The shooting occurred in the 600 block of 11th Drive NW, according to police. Butler's murder charge could bring a death sentence or a life sentence if he is convicted, according to VonAllman. Other possibilities are 25-years-to-life and 30-years-to-life. Aggravated robbery carries a prison term of three to 11 years and a possible fine up to $20,000. Mark Perlaky of the Tuscarawas County Public Defender's Office is representing Butler. Butler was free on bond in a Stark County case at the time of Carlisle's murder. He is scheduled to stand trial April 5 on four counts of felonious assault and one count of discharging a firearm in or near prohibited premises in Canton. All the charges carry specifications that a gun was used in the crimes. The charges came from an April 2020 incident in which Butler allegedly fired a gun into the air, then into a car where a young woman and three teenage girls were sitting. Gunshots hit the car and injured a 17-year-old girl. She was hit by debris when the bullet hit the car.