one question not subject to horsetrading. When cheneys liberal critics place her support for democracy alongside her other positions they implicitly endorse the same calculation made by her conservative opponents that the rule of law is another issue. The only way democracy survives is if both sides respect the outcome of a free and Fair Election as a precondition to all their other disagreements. Democracy is a system for maintaining domestic peace. You make peace with your enemies, not your friends. You know, rev, this is such an important piece. It reminds me what ive learned over the past year and learned it. Ann applebalm coming on your morning joeed what were experiencing now happened in 2014 and 2015 and started happening in hungary. We can look and see whats happened with the erosion of democracy. With the erosion of the rule of law. In those european powers now. And its very clear. They brag about being ill liberal democracies. And this is a battle now. We are in a political fight and its between those who believe in democracy and those who believe in ill liberal democracy. And last night, regardless of what position she took in the past, just like regardless of positions that progressives took in the past that i did not like. Those of us who believe in free and Fair Elections and dont want to lie about American Democracy and lie about american institutions and dont want to lie about the last election being stolen, were all on the same side. Whether some progressives writing for the New York Times like it or not. Absolutely. Were on the side of democracy and truth. Now, we may have different interpretations of how we ought to handle that democracy and what we want to bring in the democratic process to win in a policy debate. But at the end of the day we all want democracy and we all want the will of the people and the majority of those people to be respected. What were seeing happen this morning is really sad for all sides because were seeing someone remove from a position of influence because they will not embrace a lie. Were not talking about a policy. Were not talking about a position. Were talking about you will not go along with what we know and have proven to be a lie therefore you are punishable. And i think the real question is if they continue in this vain, i think the writer is right. Will democracy mean anything at all . Because when you can now say we will proclaim an election result to be what we say it is whether it is that or not you no longer have a democracy. Youre being ruled by a mob on your way to an autocracy. And that is what is being decided 9 00 a. M. This morning whether they are going to continue to go that way. This is dick cheneys daughter. This is someone that voted over 90 with donald trump. And they would remove her because she wont go along with a lie . They have gone way beyond the pail here. She is so much more conservative than Elise Stefanik or whoever Elise Stefanik who wants to take her position. Elise stefanik who wants to take her position. Shes so much more conservative. But willie, as ive been saying for years, it doesnt matter if youre conservative or not, not with these republicans. Ideology stopped mattering a long time ago. It became about tribalism. I want to say about if youre a liberal out there and you want to write that oped about liz cheney and you dont forgive her, let me just let you know right now, you can write it if you think its click bait. Liz cheney doesnt care. Thats not what this is about. In the immortal words of pete townsend, im sure shes not thinking about the immortal words of pete townsend. Shes not made to be forgiven. People on twitter when i will Say Something conservative, idealogically about the budgets being too big or talk about how we need to toughen things up at the southern border. Youre just the same as youve always been. Willie, i never said i changed. I just support liberal democracy. Liz cheney just supports liberal democracy. Bernie sanders just supports liberal democracy. Elizabeth warren just supporting a liberal democracy. Its like a british war cabinet. Yes, when things are not dire, Winston Churchill fought like hell. But when it was time to put a war cabinet together, that war cabinet came together and today liz cheney and democrats are all fighting this same fight. And they need to recognize that now as jonathan says or else were all this big trouble. Yeah. I think there are a lot of people signaling their virtue on twitter, shes bad and her dad is bad. What if we could do this, hold both ideas in your head. On the one hand you disagree with almost every vote shes ever taken and all of her Policy Proposals and glad someone is standing up for the democracy of the country. One person at least is saying this was a free and Fair Election. It wasnt stolen. We ought to stop saying that. What if you could do that. Lets bring into the conversation, senior political reporter for Morning Consult, eli yokley. Theres a new poll on liz cheneys impending removal from her Leadership Position. Eli, good morning. What do the numbers tell you about how republicans are feeling about this decision today . The numbers say Republican Voters want her gone. Half of Republican Voters in our poll said the House Republican conference should remove her today. Only one in five Republican Voters said she should stay. Theres a little divide among genders. Trump voters were more likely than the average republican voter say she should go. Her biggest block of supporters in this poll, democrats. 6 in 7 democrats said liz cheney should stay on as conference chair. I guess these numbers arent completely surprising given the level of support President Trump still has within the Republican Party. What about the independent number there . What does that tell you . Independents are on her side generally. Liz cheney is not a popular figure within the Republican Party. A lot of support is coming from democrats to some extent who are supporting her bid. Liz cheney lost the Republican Voters earlier this year. When she came into 2021, a lot of Republican Voters nationwide really didnt know who she was. After january 6th she came out for Donald Trumps impeachment and her numbers sunk among Republican Voters. Similar thing happened with Mitch Mcconnell after the january 6th riots. His numbers sunk under water. But he has stopped talking about donald trump, the most popular man in republican politics and seen his stock rise with Republican Voters. Liz cheney kept talking and its stayed down. One of these jobs will keep their job at the end of the today probably. Anna palmer, theres more than just the National Polls of republicans which actually show that an overwhelming number want her gone. Theres also, of course, sort of the inside outside game. It is awfully perilous for the Republican House caucus to go off the side of the cliff when the Wall Street Journal Editorial Page is blasting them for doing it, when peggy is blasting them for doing it. When Business Leaders are blasting them for doing it. When longtime establishment allies are blasting them for doing it. They ran afoul after january 6th and a lot of Lobbying Interests said they couldnt give money to house members for quite some time. This is a really isolating move for Kevin Mccarthy. A really isolating move for this house gop caucus. Have you talked to any leaders that understand that . I think its reflective of the change of where the power base or House Republicans in particular are. Its not those folks you just mentioned the typical when i came in almost 20 years ago to cover politics, it was what do Business Leaders think, what do some of those folks in the Wall Street Journal Editorial Page think. Most House Republicans feel the base of the party, the enthusiasm of the party for donald trump isnt with people that arent with that kind of establishment wing of the party. I think there is peril there in terms of the longterm value of the Republican Party and also when you look at what does this mean for elections Going Forward . Donald trump has won one election. He lost the senate. He lost the house. And he lost Georgia Senate races for republicans. This is going to be an issue they have to wrestle with Going Forward. Eli, looking at these numbers and your reporting about where the Republican Party is right now n terms of where are you seeing its never too early to look at 2022 and 2024 as to where some of the top contenders stand, where republicans see in terms of the Map Reclaiming perhaps majority next year in the mid terms but the trump effect as we pivot towards the next president ial election. How much of an overwhelming favorite is he if he were to run again and if he doesnt, what does the rest of the field look like . Donald trump is the favorite in all the polling we have done. Majority of Republican Voters say he should be the nominee and more say he should play a bigger role in the Republican Party. How does he reach these folks . He doesnt have twitter account or facebook. He has a blog but only one in five Republican Voters say theyll look for it according to our latest poll. You listen to the campaigns right now, theres a candidate in ohio who launched his Campaign Based on impeachment. Im here in missouri right now and reporting on the senate race. Everybody is just looking for that donald trump endorsement. Hes hanging over these candidates because they see the same polling we see that say 8 in 10 Republican Voters like this guy. They want him to be involved in this party. And thats going to hang over the campaigns of 2022 a lot. All right, eli, Morning Consult, thank you so much for bringing us those polls this morning. Appreciate it. Mika, lets underline what were talking about here because its been shot through the political prism so many times since january 6th. The subject has been changed so many times. Were talking about a lie that was born online. The flames were fanned by President Trump. An attack on the United States capitol. There was an attack on the United States capitol, something we have not seen, of course, in our life times or many life times back. And now what were seeing today is a vote against someone who is saying thats bad. We cant allow that in our party. We cant allow that in our country. And she will stand alone with maybe a small handful of other republicans in saying that was a bad thing that happened. We cant allow it to happen again. She now is in the extreme, the Mainstream Position is january 6th was okay. Well, washington is not well right now at all. Later on in the show were going to be talking about dialect kal thinking and the type of therapy that could help a lot of people. But in this case, liz cheney requires dialectcal thinking. You can be against her positions and all of her votes along the way, but you also can see her right now as a vision, a tiny ray of hope in what has become a sea of cowards, a sea of men and some women who are abandoning our constitution and our country. And that this sort of corruption has a grip of the Republican Party and she is standing out as a ray of hope for our democracy. You can think two things at once about liz cheney, but if you believe in truth and our democracy, joe, you have to be able to see both of those things in order to see what she is doing right now. Well, and thats what ive been doing for the past several years. I mean, you can if youre in my position, supporting what democrats do, that pushes donald trump back requires dialectical thinking. Two things can be true at once. I can prove progressive economic policies would be ruinist to the United States of america. And we can argue that. And we can debate that. And i can say they spend too much money. They want to tax too much. They want to regulate too much. And lit undermine American Democracy. But on the other side i can say at the same time, no but. Im sorry. Will undermine not American Democracy but will undermine americas economy. And throw millions and millions of people out of work. At the same time, i can say theyre on my side when it comes to defending democracy, to pushing back against these Conspiracy Theories, to recognizing the Election Results, just like they did. The overwhelming majority of them did when george w. Bush got elected twice. When george h. W. Got elected, Ronald Reagan got elected twice. Yes, we can hold two thoughts in our mind at the same time. And one might be more prevalent at the moment. I think thats where were trying to help people understand whats at stake. I think people think because donald trump lost the election and some people might believe he didnt, that its over. Its not over. In fact, the fact that this big lie continues is a bad sign. Jonathans point is so important, which is, if you say oh, im not going to listen to liz cheney now because of all of these other votes she did in the past. Then youre acting like republicans who are saying all things are equal. We are going to do whatever we can to get the judges we want in. Get the taxes we want in, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera, again, hold two separate thoughts in your mind and say if somebody is going to get elected president that you dont like, we have a system of checks and balances that will round off the sharp edges. Thats what makes our country great. Madisonian democracy. Now were in a battle whether we move forward with Madisonian Democracy or not. Whether vote counts matter or not. And if you look at what republicans have been saying in arizona, if you look at what republicans have said in the house, theyve just been ignoring reality. And rev, speaking of ignoring reality. Youre ignoring the commercial break. Lets talk about the fact that anna palmer brought up a great point. Think about this, this is crazy. Donald trump has won one election. Four and a half years ago. Hes beaten the democrats once. And he didnt even win in the popular vote. He lost the popular vote twice. Hes only one one election. And that was in 2016. Then because he was in the white house, republicans got trashed at the polls in 2017. They took historic losses in 2018. They lost in 2019 Southern Governorships because of donald trump. Then in 2020, yes, it was close. Republicans outperformed expectations, but at the end of the day, donald trump made the republicans lose the white house. Donald trump made the republicans lose the senate in georgia and donald