Pirro, along with jessica tarlov, jesse watters, Shannon Bream and greg gutfeld. Its 5 00 in new york city, and this is the five judge jeanine the republican candidates picking uhep the piec after a wild second debate. Th. E contenders ripping each other to shredothes while tryin sell themselves as the best chance to defeat president idden. But the big question is, did anyone break through . The candidates seemed to care more about delivering their 1line zingers and talking over each other than trying to win over actual voters. You are a ducking these things and let me tell you whats going to happen. You keep doing that, no one up here is going to call you donald trump anymor e were going to call you donned duck. Im theny only one up here has gotten in the big fights and delivered big deliveries. Joe biden doesnt belong on the picket line he belongs on the unemployment line. Bring it then. You hung your curtains. They were there before i even showed up as the residence. Excuse me. Excuse me thank you while im speaking. Literally. If i may. Chairman, you cant be on both sides. Gentlemen, youll have your turn. Every time i hear you i feel a little bit dumber for what you say. Vivek put your hand down for a second will you . I still got time dude, so chill out. Judge jeanine the debate was so ruckus our very own dana perino at times had to lay down the law. But does that mean obama care is here to stay . Well, thank you for reiterating the question because bed love to answer it. We will get someone questions but you have to let us move on. We are going to the border yet. These are good people on theo stage. They disagree buplt lets have legitimate disagreement i would say. Stewart can we get backbu to the question. No, we cannot. Governor desantis i am going straight sir, well have to cut your w micil and i dont wao do that. Do i dont want. So Governor Desantis, lenwantt to you. I doha want to just remind everyone. These aryoe one minutes per questions three seconds for a followup and the more you mention each other that means the fewer questions youre going to get. Judge jeanine dana is here to help us break down what happened. Dana were all going to be asking you questions but you here. Enave been we were all talking about how great you weree al and how you h delivered that line. Thank you. Judge jeanine back to u really did lay down the law so were all very proud of you you did a great yo job. Bud t were going to go around e table and ask you questions. Okay, great. Judge jeanine well each give you a take. I watched to see who was connecting and, you know, where that special moment was coming. And for me nikki haley was the moment. For me, when i watched nikki haley, i saw a woman who, number one, took no prisoners, who wasnt afraid of the men. She literally squared off with her Body Language to the men. Ann d she said, you know, know your facts, know your homework, bring it tim, talking to senator tim scott, and then, with vivek that one line, the more i listenst to you i feel dumber for having to you. But i think nikki haley added some points, hopefully from her point of fro view, on top of wh she did from the Firstdi Debatee now, iba Thought Desantis continued with the samcoe kindn, i did a great job in florida, i did this, and i can do it againa i dont know that there wan s anything new there. I thini dok vivek with a finger the air started to get a little aggravating. I kept wanting him to put his fingert down. And burgum i thought the guy was just a new sense he kept jumping in and i thought you handled him very well. An td Chris Christie to me, the only reason hes there is to take down donald trump or donald duck as he called him. He wasnt there to explain to the American People what he could do but t simply to say th Donald Trumps a horrible person and that he suffers from trump derangement syndrome. But, dana, you had a front row seat. You got to see them up close and personal. And from your vantage point, who do you think won the night . O do i think your analysis ist adding to the consensus that, one, maybe there wasnt one breakout star from the night. I doe think that all of them ft a need to speak, sometimes to speak all at once and sometimes to say all the things that they wanted teao say in one answer. Which was difficult to handle and not that helpful. Ul for example, we wanted to start off with theo economy and i believe the first answer from Vivek Ramaswamy answered everything including then the border and fentanyl and crime. Ed and ti said believe me, you kn were going to get to all of those things you dont have to answer them all in the first he question. I think in some ways because they were under a lostt of pressure to get some time in, there is a frustration when th thereers multiple candidates ae i understand this. Theres multiple candidates thee als. L want to answer the same questions but if you did that you would basically you would ask them four questions and you really wouldnt get anywhere. Sodnt there were certainly som good moments. Actually the line of the night that makes me laugh is when vivek said thank you for speaking over me when im in interrupting. Judge jeanine that was a great line. I wasg up like, oh, they mig have learned that one on the fa i thave. Judge jeanine they he turned that around. Greghat your take. Greg i g think danas wro there was a breakout star and it was Dana Perinuto [cheers and applause]. Greg ne a i did not envy youa i was watching it, you were mu pretty much shouldering the load for two hours and you didnt break a sweat. B it wasre amazing. My problem with the debate wasnt really thwae candidates all, because the outcomes you get are created by the design and Fox Joining Univision perhaps was the worst partnership ive seen since bud light hired dylan mulvaney. E you had a host