trump made republicans lose the House Of Representatives. So this is really if you want to look as far as oneterm president s go, one of the greatest all time losers in the history of american politics. And yet the rank and file republicans keep following him over the cliff. It would be like if, a church kept embracing a pastor as he lost half his congregation or she lost half her congregation. The choir quit. And they had to file for bankruptcy. Theyre like, yes. Lets keep this guy in there. Hes doing a great job. Its the same with Donald Trumps failing Republican Party. Well, it would be when the church goes from being a church to a cult. Thats what the Republican Party is becoming. A cult. When you cannot look at reality because you are so lost in following something that is delusional, the best thing that has happened to the democrats has been donald trump. Donald trump has single handedly given them the white house, the senate and the House Of Representatives. And lets remember he also lost the popular vote when he did win in 16. The only thing he won in 16 was the Electoral College. If it had gone by the popular vote, he even lost there. So why are the republicans just worshipping this loser . He is a loser. The best thing that could happen for the democrats the mid terms is that donald trump remain the figure that the republicans are rallying around because he energizing the democratic base. People in communities that ive worked in for decades have become awakened, enlightened and woke because of donald trump. If donald trump would go somewhere, we would have a hard time keeping them woke. I mean, and the move today will only further energize the very people that they do not want energized. They do not understand what made joe biden the biggest winner of votes for president , more than fdr, barack obama, john kennedy, lyndon johnson, donald trump. Donald trump is a gift that keeps on giving. And its damaging our country, too. Still ahead on morning joe, long lines at gas stations across the country as drivers race to fuel up following that major Pipeline Hack over the weekend. Plus, our next guest is a Primary Care Physician who makes the case for why outdoor masking is not necessary for children. Youre watching morning joe. Well be right back. K. [ humming ] alexa . Play ooh la la. [ ooh la la by Cherie Playing ] the moxie showerhead speaker. Only from kohler. Managing Type 2 Diabetes . Youre on it. Staying active and eating right . Yup, on it there, too. You may think youre doing all you can to manage Type 2 Diabetes and Heart Disease but could your medication do more to lower your heart risk . Jardiance can reduce the risk of cardiovascular death for adults who also have known Heart Disease. So, it could help save your life from a heart attack or stroke. And jardiance lowers a1c. Jardiance can cause serious side effects including dehydration, genital yeast or urinary tract infections, and sudden kidney problems. Ketoacidosis is a serious side effect that may be fatal. A rare but lifethreatening bacterial infection in the skin of the perineum could occur. Stop taking jardiance and call your doctor right away if you have symptoms of this bacterial infection, ketoacidosis or an allergic reaction, and dont take it if youre on dialysis or have severe kidney problems. Taking jardiance with a sulfonylurea or insulin may cause low blood sugar. Lower a1c and lower risk of a fatal heart attack . On it with jardiance. Ask your doctor about jardiance. Comfort in the extreme. The lincoln family of luxury suvs. Limu emu. And doug. So then i said to him, you oughta customize your Car Insurance with Liberty Mutual, so you only pay for what you need. Oh um, doug can we talk about something other than work, its the weekend. Yeah, yeah. [ squawk ] hot dog or. Chicken . [ squawk ] only pay for what you need. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Starting tomorrow, new yorkers will be able to get the vaccine at subway and train stations, which sounds sterile. Thats just what the subway needed, more Random Band Aids and needles on the ground. Mayor de blasio announced a list of incentives to get people vaccinated, including free food, free tickets to events and the opportunity for one Lucky Vaccinator to be starting quarterback for the New York Jets this season. Couldnt do any worse. The first doses of the Pfizer Vaccine for kids age 12 to 15 were given yesterday in georgia, delaware and arkansas. A day after the fda approved the vaccine for that age group. Those states Public Health systems decided not to wait for the final approval from the cdcs vaccine advisory committee. A decision that could come as early as today. Right now its an Emergency Use Authorization. Public Health Officials in georgia say they were worried that if they turned away young people who wanted the shot yesterday, those kids might not come back. More than a dozen states including new york, minnesota and texas say they will wait for the goahead from the committee and theyre ready as soon as that approval comes down. The committee will be meeting today. States could begin vaccinating children as soon as wednesday and thursday. Joining us now, practicing internist, Mental Health advocate, dr. Lucy mcbride. Great to see you again this morning. Let me begin with the childhood vaccine. Should parents be confident now in giving this to kids age 12 to 15 . First, thanks for having me. Its great to be here again. I will have my 15yearold daughter vaccinated because she wants it. She has been marinating in fear for 14 months. The this will help her go to camp, go to school, engage in social activities without fear. That said, i think this should be a parent by parent, guardian by guard you know decision theres no one size fits all prescription for how to hand it will vaccine for this age group. We know that this age group is at very low risk for covid19. Yet, vaccinating them offers a Public Service and hastens the containment of the virus so that we can get on with our lives. So there are questions about the vaccine, which now as i said will be available this week, 12 to 15, but also about masking. You have a new piece in the atlantic titled why dont think kids need masks outside. Parents gradually reap the rewards of vaccinations, theyre wondering if they need to keep up pandemic precautions for their childrens sake, although Emergency Use Authorization for the Pfizer Vaccine was granted this week, for 12 to 15yearolds, kids this age and under dont need to wait for freedom through shots. They can and should enjoy some benefits of our collective progress. Thats why i have begun telling my parents that their kids, vaccinated or not, do not need to wear masks outside. The big picture is that were entering a new phase of the pandemic. As more than half of adults in the United States have received at least one vaccine dose and case rates drop, the risk of transmitting covid19 to unvaccinated people also lowers. Getting kids moving and reconnecting them with their friends is the evidencebased path toward restoring their health and their well being. Dr. Mcbride, as you know, as i know with kids, theyve been in these masks for over a year now. Why do you believe ill let you flush this out a little bit, its okay to start taking them off, at least outside. Well, lets talk about the facts. The fact of the matter, willie s that Outdoor Transmission is exceedingly unlikely. Theres actually no documented case of sarscov2. Passing by someone on the sidewalk or at an outdoor restaurant. It hasnt been documented. In fact f you talk to most epidemiologists and Public Health officials thought to be far less than 1 . And when the advantages, the social, emotional benefits are so huge, letting kids engage in their lives, letting them see the full range of facial expressions of their peers when those outweigh the minuscule risk of Outdoor Transmission, its really time to put facts in the drivers seat of our behaviors and Public Policies and take fear out of the drivers seat. We need to stop exposing kids to unnecessary fear and an exaggerated risk of Outdoor Transmission because after all health is more than the absence of disease. Its about not getting sick and of course there will be parents who want to mask their kids outside. There are high risk children. There are children who live with high risk adults. But in general, for most children, most anyone who is outdoors, the risk of Outdoor Transmission are so small and the benefits of moving on in the evidencebased way are enormously high. Dr. Mcbride, we have been so conditioned as a country to think of kids, adults, anybody in tight quarters that just being dangerous on its face. You look at playgrounds and a bunch of kids on a new york city playground and makes you cringe a little bit, but thats based on old thinking and old information. So what youre saying is not that we should get rid of masks all together and probably still be used in schools and inside cabins at camp, but as long as youre outside you believe its okay not to wear the mask. Indoors is a different story. We know the virus thrives indoors in crowded conditions and spreads among unvaccinated people. So the risk is still there of covid. We have Tens Of Thousands of cases every year and the cdc is naturally concerned about on going community spread. At the same time, we are in a transition phase. Were in a very different stage of the pandemic right now where case rates are going down. We have shots going into arms every minute of the day. And as we contain the virus, the risk to all of us, vaccinated and unvaccinated goes down. Outdoors is safe. We need to get out there. All right. Dr. Lucy mcbride says take off the mask outside for the kids. Its time. And also thinking about Mental Health there, too. Dr. Mcbride, always great to see you. Thank you so much for your time. Mika . All right. To the economy now. U. S. Employers posted a Record Number of job openings in march, reaching a level of 8. 1 million. The number reflects a widening gap between open positions and workers willing and able to take those roles. Meanwhile, a growing number of republicanled states are moving to end the extra 300 a week in covid19 pandemicrelated Unemployment Benefits. Arguing that the relief is discouraging u. S. Workers from rejoining the labor force. Yesterday, tennessee announced it will stop participating in the federal governments Supplemental Unemployment Benefits Program on july 23rd. The state joins july 3rd. Excuse me. The state joins alabama, arkansas, iowa, mississippi, montana, north dakota and South Carolina who have all also announced they would end the program. Officials in georgia yesterday said their state is likely to slash the jobless benefit as well. Yesterday, President Biden urged out of Work Americans to accept the jobs they might be offered and warned they would lose Unemployment Benefits if they dont. Were going to make it clear that Anyone Collecting Unemployment who is offered a suitable job, must take the job or lose their Unemployment Benefits. Friend from columbia university, professor of economics, economist dr. Jeffrey sacks. Jeffrey, this is so great to you here. Here we go. No, no, no. You and i have agreed over i think past 15 years we have to keep an eye on the debt. We have to keep an eye on the deficit. We have to keep an eye on anything that drives the deficit up and the debt up. But im curious as a progressive, how you balancing the current debate that youre hearing that larry somers is for the first time concerned about inflationary interests, even paul krugman we had on our show said he didnt love the400 stimulus check. He would prefer it went more into infrastructure but it was very popular and helped sell the bill. Im curious, what are your thoughts as you hear this debate unwind about helping people who are truly disadvantaged but also pumping more money into the economy that then was taken out because of covid. I think the key right now is we need to rebuild the economy in a lot of different areas in the roads, the bridges, digital, in the plans for infrastructure, but we ought to pay for that Going Forward. And thats really where the debate in washington is now. Washington, as you know, has not thought about anything but tax cuts for basically 40 years and President Biden is putting some Tax Increases on the table and hes Finding Resistance actually in both parties, the republicans are saying were not going to raise one dollar to reverse the 2017 Corporate Tax cut which was a sheer give away, raise the Budget Deficit and Many Democrats are saying we dont want this tax raise. We dont want that tax raise. We want to end the deductions on the state and local taxes. So, the big question for us is whether were going to actually pay for what we need in the United States. Thats the backdrop. Dr. Sachs, Jonathan Lemire. Good to see you this morning. In the building behind me right now theres a lot of debate about the administrations new proposal for infrastructure jobs, family planning, it will frankly remake how the government deals with its citizens in a very dramatic in the social safety net. Republicans are saying no, its too big. They dont how theyll pay for it with tax rates and so on. Is this debate about whats coming happens with the slow down in the jobs report, with concerns perhaps voiced by some theres too much federal help already. What sort of balance needs to be struck here . Whats your overall assessment just to the size of the package the administration is looking to put forth . First of all, i think all these numbers are very hard for people to process because when they announce a number like a 2 billion package, the first thing you have to do is look over how many years and divide by that to get the idea of whats the real annual spending. Then you have to decide that by the size of our economy which is 20 Trillion Dollars a year. What theyre talking about is 1 or 2 of our national output. Its not very large. And the Tax Increases are not very large either, but when its put in these big headlines, then people can think its over the top. We simply havent patched our infrastructure, much less modernized it for decades. We havent done other than tax cuts for decades. The truth is the American People, the average person overwhelmingly supports the higher taxes on companies and on wealthy people, usually by a margin of 70 in favor or 75 in favor to 20 opposed. Whats going on in the white house behind you is the lobbying. We have powerful, rich people who are opposing any contribution that they might make. We have megacorporations that dont pay any taxes and they want to keep it that way. We have an irs that had its budget cut so much that it doesnt do audits anymore. So this is a game thats going on. The American People by and large see through the game but washington often doesnt care. They dont care about that game. The game theyre in is the campaign contributions. So, my sense is we need to modernize, upgrade our technology. We need to get to 5g digital and get to clean energy and repair roads and bridges and the price tag is absolutely affordable, but the Greedy Companies and greedy, very rich people who have gotten a lot richer in the last two years with the soaring stock market need to get on to the program. Thats my feeling. Dr. Sachs saying something radical these days. We have to pay for this. Great to see you as always. Great to be with you. Anna palmer, lets talk about the status of this massive 2. 5 trillion billion negotiations. We know that joe manchin was called into the house, Kyrsten Sinema. The moderates the white house had to get on board to get to 50 50. Where is it on the wiggle room on the number around the Corporate Tax rate . Yeah. What were starting to see is the contours of this bill and whats going to come together. The big four leaders are heading to the white house today. But theyre very, very far apart. Im pretty bearish when you look at the reporting of what weve been talking to people about republicans actually coming forward on this. Even what Mitch Mcconnell has been saying over the last week or so, he raised the number to 800 billion for infrastructure. But again still just talking about that hard infrastructure. And his redline continues to be increasing the taxes that the professor was just talking about. So if thats the case, its hard to see any package that democrats are going to bring forward that youre going to find republicans to agree to. I think the big question is how long does this dance continue in the next couple weeks between democrats and republicans and when will it be enough for someone like senator joe manchin or Kyrsten Sinema say democrats have in good faith tried to negotiate and find a way forward with republicans but they arent willing to come to any sort of agreement here. Thats something to be watching in the next i think two to three weeks, definitely around the memorial daybreak. Anna palmer, thank you very much for coming on this morning, as always. Coming up, gas prices are climbing across the east coast in the wake of the Colonial Pipeline hack. Were going to go live to North Carolina where a State Of Emergency has been declared as drivers wait hours in some cases to fill up their tanks. Morning joe is coming right back. Stay restless with the icon that does the same. The rx, crafted by lexus. Lease the 2021 rx 350 for 439 a month for 36 months. Experience amazing, at your lexus dealer. The war munger, a person that loves seeing our troops fighting, liz cheney. How about that . The good news is in her state she has been censured and in her state her poll numbers have dropped faster than any human being ive ever seen. So hopefully theyll get rid of her with the next election. Get rid of them all. So, that is, by the way, that is the same guy who, willie, attacked john mccain regularly while he was dying of cancer and continued to attack john mccain after he died after cancer. Thats the same guy who, of course, stayed in an Ivy League School that his daddy probably got him into and daddy kept him out of the war while john mccain was getting beaten up so badly in vietnam that he couldnt even raise his arms over his head for the rest of his life. And john mccain had a chance to get out of that hell, he stayed because his Band Of Brothers were still left behind. Thats the same guy right there, donald trump, that attacked john mccain and thats attacked liz cheney and thats attacked in the past Ronald Reagan. Thats attacked everybody. Attacked our country. And you hear those people in the audience and this has been i got to say, this has been mika will tell you this for me watching this happen, i know liz and ive always respected, known and love and respected her family, but weve never been particularly close. For some reason, this week has been kind of hardest for me over the past four or five years as far as figuring out what happened to the people i grew up with, figuring out what happened to the people who claimed when they were voting for me they were for small government. What happened to the people who when they voted for me claimed that they were for a strong nato, that they were for pushing back on russia, that they were for democracy that they were for the rule of law. No man above the law they would say. They would hold their little constitutions which i always had in my pocket and they would say, in this country, we are not a law of men. We are we are not a nation of men. We are a nation of laws. Uhhuh. That was the cornerstone of what we believed. All the people who claim to be conservatives are saying the same thing for 50 years that liz cheney was saying, that i said in congress. And now i dont understand it now. I dont understand why my friends still and my Family Members still follow this man. Nothing conservative about him. Its what you remember me saying and what mika remembers me saying through the 2016 campaign, i said it go back. Look at the tapes. I warned republicans, theres nothing conservative about this man. Hes hijacking your party. In February Of 2016, i said this guy will destroy the party of Abraham Lincoln, and yet its not just about voting, willie. I have good friends, lifelong friends that have advanced degrees, that are attorneys, that are of moderate temperament, that over the past year theyve told me, oh, covid. Its just like the flu. Because they hear donald trump say its just like the flu. Of course, they didnt repeat donald trump when the woodward tapes were leaked. And actually donald trump saying it was much worse than the flu. These are the same people that told me theyre not taking the vaccine. And they all have Different Reasons for not taking the vaccine. But if donald trump had told them from the very beginning to take the vaccine, they would have taken the vaccine. Yeah. These are the same people who i went to church with. Yeah. I went to Sunday School with. I went to Training Union with. I went on Mission Trips with. I sang in the church choir with. I grew up with. I spent every friday night with. We would have bible studies. These are the people you love. These are the people i love. Not past tense. These are the people i love. And joe, if i may, these are the people that if donald trump called any one of them a murderer 12 times. And if donald trump did anything to try and destroy them, you would be on a plane and you would be by their side and you would be fighting for them. And i would tell them i would go to war. You wouldnt think a second i wouldnt think a second. All of my friends, by the way, these same friends right now these people are family. I said this before, if i needed something, even today they would give it to me. If i needed a kidney, they would give it to me. Actually makes it more disturbing. These people are in a cult and it allows them to separate everything theyve learned in school, everything theyve learned in church, everything theyve read in jesus words. Everything theyve read in the new testament, everything theyve read in the gospels, everything theyve read in the Old Testament and theyre able to separate that and embrace this alternate reality. And for some reason, i guess watching it happen to somebody else. Let me say, by the way, by the way, mika will tell you this. Donald trump, you know, this isnt about donald trump calling me a murderer. This is about me talking to my friends and them having this massive disconnect and not understanding if a president had called them a murderer and said they should be thrown in jail and then, of course, capital punishment, all that, i would have been the first to rush up there. We would have all rushed up there. This is so bizarre. And beyond. So they knew that was a lie, right . And if he was going to lie in such a grand way about something as crazy as that, willie, ill get to willie when i want to get to willie. Hes right there. I see him. Ill get to him when i feel like it. Ill go to willie when i feel like it. So if hes going to lie about that, willie, what the hell wont he lie about . Then we get to the things that matter. The vaccine. Like why wont he come out and tell them people are lying about the vaccine. Why woen he be aggressive on the front lines . The election, which is what were talking about now. The insurrection. Why does he keep lying about the election . Why does he keep lying about the insurrection . He was the guy who inspired it. But most importantly, those people who were booing in the audience, ive got to tell you, im just at a loss. Why are they still embracing him. Liberals who are supporting him, what morons. Shut up and get off my twitter feed. Just shut up. And get off my twitter feed. Willie, i got to tell you, i cant grasp how this happened. People i know, people i love, people who have always stood forget about politics but in life for whats right. People who taught their kids to do the right thing. People who lived by a code that made me proud to be their friends. What happened . I have no idea. I never would have believed this five years ago. Tell you the truth, i never believed that 75 million americans would vote for this guy. They did. Then the insurrection came. I never would have believed they would have stayed with him. Im telling you, ive said it before, put all the polls up that joe biden has a 63 approval rating. Whatever. He was going to win wisconsin by 20 points. If the election were held today, donald trump would get 75 million votes. He hasnt lost a single vote. And, yes, you can give me all you can say, oh, my cousin. My cousin in scranton is not voting for him next time. No, he would get the 75. I dont know a Single Person who has changed their mind. Certainly not enough people. You look at these polls. He dominates the Republican Party even more. And of course theyre going to keep losing elections. They may win in 2022 for obvious reasons. But National Elections are done as a national party. This isnt about politics. This is about me looking back over the past 50 years and realizing that almost everybody that i grew up with, everybody that i loved then and love now live by a different set of realities when it comes to politics. Youre talking about an experience, joe, i think everyone in this country had in One Way Or Another. That by the way, that speech that he made was at the american conservative union, which stands for conservative principles and conservative policies, cheering donald trump and booing liz cheney who, of course, has a much higher life time Conservative Rating than donald trump or Elise Stefanik or anybody else who is following in her footsteps. But what youre talking about is something that happened i always set the date as donald trump came down the escalator and it was a bit of a joke. It was a publicity stunt. July of 2015, when he first ripped john mccain, senator john mccain, war hero john mccain and said i like my heroes who werent captured or whatever he said and we said conventional politics tells you thats it. Hes done. You cant do that. And his support started to tick up and people like youre talking about, people we know sort of liked it in some way because he was, quote, speaking truth or whatever they thought he was doing. Then he comes out with a muslim ban. He goes after gold star family. He crosses all these lines that you cannot cross a a conservative or as an american frankly. And his support just goes up. And now, joe, all the people youre talk about continue to fall on their swords for a man who is no longer president. A man who plays 36 holes of golf and sits on the patio at maralago. Thats where theyre putting their energy. Its not just your friends. Its now members of congress who are doing that, who are coming out today in a couple of hours and will make the explicit statement that loyalty to donald trump is more important than what happened on january 6th. And in preserving our democracy and free elections. Republicans will vote this morning to remove congresswoman liz cheney from her post as conference chair. Republican lawmakers will meet Behind Closed Doors at 9 00 a. M. This morning thats when a member will need to bring up a vote of no confidence against cheney. The vote will be held by Secret Ballot. And simple majority will be needed to remove her from her Leadership Position. Last night, ahead of that vote, Congress Woman cheney spoke On The House Floor. God has blessed, america, mr. Speaker. But our freedom only survives if we protect it. If we honor our oath taken before god in this chamber to support and defend the constitution. If we recognize threats to freedom when they arise. Today, we face a threat america has never seen before. A former president who provoked a violent attack on this capitol in an effort to steal the election has resumed his aggressive effort to convince americans that the election was stolen from him. He risks inciting further violence. Millions of americans have been misled by the former president. They have heard only his words but not the truth. As he continues to undermine our democratic process, sewing seeds of doubt about whether democracy really works at all. I am a conservative republican. And the most conservative of conservative principles is reverence for the rule of law. The Electoral College has voted. More than 60 state and Federal Courts including multiple judges the former president appointed have rejected his claims. The Trump Department of justice investigated the former president s claims of widespread fraud and found no evidence to support them. The election is over. That is the rule of law. That is our constitutional process. Those who refuse to accept the rulings of our courts are at war with the constitution. Our duty is clear, every one of us who has sworn the oath must act to prevent the unraveling of our