unload a litany of liberal cliches whose premises we challenge every single day and yet they were treated as approved truths. She had no followup to each one which was weird. So so it was like a deliberate list prepared by the dnc to tweak the candidates and the audience. It didnt feel like a Journalism Debate it felt like the view , without pastries. I this isnt on fox right so don accuse me of shooting in the tent. Hosthas had their autonomy to is their questions. This is on the rnc who thought they had to partner with o thought it would be value added, instead it was value sub tracted. Give univision their own debatei right . Instead ofhe loading questions with like these not so subtle accusations. Idat i was waiting no er her to ask one of the candidates when was th e last time you beat your y. Kids. It was so silly. I would reexamine the ur structure, less questions against a ton of candidates, consider the as you can see of podcasting where you can go deep whether its vivek or rfk jr. We tend to learn a lot. Maybe one night debates you have 4 30 minute debates with two Candidatesan G each, that way pr can talk, theres no insulting because people rel actually rel to each other. This debail felt like 2015. Its 2023. Maybe its time to reexamine this. Judge jeanine all right, r jesse, your ighttake . Jesse well, i thought you i looked very good on camera, dana. And i know c thats the most important thing. I would say that hair makeup and wardrobe won the debate. Jesse your eyes i think i dont think wi need to say anything else. Greg you shouldnt. Jesse and i know you dont have any children. Bu ht you had seven last night. And the cross talk was so tedious, dana, these candidates have t o learn how to throw a punch and wait and react. They cant keep talking all over each other. It is like music. You cant just play the same note on the guitar. And it felt like they were just trying to speed through all of their memorized Talking Points until the bell rings. Ll its like a chorus. Yeah. Jesse you got your hook, you got the drum solo, maybe you s have a Hornacek Shun and you av kind of just weave it in like this beautiful. Everyone was talking at the same time and you couldnt understan. A thing. There was also no story. En when donald trump was running for president , he had a story about america, about where america was and where he was going to take this country. Tr remember, the chinese were hollowing out the industrial base. He was going to bring these jos back through trade deals, smashu isis, dc was corrupt he was going to build a wall and cut taxes and regulations. Everybody knew what he wanted to do. Do you have any idea what any of thest e candidates want to do . I dont even know if they want n to cut taxes . Ta are they going to Fire Powell Ay the fed . Are they going to bust up monopolies in Silicon Valley . Gi learned nothing from these people last night. From so theyre not talking to the audience. Theyre talking toie thenc came talking at the camera, but at home, were watching it through the television on a couch and its not making any impression whatsoever. Viveks got spirit, but i cant stop looking at his forehead. And then i go higher and i look at his hair, and then i go higher and i start looking at the sky. Desantis tried to rise above things, i give him credit for that. Hes got the record, but theres no emotion. Then theres nicky who looked annoyed. And then theres scott who cant even deliver a punch. And then theres doug, we have to sayt goodbye to doug. And then we have christie, who r actually aism captivated by. When he speaks i listen and then he tells a joke that bombs. So all of these people i think go down in the polls after thish trump goes up, and thats that. Judge jeanine shannon. Shannon okay this whole thing. One of the things. Shannon go ahead dana. I was going to say one of the things that for me towards the end of the debate when i asked the survivor question, let me explain why i asked that, at because everybody that is a y republican voter who either doesnt wantwh to vote for trum or is open to voting to someone else is looking at the field saying at some point they have to coalesce behind one person if they have any hope or prayer of catching President Trump. And all the republicans know that. And so, okay, fine they didnt n want to participate, but their staffs call all of us every day and want to tell us exactly who they think should be voted off i the island. T willing to do it in ub public. Okay . So i get it, some people loved the question some people hated it, whatever. Bu, t they would not be able to answer the question of how mathematically are you actually going to do this and i didnt see that last night. Shannon and wee do know th Chris Christie wrote down a name, i bet i can figure out who that is. 8. He was one guy. I i think it was trump. Shannon he probably did. I will say hes the only one wh looks like hes having fun, when you ask gop voters whos the one person you would never vote for, hes number one on the list so he knows theres no path forwars but he seems like hes enjoying this. Felt very Lord Of The Flies last night. I have to tell you it is good for people to have zingers you just have to look like you didnte yo plan the zincers and execution ise tough. But youre there at the reagan library, the Master Communicator and he knew he would get asked about his age in 1974 he was 73g they were asking about him going into a second term and he had ththe wonderful line, im not going to exploit the youth and inexperience of my competitor but heence landed it as if he j thought of it and i dont think anybody landed their preplanned lines last night. One thing that was strange was when i asked vicepresident pence about obamacare and the record and he said last month that they would d again be