democracy. This is not about policy. This is not about partisanship. This is about our duty as americans. This is not about policy. This is not about partisanship. This is about our duty as americans. Remaining silent and ignoring the lie emboldens the liar. I will not participate in that. I will not sit back and watch in silence while others lead our party down a path that abandons the rule of law and joins the former president s crusade to undermine our democracy. Lets bring in msnbc contributor, mike barnicle, and nbc political analyst Claire Mccaskill and rogers chair in the american presidency at vanderbilt university, jon meacham and at the white house msnbc contributor, yamiche alcindor. Good to have you all on board this hour. Its too obvious of a parallel to draw, i am of course captain obvious ill draw that parallel. She runs into joe mccarthy, who at that point was destroying lives, getting people arrested, causing people to be ruined professionally, causing people to in anguish commit suicide, he was the most feared man in washington, d. C. She walked past him. I hear your going to give a speech. Yes, i am and youre not going to like it. Margaret chase smith, this woman in a town of men goes out and delivers a speech that Everybody Else was afraid to give. Two years later ikes one of my political heroes would be afraid to had nothing to lose, to be afraid of and yet he still pulled his punches on mccarthy. It was an extraordinary moment. She stood alone. The stakes were very high. Here we have liz cheney alone. Ill just say it, ive been personal here. But alone in that chamber that i love. Chamber that i loved working in, that i felt honored to be in everyday. That i have been embarrassed by. Over the past several years but Liz Cheney Last Night making me think, wait a second, that still is a place where right can be done and history can be made. Yeah. And you know, part of democracy an Essential Element of the system that representative cheney is defending and that we should all, i think, defend as strongly as we can is the right to disagree if we accept the rule of law. My old boss Charlie Peters once defined intellectual honesty as the ability to Say Something good about the other team and bad about your team, if thats where the facts lead you. And thats what she did. And thats what shes doing. I had another this wont surprise you, another historical moment. Almost exactly 30 years ago in 1989, when george h. W. Bush was looking for a new Secretary Of Defense after the John Tower Nomination fell apart, he reached into the House Of Representatives and took out dick cheney. Cheney goes over to the pentagon. That opens up a place in the house leadership that is run thats won by newt gingrich. And that sets gingrich, as you know well, on the path to 1994. This is another house leadership election. Not exactly a givenesque realm. But it is, in fact, significant in that things got worse with gingrich and the party was in the midst of a shift away from reality. I think part of the answer to the questions you were raising is that a lot of folks believe from eisenhower through george w. Bush the republican president s didnt actually deliver on fundamental conservative demands. And it was subtle. And it was insidious but eisenhower, nixon, ford, reagan, the bushes, all ran to the right and then when they were in washington, they governed more from the center. I think that began to erode some of the trust to the point where that was to mix metaphors, that was the gasoline on the garage floor and trump was the match. I think what cheney is doing go ahead. John, im so sorry. We have a slight delay here and i thought you had stopped because youre very thoughtful and your pause is pregnant inspiring. I listen to your podcast. Im a nerd. I listen to all of them. Im moved deeply by them. I remember that scene you painted in podcast in the latest season of your podcast the founder of the John Birch Society driving into new york city with four friends. And all the way in talking about how Dwight Eisenhower was basically a spy for the soviet union and that he was furthering the goals of communism there. And you talk so much about this paranoid style of american politics. So yes, there were many people disappointed in ike and many people disappointed in nixon and ford and reagan. But you also had this almost that was thriving on Conspiracy Theories, lying about each one of those republican president s from the hard, hard, hard, hard right. And they were always the people we sort of like, kind of pushed to the side. Theyve taken control of the party. Right. Right. Thats the inflection point. Thats whats happened. Thats what i didnt expect honestly five years ago to be saying or believing. But i think thats exactly right. And i think frankly as currently constituted and run, the Republican Caucus that Will Today Remove Liz Cheney from this Leadership Position is not a functional, rational actor in the constitutional system. And that is very scary for anybody who loves this country. Because the way were built, both explicitly and implicitly, is we need two parties that are about the mediation of differences and not an unfolding, apocalyptic war. And right now we have one party thats not and we have one party that is. Jon meacham, you mentioned scary. I want to go to Claire Mccaskill and develop on that. Liz cheney brought up kenya, poland, russia. I want to bring into the conversation my fathers fears about how this can happen here. And that americans dont seem to understand that, specially those the millions who voted for donald trump who arent seeing whats happening but especially for those in the Republican Party that this can happen here and you are an accomplice to that right now. It sounded so extreme four years ago when we put on the table on this show our fears about this president wanting to be a dictator, believing in dictatorships, having obsessions with leaders like vladimir putin. Having secret meetings, nobody seemed to really completely see the danger at stake within the heart of the Republican Party. And those empty chairs around Liz Cheney Last Night during her speech are a signal of the cowardice and the weakness among her own parties among republicans in the house, many of them men by the way, just pointing that out. And thats a place where evil flourishes. And this sounds so dramatic, but its not. Its where we are right now. You know, i think its so important that jon meacham is with us this morning. Because i do think this day is going to be an important day in history. I do think that Margaret Chase smith speech is an apt comparison. I do believe that this is the darkest hour for the Republican Party. And the thing thats so weird, i mean, this is what bad guys in other countries do. This is what we have stood against as a nation, since our birth. December pits in other countries lying and trying to manipulate power to their own will. I never dreamt there would be so many welcome coconspirators in this effort to undermine the most precious thing we have of all which is our democracy based on free and Fair Elections. It is awfully bad. Just to make it very brutal in terms of political terms what i cant get is they arent doing the math. You look in raw political terms. Do the math. Yes, eli was on your program this morning talking about the Morning Consult poll and 50 of the republicans said she should go. But 50 didnt say she should go. And by the way, less than 25 of the independent voters said she should go. You take 25 of the Republican Party, you take the majority of the independents, and you take the vast majority of the democrats in this country and republicans cant win. They cant win. So, it is really going down a path that really harms listen, do i want the democrats to win . Of course i do. I think youre seeing nails in the coffin of a Republican Party that has lost all moral high ground on integrity. They are kicking somebody out for telling the truth. And yamiche, im curious, yamiche, what the white house thinks the building you cover every single day about this the building behind you because today, as a matter of fact, Kevin Mccarthy will be one of the socalled big four meeting with President Biden. So on the very day that hes leading the charge to expel liz cheney because she says joe biden is the free and fair president of the United States of america, he will be sitting down trying to do some business with that president. Well, willie, all of this is happening 126 days after the Capitol Insurrection where a mob stormed into the capitol and where now liz cheney is taking this defiant last stand to say i am not going to be going down the path of calling into question the rule of law and undermining democracy. When i talk to white house officials about this civil war inside the gop where the side of truth is losing it seems this morning, they say that the president , President Biden, feels very, very like very, very wetted to the idea that he was elected to try his best to work with republicans. So even though when Kevin Mccarthy walks into this white house this afternoon, this morning, he will be walking in of course the Elephant In The Room being that he just ousted a member of his party from leadership for calling into question the legitimacy of President Biden. White house officials tell me that hes going to be showing grace, President Biden will show grace and discipline and a sense of duty. Those are the words the white house officials are using when they say the president is continuing to work with republicans despite their efforts to try to call into question his legitimate victory. Another thing im hearing from white house officials is that they understand that this is a distraction and that this Republican Party is some ways proven to be a contrast to the work that theyre doing here at the white house. They say the president who has been on the road talking about his plans, 4 trillion to help families, to provide jobs to have infrastructure and to help Home Health Aids and so many other americans to talk about systemic racism and root it out in our society, they say that all of this is happening at the gop. It shows while the president is hard at work for the American People, the gop is hard at work trying to undo the 2020 election. So of course something that cannot actually be done. But white house officials are leaning in on the idea that President Biden feels it is his duty, it is his responsibility as the leader of the United States to still work with the party that is really basing all of its interactions and all of its sense right now on Conspiracy Theories and lies. Wow. Thats a tough thing to do. Yamiche alcindor, thank you very much for your reporting. Mike barnicle, man, youve been around the capitol for a very long time. For years. And as a reporter and just in and out of the place. I know you hold it you have a special reverence for it yourself. Im just curious about your thoughts watching Liz Cheney Last Night on the floor. And again, for people watching, again, let me be very open and clear about this, i think republicans are really pushing themselves further into a corner. So, as we speak about this, mike, its not like, oh, geez, theyll get a big advantage out of this. Like mitt romney said this isnt going to pick up a single vote for them, probably going to lose more votes in suburbs. More votes with women. More votes with actually true conservatives like me who actually believe like in american conservatism. So given all of that, just what were your thoughts on that sad spectacle we saw last night as men that rushed out of the chamber as liz cheney went in to tell the truth . You know, joe, i had a bundle of thoughts last night and certainly this morning and even up to and including right now and listening to you caused me to think about a lot of other things as well. But last night when liz cheney said we must speak the truth, our election was not stolen. And america has not failed. Those are words that should resonate throughout this country because what weve talked about here today, what weve witnessed in the news, this is a very fragile republic of ours right now. We begin this hour with a brief clip of the former guy, the former president of the United States. People havent seen a whole lot of him. And they certainly havent heard from him a lot through twitter or facebook or things like that. So hes been absent. Hes been absent from the collective memory of the republic for quite for over 100 days. You said earlier when you were speaking at length about your feelings about the party and about what has happened to it, you said one phrase that resonated with me and i think a lot of other people when you said how did this happen . I think jon meacham and other historians are going to look at these past four years and right now as a matter of fact asking, how did this happen . How in this country so filled with goodness and so racked with problems that we admit to and that we try to confront each and everyday, how did it happen that a hater became president . That a divider still exists as a former president . That he gets up there and twists everything. How did this happen . And yet here we are with 43 states, maybe even more, trying to twist Election Laws so that if republicans lose elections they dont have to honor the results. This all stems from this one person, the former president of the United States. So i think were going to be talking a lot about that phrase and wondering about that phrase for many, many months to come sadly. How did this happen . These are the questions we are going to be looking at in the many hours and days to come because were at such a cross roads. Many people i think thought with bidens victory, a page had been turned. Its not. We want to turn now to americans beginning to feel the effects of the Colonial Pipeline shutdown. Across the east coast, drivers are waiting in long lines to fill up their tanks as fears of a gas shortage grow. The Colonial Pipeline supplies half the fuel for all of the east coast and remains out of service after a cyber a i tack over the weekend. Joining us from charlotte, North Carolina, tom yames. What is the latest, tom . Reporter mika good morning. Well, this gas station just behind me had to open an hour earlier because of the demand. The good news is they have gas here, but you can see the lines getting longer and longer. Just across the street we saw several stations without fuel. New development this morning, the Colonial Pipeline website is back up and running. That could be a potential step in the right direction. This morning, gas and patience running low at the pump. I have been here now for an hour and 15 minutes. Reporter Emergency Declarations issued in four states with more than 1,700 gas stations from florida to maryland out of fuel. It comes on the heels of that crippling cyberattack against a critical u. S. Fuel source. All the gas stations closer to where i live were completely empty. Americans on the hunt for gas up and down the east coast overwhelming some stations. Do you think people are panicked or do you think people are trying to figure everything out . I think its probably some panic, like the toilet paper issues a year ago. Cars bumper to bumper here in the carolinas and stretching down streets in florida. Check out the line. Reporter nationwide, gas prices reaching their highest point in nearly seven years. Despite the price in spike and demand, the white house and experts are preaching calm. There will be hoarding gas. If you dont really need it, then dont buy it. Reporter but with the Colonial Pipeline still mostly down the region that relies on the 5,500 mile system for its fuel is feeling an impact. My fear is you have these Gas Shortages its going to cause a lot of problems for people. Reporter on tuesday, in South Carolina, cars were turned away. Were out of gas. Reporter according to gas buddy, nearly 40 of Metra Atlanta gas stations are out of fuel. But these pumps in tennessee had plenty. As of right now, theres still a good supply out there. And theres no need to panic. Reporter the long lines, though, already causing a Domino Effect in some cases. You want to get groceries but you cant get groceries why . Because i cannot look. You see . The line. Reporter all of this pain at the pump as 34 million americans plan to Bublg Buckle Up and hit the road for the big memorial day weekend. So a lot of frustration still out there along the east coast. Aaa says if youre going to run errands, try to group them together. Go to the grocery store, pharmacy, pick up the lottery tickets, pick up the kids do that at once and avoid traffic times because the lines will be longer. But mika the reality is this i was talking to these drivers this morning and last night and theyre saying the same thing, listen, i drive a Long Distance to get to work. I dont want to get stuck. I dont want to miss work. The average commute time sabt 30 minutes and you kind of understand their pain and why theyre lining up right now. Mika . All right. Tom, thank you very much for that report. Now to gaza. At least 33 people were killed yesterday, including ten children in the on going violence between israel and the palestinians. Israeli air strikes flattened this 13story Apartment Building in gaza. With israel claiming it was being used by the hamas militant group. Shortly after tensions spread west to tel aviv. 130 rockets from the gaza strip sent residents of israels largest City Scrambling into bomb shelters. The clashes prompted calls from World Leaders to deescalate the violence. Yesterday they condemned the attacks from hamas but said the Palestinian People deserved, quote, equal measures of freedom. We will keep following this story. Still ahead on morning joe, Intelligence Committee chairman senator mark warner will be our guest this morning. Plus, if the Trump Administration taught us anything, its that democracy cannot be taken for granted. One of our next guests examines a critical component of democracy, the written constitution. Youre watching morning joe. Well be right back. Theres interest you accrue, and interests you pursue. Plans for the long term, and plans for a long weekend. Assets you allocate, and ones you hold tight. At thrivent, we believe money is a tool, not a goal. And with the right guidance, you can get the financial clarity you need, and live a life rich in meaning, and gratitude. To learn more, text thrive to 444555, or visit thrivent. Com. Hooh. That spin class was brutal. Well you can try using the buicks massaging seat. Oohh yeah, thats nice. Can i use apple carplay to put some music on . Sure, its wireless. Pick something we all like. Ok. Hold on. Whats your buicks wifi password . buickenvision2021. oh, you should pick something stronger. Thats really predictable. Thats a really tight spot. Dont worry. I used to hate parallel parking. [all together] me too. Hey. You really outdid yourself. Yes, we did. The allnew buick envision. An suv built around you. All of you. My nunormal . Fewer Asthma Attacks with nucala. A oncemonthly addon injection for severe eosinophilic asthma. Nucala reduces eosinophils, a key cause of severe asthma. Nucala is not for sudden breathing problems. Allergic reactions can occur. Get help right away for swelling of face, mouth, tongue or trouble breathing. Infections that can cause shingles have occurred. Dont stop steroids unless told by your doctor. Tell your doctor if you have a parasitic infection. May cause headache, injection site reactions, back pain, and fatigue. Ask your doctor about nucala. Find your nunormal with nucala. Its my 5 52 wokeuplikethis migraine medicine. Its ubrelvy. For anytime, anywhere migraine strikes, without worrying if its too late, or where i am. One dose can quickly stop my migraine in its tracks within two hours. Unlike older medicines, ubrelvy is a pill that directly blocks cgrp protein, believed to be a cause of migraine. Do not take with strong cyp3a4 inhibitors. Most common side effects were nausea and tiredness. Ask about ubrelvy. The anytime, anywhere migraine medicine. Not everybody wants the same thing. Ask about ubrelvy. Thats why i go with Liberty Mutual they customize my Car Insurance so i only pay for what i need. cause i do things a bit differently. Wet teddy bears wet teddy bears here only pay for what you need. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Rene is not an influencer. Shes more of a groundbreaker. Just look at the way shes reshaping and reimagining her fouracre. Slice of heaven. Its not hard to tell shes the real deal. Renee runs with us on a john deere 1series Tractor because out here, you cant fake a job well done. Nothing runs like a deere. Get a 1sseries tractor starting at 99 per month. Starting at 99 per month. Who goes right back to sleep after getting an alert of an unusual charge on their credit card . You do. Round the clock fraud protection. One of the many things you can expect when youre with amex. The former president is using the same language that he knows provoked violence on january 6th. As party we need to be focussed on the future. We need to be focussed on embracing the constitution, not embracing insurrection. Fundamental part of the constitution and of who we are as americans is the rule of law. Its the judicial process. The election wasnt stolen. There was a judicial process in place. If you attack the judicial process and you attack the rule of law, you arent defending the constitution, youre at war with the constitution. Republican conference chair, at least for the moment, liz cheney, speaking on sunday on the same theme of last nights floor speech. The need to defend the u. S. Constitution. Joining us now professor of history at princeton, the author of the new book the gun, the ship and the pen linda cauley. In light of what is happening in washington, in light of her speech last night, what parallels or messages from the book do you come to mind for you . Well, i came to this subject rather as an outsider because as my accent suggests i come from britain, which has no codified constitution. But when i came over to the United States in the 1980s, i became really intrigued with d. And increasingly aware of their importance. So, in the book, i trace how they increasingly spread across the globe from the 1750s. But i also end the book with various warnings that constitutions are fragile pieces of paper. They only work so long as people make them work, think hard about them, perhaps keep them well amended and of course were now in an increasingly Digital World where people are getting their political information from a variety of sources, very eclectic sometimes unworthy sources. So ones got to think how does one keep these really important, political and legal texts going . And in the center of peoples minds. Thats such a great question. Lets go to historian jon meacham to continue the conversation. Macham . Professor, talk about these historical case studies for constitutions that do fail. Are there some characteristics, some reoccurring symptoms that lead to that fatal diagnosis . Well, very often they fail because of war. You know, a country is defeated or the leader decides that he really doesnt want a written constitution. This happened in junisia, the space that sees the first modern muslim constitution, its made in 1861. In 1864 its withdrawn. And the same thing happens in turkey with their 1876 constitution. So, it can be pressure from without, but it can also be leaders changing their minds. Mike barnicle . Professor, im wondering if you have an opinion in what weve been talking about here most of the morning and that is the threat posed to the constitution, if any if your view, of the Republican Party seeming reluctance to accept the results of our last National Election where joe biden was elected. Well, you know, im not a politician, just a mere academic. But you know, one sane one can say about the federal constitution in the United States is that its now the oldest in existence. And the Founding Fathers made it very difficult to amend. The state constitutions are amended quite regularly. But the federal constitution, its very hard to amend, much harder say than the second oldest constitution that still exists, norways constitution of 1814. Theyre always amending that. And i do suspect that one of the challenges that the United States faces is that its constitution is in some ways out of date. You know, the Founding Fathers said nothing in writing about t. They said nothing about the influence of plutaucrats. In 1787 in philadelphia when they were drafting this wonderful document, they werent thinking of billionaires. So, theres all these kinds of challenges that in an ideal world perhaps a rediscussion of the federal constitution might be a useful thing to do, but how you do that in such, as is now, a divided political community, i dont know. Professor of history at princeton, linda colley, thank you so much. The book is the gun, the ship and the pen warfare, constitutions and the making of the modern world. And where we stand right now the book is so timely. Jon meacham. Thank you as well. Coming up, consumer inflation data for the month of april will be released in the next hour. And it is expected to show the biggest year over year gain in nearly a decade. Stephanie ruhle joins us to break down the numbers straight ahead on morning joe. Started out down a dirty road out down a dirty road this is my body of proof. Proof of less joint pain and clearer skin. Proof that i can fight Psoriatic Arthritis. With humira. Humira targets and blocks a specific source of inflammation that contributes to both joint and skin symptoms. Its proven to help relieve pain, stop further irreversible joint damage and clear skin in many adults. Humira can lower your ability to fight infections. Serious and sometimes fatal infections, including tuberculosis, and cancers, including lymphoma, have happened, as have blood, liver, and nervous system problems, serious allergic reactions, and new or worsening heart failure. Tell your doctor if youve been to areas where certain fungal infections are common and if youve had tb, hepatitis b, are prone to infections, or have flulike symptoms or sores. Dont start humira if you have an infection. Ask your rheumatologist about humira. Go to humira. Com to see proof in action. If you cant afford your medicine, abbvie may be able to help. Another day, another chance. If you cant afford your medicine, it could be the day you break the sales record, or the day theres appointments nonstop. With comcast business, you get the network that can deliver gig speeds to the most businesses, and you can get the advanced Cybersecurity Solutions you need with comcast business securityedge. Every day in business is a big day. Well keep you ready for whats next. Get started with a powerful internet and voice solution for just 64. 