repealing and replacing obamacare. And he said let me first talk abouirstt guns and mass shootin and how he was going to call for the death penalty. And im like, okay, but Still Obamacare . Like can we answer that . Th the otheinr thing because they were all talking over each other shanno n there could have been th one of those lines and it got swallowed. Greg had an interesting point abou dt structure. He one way is imagine youre at by your dining table and by Virtuay Reality the candidates could pou into your Family Dinner and you could ask questions and get more of a personal answer. A little ai wouldnt maybe hurt. The other thing is i really wanted to asg k about child car this is a huge upon and i did research during the debate, theres moms trying to figure out is it worth me working . Up to 50 of your income has toa go to child care. They kind of answered it but tho format doesnt give you enough. But shannon ive taken up all your time. I please go ahead. Shannon you say when people throw in the kitchen sink. To me when i was in ms. America a hundred years ago last century they can ask you whatever question you want but you have to get your answer i have to get to my Talking Points and to my platform. There was a lot of that last night. The question you asked last night had no relation to what they wanted to say. Judge jeanine yep. Jessica jessica im glad you brought up the Child Care Question i texted you during the debate a wonderful thing to bring up because it connects the economy with rolling back abortion rights Kitchen Table all of it and ppoii thought people were tg to steer around Common Sense O Extensions to the topics were talking about on a daily basis here. My general takhe e away was that, obviously im not the Target Demo Fore Ta this debate but i understand why everyone who do likes donald trump is completelu unmoved looking at these candidates. Completely uninspiring, he ri probably picked up a few extras there. D why do you think it was only christie and desantis, though, that even touched the Trump D Issue at all . Well, i think, and i admire i think Ron Desantis E commended for a couplegs things. T into the fray early on. W i would have liked to have ha gotten to ron desantis more Quickly Inntis the debate but because everyone was talking cas over each other and not ov following the rules it kept pushing it back. Burut to his credit he didnt actually jump in and if you loot at the l Washington Post poll overnight i dont know how accurate those things are but be far and away he won the debate w according to the people they polled. I think he realizes if donald trump is going to spend all his money against him he might as t well try to take him on. Chris christie we know what his position is. Ch i actually do think he answered a lo t of good questions about especially crime he willinong a on c the border he had a good answer on that. But Vivek Ramaswamy, he was happy to bringbu up President Trump buk rat in a way that wasy complimentary so that was happening. I do wonder, though, can i run by you guys what my original last question was that i dont think people wanted me to do in the room. But what i wanted to say, i wanted to say one answer only, go down the row, dog or cat. Oh. C its over for anyone who ss cat. Different kind of survivor question. Greg obama would say which one tastes better jessica you used that joke yesterday, its played out. Judge jeanine anyway, dana thanks so much. Thank you all for your Support Jessica congratulation. You handled it so well. Judge jeanine yes, you did. And coming up next, the question that stopped every candidate in their tracks and i it has to do with donald trump. Do with donald trump. Providing for your family is a top priority. But what happens when you need Affordable Health care . Christian Health Care Ministries could save you up to 40 today. As a member, you can choose your provider without network restrictions. Sign up at your convenience with our anytime enrollment. Join a Christian Community that supports each others medical expenses, offering peace of mind as you prioritize whats most important. Enroll now at your chm dot org got problems, and i dont think we can solve em. You made a really deep cut jesse its the big moment from the debate dana was just telling us about. Can anybody on the stage defeat trump . Candidates, its now obvious that if you all stay in the race, former President Donald Trump wins the nomination. None of you have indicated that youre dropping out. So which one of you, on stage tonight, should be voted off the island . Please use your marker to write your choice on the note pad in front of you, 15 seconds starting now. Of the people on the stage who should be. Are you serious . With all due respect, were here, like were happy to debate. I think that thats disrespectful to my fellow competitors. I think im the only one on this stage thats been clear about this. I vote donald trump off the island right now. Jesse what did you think of desantis there . Judge jeanine you know what . I gave him credit. Because desantis didnt look around. Remember the first debate he looked around to see what other people were doing before he raised his hand with everyone. I think it was about will you support the candidate that the party nominates. I like that. I liked that he indicated that, you know, im not going to play this where you go and where you go. Heres the bottom line. Trump is at 56. Hes 42 points ahead of desantis. You know what . Trump wins whether theyre all in or out, trump still wins. Jesse and then you have iowa and that will shake loose a bunch of People Jessica it should but people should get this together sooner. If they really think that donald trump is not the guy that should be leading the republican party, there has to be some coordination. It