90 a month. And ask how to add comcast business securityedge. Call today. The padres will be shorthanded in todays. Fernando jr. In the injured list yesterday. Three other padre players will be sideline because of contact tracing. The new york yankees is also dealing with the virus reporting of breakflu cases yesterday. Their base coach and Reggie Willis each tested positive despite vaccinated. Joining us now will leach. Hes also the new author of how lucky. I cant acknowledge that your st. Louis cardinals are tied for the best record for all of baseball, i just jinxed it for you. We are glad baseball is coming around to understand where the cardinals right where it should be. You can communicate with claire mckaskill. Shes the best in baseball right now. How about that 11th rask night against the brewers. We are feeling great in st. Louis and a little bit of a great start. Well be talking about baseball in october. All about starting pitching and even with the weird extra innings. So will, well put the baseball to the side for a second because we want to talk about your book, how lucky, people have come to love your writing about sports and culture but this is your first novel. What makes you step in the world of fiction . I want to write about a character, his name is daniel, hes 26yearsold and he has spinal disprophy and my son actually have this. I want to set the story. But, certainly it basically tells a story of daniel witnesses what he thinks a kidnapping and he tries to investigate it while hes learning about his life a little bit. I traditionally known for sports, there are a lot of tailgating and certainly everybody missed tailgating last year, hopefully it is funny and suspensful. An author named steven king, he wrote this i am reading a fantastic novel by will leitch called how lucky, a lot of you will like. I had to check to make sure it is not one of those tweets that people put together. Steven king is a brilliant writer. I am originally from Central Illinois where people dont read perhaps as much as i would have liked them to. Hes a physical representation of what books are. I dont know steven king, i was honored. I have been reading steven king books when i was nineyearsold. Mike is here with a question for you. Will, that was high praise from steven king. In terms of your writing and you write about reality each and everyday whether it is sports or culture and i read a lot about it. How do you go from writing the reality that surrounds us each and everyday whether it is sports or anything else and you become the person in the novel you are writing and after you tell us that, your thoughts on albert rose . First, i thought it will be easier, unlike journalism, you make all the people do whatever you want them. In journalism if someone do irrational things, people do irrational things. It was fun to put together. It is really telling a story. It is the same kind of concept as journalism, certainly as a cardinals fan to watch him come up there is a lot of debate whether or not he should come back to st. Louis. It is different to find a logical spot for him to come back to st. Louis. Albert has to come back to st. Louis for crying out loud. I think a lot of magic can happen if he got them back. It would be a good way for him to go out. You mentioned you are from Central Illinois. Congratulations on the new book how lucky, hes one of the great writers out there. Good to see you my friend. Just over an hour from now, republicans will gather to vote in secret on liz cheneys future as conference chair. A simple majority will decide her fate. We are following all the Dramatic Development as morning joe continues. Our Retirement Plan with voya, keeps us moving forward. Hey, kevin hey, guys they have Customized Solutions to help our familys special needs. Hey, graduation selfie well done and voya stays by our side, keeping us on track for retirement. Giving us confidence in our future. And in kevins. You ready for your first day on the job . I was born ready. Go get em, kev. Well planned. Well invested. Well protected. Voya. Be confident to and through retirement. Lactaid is 100 real milk, just without the lactose. So you can enjoy it even if youre sensitive to dairy. So anyone who says lactaid isnt real milk is also saying mabel here isnt a real cow. And she really hates that. How great is it that we get to tell everybody how Liberty Mutual customizes your Car Insurance mabel here isnt a real cow. So you only pay for what you need . I mean it. Uhoh, sorry. Oh. What . Im an emu no, buddy only pay for what you need. Liberty, liberty, liberty, liberty. After my car accident, liberty, liberty, liberty, liberty. I wondered what my case was worth. So i called the barnes firm. When that car hit my motorcycle, insurance wasnt fair. So i called the barnes firm. It was the best call i couldve made. Atat t bararnefirmrm, our r inry a attneysys wk hahard i couldve made. Atat t bararnefirmrm, to get you the best result possible. Call us now and find out what your case could be worth. You u mit bebe sprisised the Barnes Firm Injury Attorneys call one eight hundred, Eight Million senator paul, with all new respect, you are entirely and completely incorrect that the nih has not ever and does not now fund gain function of research in the Wuhan Institute. I dont favor game of Function Research that are not correct. Youre fooling with Mother Nature here, you are allowing super virus to be created with a 15 mortality. It is very dangerous and it is a huge mistake to share this with china and it is a huge mistake to allow this in the United States. We should be careful to investigate where this virus came from. I fully agree that you should investigate where the virus came from. Again, we have not funded gain of functions, research in the wuhan, virology. Why is he doing this to himself . I dont know why he does. It is more than strange, it is disturbing. Dr. Anthony fauci pushing back on senator rand paul allegations that the National Institutes of health have been funding the chinese lab in wuhan. We have been watching this for six months, it is really strange for the guy that has a doctor in front of his name for some reason seems to get further out there than anybody else. Hes basically sounding like some qanon. Rand paul is a doctor. Dr. Fauci is the chief boogie man for chief conspiracy theory. We know this over the years and there are all kinds of theories. Theyre not only the darkest corners on the internet, they found their way on prominent tv shows where dr. Fauci is being called a criminal. That talk online and Cable News Spill Over into congress where United States senators willing to take those ideas and theories and run with them and con front dr. Fauci himself. Those were extraordinary exchanges yesterday. We have cofounder of punch ball news and reverend sharpton and White House Reporter Jonathan Lemire, it is good to have you all. I got a sense last night when watching liz cheney that we were watching One Way Or Another of a piece of history. As a conservative you look back to those moments where somebody steps into the limelight and leads a movement, you think of reagan in 1966. I think of Margaret Thatcher in 1975 in britain and her address before the conservative party, she sort of sweeps away the light and shows everybody whos in control there. Liz cheney could well be that person in 2021, but the question is for what party because the party that shes a member of that i was a member of, Ronald Reagan was a member of. That party no longer exists. It is a party that well, forget about ideology, it is a party thats antidemocratic that refuses and taking its Future Position, being a party thats refused to accept democratic winning elections. If they dont like the outcome, they wont accept the Election Results. Certainly what it seems if you look at arizona and you look at whats happening in the House Of Representatives right now with Republican Caucus. This is something incredible to watch. Looking women over 50,000 submissions for remarkable women who have done remarkable things. This is different to see her standing out here alone. Republicans left, they left the hall because they did not want to be embarrassed or they were too weak to sit there and listen to the truth. House republicans are expected to vote this morning to remove her. To get her out of their way, congresswoman liz cheney from her pest as conference chair. Gop lawmakers will meet Behind Closed Doors at 9 00 a. M. , thats when a member will need to bring up a vote of no confidence against cheney. The vote will be held by Secret Ballot and a simple majority will be needed to remove her from her Leadership Position. Congresswoman cheney spoke On The House Floor. I am a conservative republican, the most conservative of conservative principles is reverence for the rule of law. The Electoral College have voted and including multiple judges have rejected his claims. The Trump Department of justice investigated the formal president s claim of fraud and found no evidence to support them. The election is over. That is the rule of law. That is our constitutional process. Those who refused to accept the rulings of our courts are at war with the constitution. Our duty is clear. Every one of us who has sworn the oath must act to prevent the unraveling of our democracy. This is not about policy. This is not about partisanship. This is about our duty as americans. Remaining silent and ignoring the lie emboldens the liar. I will not participate in that. I will not sit back and watch in silence while others lead our party down a path that abandons the rule of law and joins the former president s crusade to undermine or democracy. As the party of reagan, republicans have championed democracy and won the cold war and defeated the communists. Today america is on another cusp of the cold war, this time with communist china. American democracy is a failure. We must speak the truth. Our election was not stolen and america has not failed. I received a message last week from a gold star father who says standing up for the truth honors all who gave all. We must all strive to be worthy of the sacrifice of those who have died for our freedom. Theyre the patriots, Katherine Lee bates described in the word of america is beautiful, mercy more than life. Ultimately, mr. Speaker, this is at the heart of what our oath requires that we love our country more. That we love her so much that well stand above politics to defend her. Well do everything in our power to protect our constitution and our freedom that has been paid for by the blood of so many. We must love america so much that well never yield in her defense. Thats our duty. Thank you. So, willie, freedom only survive if we protect it, we must speak the truth, the election was not stolen. America has not fail and Donald Trumps attempt to undermine democracy as liz cheney says in the floor of the peoples house last night. She simply says i will not participate. That had the feel of a political urology. It sounded like liz cheney was standing there remembering the party that never existed, talking about the bushes. None were in the room because as you said they walked out except for congressman of colorado perhaps ashamed. She was reminding them the rule of law at the top of the list. So much of this comes down to Donald Trumps personal ambition. What his hold in the party for 2024. You are watching morning joe, well be right back. Well be right back. [sfx thunder rumbles] [sfx rainstorm] comfort in the extreme. The lincoln family of luxury suvs. As your business changes, the United States Postal Service is changing with it. With ecommerce that runs at the speed of now. Next day and twoday shipping nationwide, and returns right from the doorstep. Its a whole new world out there. Lets not keep it waiting. From prom dresses to workouts its a whole new world out there. And new adventures you hope the more you give the less theyll miss. But even if your teen was vaccinated against meningitis in the past they may be missing vaccination for meningitis b. Although uncommon, up to 1 in 5 survivors of meningitis will have long term consequences. Now as youre thinking about all the vaccines your teen might need make sure you ask your doctor if your teen is missing meningitis b vaccination. Did you know you can go to libertymutual. Com to customizes your Car Insurance so you only pay for what you need . Really . I didnt aah ok. Im on vibrate. Aaah only pay for what you need. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Liberty. Sales are down from last quarter but we are hoping things will pick up by q3. Yeah. Uh. Doug . Sorry about that. Umm. What. Its. Um. You alright . [sigh] [ding] never settle with power e trade. It has powerful, easytouse tools to help you find opportunities, 24 7 support when you need answers plus some of the lowest options and futures Contract Prices around. Dont get mad. Get e trade and start trading today. My plaque psoriasis. The itching. The burning. The stinging. My skin was no longer mine. My Psoriatic Arthritis, made my joints stiff, swollen. Painful. Emerge tremfyant™. With tremfya®, adults with moderate to severe plaque psoriasis. Can uncover clearer skin and improve symptoms at 16 weeks. Tremfya® is the only medication of its kind also approved for adults with active Psoriatic Arthritis. Serious allergic reactions may occur. Tremfya® may increase your risk of infections and lower your ability to fight them. Tell your doctor if you have an infection or symptoms or if you had a vaccine or plan to. Tremfya®. Emerge tremfyant™. Janssen can help you explore cost support options. Can you be free of hair breakage worries . We invited mahault to see for herself that new dove breakage remedy gives damaged hair the strength it needs. Even with repeated combing hair treated with dove shows 97 less breakage. Strong hair with new dove breakage remedy. In business, its never just another day. Its the big sale, or the big presentation. Shows 97 less breakage. The day where everything goes right. Or the one where nothing does. With comcast business you get the network that can deliver gig speeds to the most businesses and advanced cybersecurity to protect every device on it all backed by a dedicated team, 24 7. Every day in business is a big day. Well keep you ready for whats next. Comcast business powering possibilities. If we honor our oath, taken before god in this chamber to support and defend the constitution. If we recognize threats to freedom when they arise, today we face as threat america has never seen before. A formal president who provoked a violent attack on this capitol in an effort to steal the election has resumed his aggressive efforts to convince the americans that the election was stolen from him. He risked inciting further violence. Millions have been misled. They have only heard his words but not the truth as he undermines our democratic process sewing seeds of doubt as if our democracy works at all. Ana palmer, you cant help but think who else is with her. Most of them are going to vote against her and knock her out of her leadership. Part of the reason they did not want to hear that message because they know shes right. Despite the fact of what shes standing up for is a free and Fair Election saying it was not stolen, joe biden is president and donald trump is lying to you. Yes, i think she gives voice to where a lot of actual House Republicans are whether they talk privately to you what they dont agree on the formal president is doing. Theyre making the point that one in the short term is not good for them that there is political beings or to go up this president there is a real fear of the fact that donald trump may support primary challenger and her speaking like this is not helpful to them gaining majority in 2022. The political calculation is very simple along those two lines. The big problem for House Republicans is liz cheney is going to continue to speak like this. Shes not going to stop and now shes untheterred. Shes not part of the leadership and having anything to reign her in. I expect her to continue to speak like this loudly on these Talking Points for weeks and months to come which is a major problem for republicans. Coming up, what the Biden Administration is doing to counter the risk of inflation. Stephanie ruhle has new insight on that, she joins us straight ahead on morning joe. Are you managing your diabetes. Using fingersticks . With the new freestyle libre 2 system, a continuous glucose monitor, you can check your glucose with a painless, onesecond scan. And now with optional alarms, you can choose to be notified if you go too high or too low. And for those who qualify, the freestyle libre 2 system is now covered by medicare. Ask your doctor for a prescription. You can do it without fingersticks. Learn more at freestyle libre 2 dot u. S. Facing leaks takes strength. So heres to the strong, who trust in our performance and comfortable longlasting protection. Because your strength is supported by ours. Depend. The only thing stronger than us, is you. I think the sketchy website i bought this turtle from stole all of my info. Ooh, have you looked on the bright side . Discover never holds you responsible for unauthorized purchases on your card. giggling thats my turtle. Fraud protection. Discover. Something brighter. [ ] giggling when you have diabetes,rtle. Managing your blood sugar is crucial. Try boost glucose control. The patented blend is clinically shown to help manage blood sugar levels. Boost glucose control products contain high quality protein and key nutrients to support immune health. Try boost. Sure, about this . Experience capability, crafted by lexus. Were good. The remarkable gx and lx. Get 0. 9 apr financing on the 2021 gx 460. Experience amazing, at your lexus dealer. Another day, another chance. Get 0. 9 apr financing on the 2021 gx 460. It could be the day you break the sales record, or the day theres appointments nonstop. With comcast business, you get the network that can deliver gig speeds to the most businesses, and you can get the advanced Cybersecurity Solutions you need with comcast business securityedge. Every day in business is a big day. Well keep you ready for whats next. Get started with a powerful internet and voice solution for just 64. 90 a month. And ask how to add comcast business securityedge. Call today. I talked about when Donald Trumps fame ignorance of the kkk and david duke and pretended he didnt know who david duke was. At that point it had become evidence that the Republican Party was going in all in for him. I asked the question at the end of that column in February Of 2016, thinks where the party of Abraham Lincoln dies. Time and time again over the past four years, i thought the Republican Party would turn away from donald trump was wrong time and time again and now this is whether we gotten where liz cheney stands alone On The House Floor supporting the basic proposition that republicans should not embraced a big lie that they know is a big lie that Rudy Giuliani admitted in Federal Court was a big lie. Donald Trump Administration admitted it was a big lie when they said it was the safest, the most honest election towards to that effect ever run. And yet there is liz cheney sitting On The House Floor alone because republicans cant be seen with her telling the most basic of truths that every trump judge appointed to this Supreme Court or every trump judge appointed to the Supreme Court and District Court all said the same thing. There was no widespread voter fraud. Joe biden won the election. Yet, for her simply repeating that truth, shes there alone making this declaration of conscious. It is incredible that we are here. What liz cheney stood up for last night is the foundation of our democracy. The idea that we have fear, and fair and free elections and that we honor their results. If you lose power, you step away from power. Thats set in the beginning of this constitution and this republic and now that is under fire. She defended the basic principles as she stood alone. There is so many of them that the Republican Party could have walked away from the big lie and donald trump. They had their chance. It looked like for maybe 24 hours they may have, when january 6th happened and the violet mob in Donald Trumps name stormed the citadel of democracy. Lives were loss and for 24 hours or so, it looks like republicans may use that as their breaking point. A lot of them and if not all of them will walk away from donald trump. His power over the party seems to only grown in recent weeks. The party has lost control of the house and the senate. The Republican Party, the vast majority of them are tinabeth tethering themselves to him. Part of what he stands for is not telling the truth and not honoring the results of an election. Liz cheney will be bounced quickly and quietly. Shes not going to go away. Shes going to talk out. Senator romney and kinziger who joins her on that. Other republicans who keep on propagating the big lie, theyre all growing in number and they have complete sway over where the Republican Party is going in 2022 or 2024, making if they can ever honor the results of the election again. Coming up, what officials learning of the cyber attack that shuts down the pipeline of the east coast. Morning joe is coming back in a moment. Whats the 1 retinol brand used most by dermatologists . Tahdah, its neutrogena® with dermproven retinol, rapid wrinkle repair® smooths the look of fine lines in 1week, deep wrinkles in 4. So you can kiss wrinkles, and other wrinkle creams goodbye. Rapid wrinkle repair® pair with our most concentrated retinol ever for 2x the power. Neutrogena® hooh. That spin class was brutal. Well you can try using the buicks massaging seat. Oohh yeah, thats nice. Can i use apple carplay to put some music on . Sure, its wireless. Pick something we all like. Ok. Hold on. Whats your buicks wifi password . buickenvision2021. oh, you should pick something stronger. Thats really predictable. Thats a really tight spot. Dont worry. I used to hate parallel parking. [all together] me too. Hey. You really outdid yourself. Yes, we did. The allnew buick envision. An suv built around you. All of you. My Psoriatic Arthritis pain . I had enough an suv built around you. Its not getting in my way. Joint pain, swelling, tenderness. Much better. My psoriasis, clearer. Cosentyx works on all of this. Four years and counting. So watch out. I got this watch me. Real people with active Psoriatic Arthritis look and feel better with cosentyx. Cosentyx works fast for results that can last. It treats the multiple symptoms of Psoriatic Arthritis, like joint pain and tenderness, back pain, and helps stop further joint damage. Dont use if youre allergic to cosentyx. Before starting, get checked for tuberculosis. An increased risk of infections and lowered ability to fight them may occur. Tell your doctor about an infection or symptoms, if your inflammatory bowel disease symptoms develop or worsen, or if youve had a vaccine, or plan to. Serious allergic reactions may occur. I just look and feel better. I got real relief with cosentyx. Watch me feel real relief. Ask your rheumatologist about cosentyx. This is our block. Our place. Our people. Our block, its just like yours. Full of the people who shaped you. They all deserve care and access to the vaccine. No matter their address, income, or skin color. Not having a ride to get the vaccine. Cant be the reason you dont get it. You wanna help . Donate a ride today. Good morning, i guess, let me emphasize as much as there is no cause cost for hording toilet paper during the pandemic or hording gasoline that the pipeline should be substantial by the end of this week or over the weekend. Energy secretary Jennifer Granholm is asking americans not to horde fuel. One fifth of gas stations in atlanta are out of fuel yesterday. The governor of georgia and North Carolinas declared a sta of emergency. The pipeline shut down is affecting air travel as well. American airlines is adding lay overs to several long distant flights to refuel. The department of energy is warning that affected areas may not seek gas shipments immediately and could quote need to rely on inventories for several days after Colonial Pipeline service is restored. Joining us now, the chairman of select committee, mark warner, of virginia. Senator, i would like to look at this problem. What have you heard about when full service will be restored and should people be calm about this and not horde gas because there are conflicting messages here. You have one from Jennifer Granholms. I talked to friends in North Carolina yesterday, they were seeing gas lines, we didnt see them in virginia until last night as i was coming home. I started seeing gas lines in alexander. I understand peoples response. I do think that Colonial Pipeline will be back on line by the end of the week. This is why Cyber Security needs to be a higher priority for all of us. When the bad guys in this case, it was a russian criminal gang. When the bad guys try to shut down a companys operation, theyll be many times successful. What i most fear from a security standpoint, many of your viewers may have remembered a few months ago where russia got into 16,000 companies and they only decided to exfiltrate certain companies. The way hackers have done with Colonial Pipeline, we could have had our whole economy come grinding to the stop. The good news is it is totally bipartisan. I agree you will have industry support to make sure there is a mandatory reporting period so that somebody is attacking like this critical infrastructure, the security firms out there and the cloud providers like microsoft and amazon and the fbi and Homeland Security all know that in realtime because right now even the case of Colonial Pipeline of this critical part of infrastructure there was no mandatory requirements. Senator, it is willie geist, yesterday we had chris kreb on the show, we asked him how could this happen and he said frankly it could be as simple as this ransom group sending an email to colonial and shuts down the gas line. How could that be possible in this day and age if the company is not prepared for this . The socalled sending an email called a phishing export. It happens all the time. Making your company totally safe, the bad guys only try to get in one time. Yes, we need cyber hygiene. When the bad guys do get in breakthrough, we can post our whole network and get back in a timely fashion. In the case of Colonial Pipeline, it appears these guys got in and fairly so launched new tactic. In the case of solar wind, they were inside our system months and going further in and if we had not had the case of solar, a private company voluntarily comes forward, we may still not have known the fact. If you combine the denial of service which is colonial with the expanding supply chain kind of, Many Companies are being infected. Solar wind, you have the potential for disaster and right now we dont have a way for the good guys in the private sector and the government to find out that information. The good news is people will realize this in the cyber dough domain. It is time to put that senator. We want to bring some breaking news into the conversation. The u. S. Labor Department Released new inflation numbers. The Consumer Price index rose 4. 2 in april over its level a year ago. Before we get back to the senator on this. Lets bring in stephanie ruhle. What do these numbers mean . Listen, this is a very big jump. This is a biggest jump we have seen since 2008. This has people across the board concerned. If you go to any Kitchen Table across america, people are talking about their gas prices are up and grocery bills up and lumber prices are up. You have to put it in context, theyre up against last year when things were down. 2019, things are steadily going up in line, not this huge jump. You have to factor in what just happened to us. This time year we were not spending any money or going anywhere, we were in a shutdown. A year later, we were back out there in a spending boom and also the last year there was a production lab, Food Production and transportation shipping and all of those things were impacted which is why we are facing shortages. Combine shortages and demand, the treasury department, the fed had said hold on a second, this is going to work itself out. But, this does cause a problem at least in the short term for the Biden Administration. Theyre looking to get through over 4 trillion of infrastructures spending right after a jobs report that was disappointing and inflation number that had people across the country eventhough we are saving more money saying hold on for a second, i dont want to pay more. This is a hurdle for them. Let me ask you by looking at these numbers, i am curious what your gut reaction is. Anybody watches this show, i have been warning about inflation and big deficits and debt, i have been wrong for 25 years, maybe i am just a product of like growing up in the 70s and 80s. I am curious of Larry Summers and others talking about inflation pressure because we are pumping more money in the economy than taking out because of covid. We see the future going down on wall street from the people that you talk to everyday, are they concerned about inflation and do you think this jump, 4. 2 jump is going to fuel those concerns or give them the sense of relief that it may not be as bad as they worry about. Listen, joe, inflation is not necessarily a bad thing. A little inflation is okay. Of course, unfortunately it hurts people at the bottom the most. Theyre the people who have suffered so much this year while people on top have had a good year. This flush of money thats in the system right now, thats going to work itself out, too. All that happened in the last year white house temporary. It is not like those stimulus checks are going to be coming every month. I would say go online is what the fed is saying. While you have an economic recovery, it does not move ahead like a straight shot. There is some kicks in it. Look at that jobs number, it does not say businesses are not doing well, theyre not hiring. No, it is going to take some time to get back on track. Stephanie, thank you so much. Well see you at 9 00. Senator, your thoughts on obviously, you follow the markets closely and you follow the economy closely, youre a number guy from way back. Any concerns of pumping so much into the economy that perhaps the inflation will really push it up for the first time in like what, 30 or 40 years . John, i got some concerns and like you i spent years and years with the socalled gang of role plans. No negative implications yet. I am not sure on stephanies promise. I think it is pretty much dead on. We have put 5 trillion into the economy. I think history will treat that as smart because otherwise, well have a melt down. The feds got a good handle on this. If it goes on another quarter, it will be a much more significant warning sign. I would point out though the money that we put out, none of those dollars that are going to stay in state and local government and even hit the street yet, this will be coming into the economy over the next year plus. For anyone to say that we should not have been doing anything on infrastructure. You know joe thats not a Good Business plan for america for our roads and rails and airports and our third world compares to the kind of airports we see around the world or highspeed rail. A once in a generation plan, and we can debate the contour of that. It is paid for. It is absolutely the right thing to do. Republicans are actually, tlr talks that are moving forward. Lets hope democrats and republicans can come together. Janet yellen said a few weeks ago because of low Interest Rates, if you look at the percentage of our budget that goes to servicing the debt, it is about the same as 2021 as it was in the 1980s. Senator, thank you so much for being with us. Joe, one caveat though. I have Great Respect for secretary yellen, if Interest Rate goes up 1 point, it adds 200 a year of annual interest. That comes before medicare and spend Everything Else. And that is. Thats the real concern. If Interest Rates go up to what they have been over the past 40 years, that price tag for servicing the debt absolutely explodes. The senators right. Thank you so much for being with us. Coming up, a little therapy session for the morning to help washington. We continue the conversation we started. Will and i have something we need to work through. Yes, this will be yeah, willie and you. How our nations leaders are practicing mindfulness. Thats next on morning joe. Odor protection that works new dove men plantbased care. Theres interest you accrue, and interests you pursue. Plans for the long term, and plans for a long weekend. At thrivent, we believe money is a tool, not a goal. To learn more, text thrive to 444555, or visit thrivent. Com. Hey google, turn up the heat. Bipolar depression. Its a dark, lonely place. This is art inspired by real stories of People Living with bipolar depression. Emptiness. A hopeless struggle. The lows of bipolar depression can disrupt your life and be hard to manage. Latuda could make a real difference in your symptoms. Latuda was proven to significantly reduce bipolar depression symptoms, and in clinical studies, had no substantial impact on weight. Now im feeling connected. Empowered. Latuda is not for everyone. Call your doctor about unusual mood changes, behaviors or suicidal thoughts. Antidepressants can increase these in children, teens, and young adults. Elderly dementia patients on latuda have an increased risk of death or stroke. Call your doctor about fever, stiff muscles, and confusion, as these may be lifethreatening, or uncontrollable muscle movements as these may be permanent. These are not all the serious side effects. This is where i want to be. Talk to your doctor and ask if latuda could make the difference youve been looking for in your bipolar depression symptoms. This is how you become the best [music youre the best by joe esposito] [music youre the best by joe esposito] [triumphantly yells] [ding] dont get mad. Get e trade and take charge of your finances today. Ive got the brains youve got the looks lets make lots of money youve got the brawn ive got the brains lets make lots of uh uh uh oohhh theres a lot of opportunities with allstate, drivers who switched saved over 700. Saving is easy when youre in good hands. Allstate click or call to switch today. Meditation and mindfulness can get a little controlled of the Substance Use that we have, the opioid crisis. How can we take the advantage of the improved funding and the Science Behind it. We are sitting at the center of the opioid crisis. Here i am an old quarterback outside of ohio, who was in congress and blue collar town and blue collar family and im siting here talking to you about yoga. Why . Why am i doing this . It works. It will me and dan and helps people who have addiction issues and so many other kids in school. It helps. If it was Something Else i would be saying look, we got to be doing this because it works. That was congressman tim ryan with our chief medical correspondent Dave Campbell at the yoga benefit mindfulness. Will, we were talking about this yesterday. These doctors from massachusetts, he wrote dbt for dummy. They had these dbt for dummies, it debut at number one on the amazon. Com, worldwide web, number one, willie, it sold more books in the first state and loaded. Wow. I have never seen anything like it before. Two of the classics. Crazy. That was a big day when rome was burng and took over. You got to love congressman ryan there, sitting in his Baker Mayfield tshirt. I know a lot of people now who over the last few years are practicing yoga and practicing other forms of mindfulness and it seems to work for a lot of people. You are saying you can touch your toes. Thats not what it is about. Tim ryan is a huge proponent of training and needs to remained streamed. Lets bring in on those experts, dbt, a therapy that teaches the people the skills to manage strong emotions and volatile relationships and stressful situations. Dr. Jillian gallen, authored the book child adolescence. Medic at the three east unit at Mclean Hospital and their new book is dbt for dummies. Jillian, before we go into this whole thing of mindfulness being yoga and touching toes and as you have called woo woo and people have called it woo woo and its not. This is about science, slowing down and then doing able to do better in basic relationships in life. Can you explain the Science Behind mindfulness . Yeah. I think so youre right. Every once in a while, not once in a while, a lot of the time people are afraid of mindfulness, they think, ooh, im not sure what that is. What is mindfulness . What is this thing . What is this fad . How does it fit into yoga. Its practice and attention. Most of us live relatively mindless habitual lives and we go through our routine and we interact and multitack, and mindfulness is about learning to Pay Attention. John cabotson has a fantastic definition they think brings it home for people that this is not something that they cant reach. He says we Pay Attention in a particular way without judgment and on purpose, right . We learn to direct our attention and we take that muscle in our brain and for some of us the mussel strong and for other people we need to build that muscle. Unfortunately, things like social media can weaken that muscle, but its about attention, paying attention to what our thoughts are, what our reactions are and when we can actually Pay Attention, its great. We can sit in that space between the urge to do something, to respond to an email and to Say Something to a friend, to respond on social media, and we can start to step back and Pay Attention and notice that thats a thought, thats an urge and thats a feeling and actually make a decision about what we want to do next so we can become less reactive people in our lives, and theres many, many studies on mindfulness and blaise can talk about those and you can see through scans and questionnaires that we can change our brain in as short as two weeks by practicing mindfulness. Its the same attempt to have retrained the taste buds on food. Blaise aguirre, if you work on mindfulness and apply it to your life it leads to a more thoughtful, methodical approach to thinking which technology has interrupted all of our brains especially young brains which are constantly darting from one thing to another, and id love to hear more about the impact that mindfulness can have on retraining the brain to be less reactive, or in my case, actually requiring less medicine to go to sleep at night because i go to bed really early and mindfulness has allowed me to be able to fall asleep again. Can you explain the Science Behind that . Whats happening in the brain when you apply mindfulness . So one of the things that we know especially when people are very emotionally disregulated and meaning that their emotions are out of control is that they spend a lot of time in the part of the brain and thats firing all of the time and that generates a whole lot of emotions and those emotions lead to a whole lot of thoughts and in most cases theyre worry thoughts and theyre not going to the beach thoughts. So what happens is as you get caught up in all of those emotions, its just very difficult to fall asleep because youre worried about today. Youre worried about tomorrow and worried about what will happen to everybody, so by slowing that down and what we know is when people practice mindfulness the amigdula begins to settle down and you realize that these worry thoughts arent anything that happens right now. Theres nothing so bad right at this present moment that you cant deal with it and you get back to the present moment, the only moment we ever really have you realize that its not such a bad moment and you can get through it and its only moments when were not living in this one that we suffer and you cant fall asleep. Thats me. Jillian, two things when i started learning about this six months ago that had an impact on me in thinking, wait a second, this isnt as you say, woo woo. Theres something to it. Somebody sent me a study that showed when you practice mindfulness in a week sometimes, that actually your brain changes on the scans and that was where i realized objectively this played a big difference in peoples lives. The second thing was something that that you talked about, and that is when you have a thought that comes to your mind and you want to react to it quickly, and i still make that mistake sometimes where i try to react too quickly, you talk about looking at that thought as just its in the mind, all right. Its not necessarily real. Dont suffer twice. It may never come to fruition, but you sort of have this its in the mind. Let it go. Ruminate on it, bring it back in later and think about it and then make your decision on how to respond. This is the wonderful thing about mindfulness. So i can be here and i can have lots of thoughts in my brain and i can just notice them as my thoughts, right . What interferes with that capacity and why mindfulness can be so challenging is emotions. The stronger we feel something, right . The more quickly we want to move. In dbt we call that an emotion mind. I have to do it right now. We have to react. We think about it as this muscle that i can build that muscle and like flexing a bicep, like, wow. I really want to say this, react in this way, do this, buy this, whatever it is right now and i can just pause. I can just wait a second and then i can actually decide, do i want to move forward with this right now . Thats fine. You can or maybe i want to wait a little bit. Maybe i should talk this over. Maybe i should sleep on it, whatever it is, but i can just sit and pause and thats okay. Ill tell you, blaise, one of the great things that i heard you guys talk about that makes such a huge difference and its three words that we use around our house an awful lot and it helps with anxiety. Dont suffer twice. When youre afraid somethings going to happen and how are we going to respond and then one of us will say to another, dont suffer twice. Explain that concept. Yes. So i see this a lot with the young people i work with, and they come into my office and they say i failed a test. Now, if you failed a test then you will suffer when you get the results back. Thats the moment to suffer. Theres no point in suffering now for something youre going to suffer with later. So if you start worrying about having failed that test, you suffer that entire time, then you failed the test and now youre suffering again. On the other hand, if you havent failed the test and youve done pretty well then you suffered needlessly. Suffer only at the moment when suffering is required and not ahead of time and you arent only suffering once, twice, three times and then you suffer again and all of that suffering that happens ahead of time begins to impact your day and you stress out and all that sort of stuff. That is the bottom line in terms of how you started the show. Joe, dont surfer twice on the issue you were talking about with your family and friends and the new book is dbt for dummies, dr. S Gillian Galen and blaise aguirre, and right now, liz cheney entering the room where the Republican Caucus is going to determine her fate. Its a defining moment for the Republican Party. She made what i called earlier a eulogy, a speech last night in the house in front of only one member, one republican member who sat there, ken buck of colorado. All of the others walking out of the chamber. They didnt want to hear, perhaps, out of shame what she was telling them about where the party has been and what it stood for one minute from now. Joe, she truly is the woman of the moment. I have to say, i salute her. Dont agree with her, never really have, but today i stand with liz cheney. And i think so many people that may not have agreed with what she believed in, what i believe in, what conservatives believe in politically, actually are in her corner as she actually fights for peaceful transitions, for free and Fair Elections, and for the recognition of people who win elections fairly and democratically. Every trump judge has confirmed that that has had this case brought before them. Its time for republicans to also accept that reality. That does it for us this morning. Stephanie youll picks up the coverage right now. Hi there. Im stephanie ruhle. It is wednesday, may 12th and we are following several breaking stories in the nations capitol right now. First, House Republicans are meeting Behind Closed Doors at this very moment. They will vote soon on whether to oust congresswoman liz cheney from gop leadership, and this just in, growing fears over inflation. With the consumerprice index, cpi rising 4. 2 in april from a year ago. That is more than expected and the fastest pace in