A completely different soviet union, in the soviet union, in which stalin was already at the top, it was possible to hold such alternative demonstrations, in support of trotsky and against trotsky, workers, not some bourgeoisie, workers of the putilovsky plant, ugh , held demonstrations in support of zinoev and his group in the party, and these were the 1920s and early 1930s. In the 36th year the secretaries of the regional committees of the party took a plan for the number of people shot, this is a completely different story, because in the 28th or 29th year, if you told the secretary of some committee of the bolshevik party, and you have to write a plan, how many people you will shoot this year, he would have decided that you were crazy, in 37 it didnt seem crazy, it seemed normal, and only 10 years had passed, and in russia 10 years had passed from the 14th to the 24th, you see how she changed, imagine the next 10 years, its just in one day everything is not happening, so when we say, navalnys funeral was held and nothing, then maybe its not the appearance of an alternative but. A free massacre of an alternative, because once again these people gathered for navalnys funeral, but remember 10 years ago they they were not going to the funeral, they were going to the demonstration in support of navalny in the center of moscow, not on its outskirts, there were much more of them, and now they are afraid even to come to the funeral, you understand, and thats natural, im not telling the whole story of issuing the body shameful with that in fact, they, we, yes, we found out about the causes of death, you can find out , look at who to trust, if our intelligence, then it is a blood clot, well, ours, our intelligence, i wont even comment on it, i mean, really, it was , was the examination of the body, after the thrombusthrombus, good, which could be trusted, but the relatives did not insist on reexamination. They agreed that the person would at least be buried in exchange for the fact that they would not ask unnecessary questions, well, this is also an important point, no one asked this question to the funeral, as if a person died, but she did not die, as the president of ukraine said, in order to refute here the statement of our chief military intelligence more. Officially, the instance and this person were killed, and i absolutely agree with the president of ukraine in this regard, so for me this is not the beginning of any development of events in russia, but for me it is confirmation that putin has once again shown that he can do everything , whatever, and nothing will happen to him, because you understand, navalny, lets say, was a symbol much larger socially. Agreement than the war with ukraine, but we said that the russians, they do not oppose the war in ukraine en masse , there were no such actions in the 202nd year, at least in the 14th, thats a lot, remember, they were huge actions in the 14th year, they did not change anything, and we saw a huge number of people who went out into the streets in all russian cities, not isolated pickets, where all these people, they were scared, they left, they were disappointed in their opportunities. And now it is absolutely obvious that even destruction a person who was for many there a symbol of some hopes, we are not saying now whether it was justified or not, but it was oleksiy navalny. Destined to become a symbol of these hopes for change, and these people absolutely sincerely believed that this could be the president of russia when, if the putin regime collapses, they saw him in this role, and everyone saw him in this role, i never understood why, to me it was a religious question that people believed that, but thats what they believed, with this man linked their faith in change, as by the way , once in the late 80s, early 90s, they linked their faith in. Change to the person of boris yeltsin, and well, that is, rational or irrational, thats another question, but it was a matter of faith, and now this person was killed in the colony in a terrible way, this person was imprisoned for absolutely nothing, everyone knows that too , its just because she was also slandered because she. They wanted to destroy the existing la to the court, as a witness, yesterday she was at a funeral, and after that funeral she was detained, also surreal, however, the person behind, according to whose testimony navalny was later given this de facto death sentence, came to say goodbye to him and was detained by the moscow police. Surname zelensky, navalnys operator, former fbk, there are coincidences, so they arrested zelensky after all, you know, you at least another zelensky, but at navalnys funeral, because they value this symbolism, they needed to pohoren navalny to arrest zelensky, that is all the problems of solving, and this also says a lot, so. In this regard, and what i wanted to emphasize, that this also did not lead to any mass disturbances, the question arises, what else does putin have to do in russia to cause mass unrest, this is actually an experiment, because there is nothing else that can stir up a huge number of people, there is already a war, the death of the most popular Opposition Leader is already there. What should i do to eat children 10 years on yes for breakfast . Well, they will say that volodymyr volodymovich must eat something, he knows better, so this is what we are talking about, in fact, we are talking about a tamed society, this is a decade, exactly a decade, everyone could think, why did he start this with ukraine from the 14th for the 24th year, this is the decade of a tamed society, the transformation of an authoritarian country. Managed democracy, remember, we said that, which was absolutely disgusting, but under it you could live in a totalitarian state, under which you cannot live, it is disgusting, low, vile, inhumane, but they live and can no longer do anything about it, in the 14th year they still could, the opportunities for change were not used, and now there are no changes in totalitarianism, in totalitarianism there are changes and only the death of the peasant and some other cataclysms that have not yet been observed. Thank you khrystyna for this conversation, thank you very much, vitaly portnikov, and the saturday political club, which will return to you, it is easy to guess khrystyna yatskiv, see you next saturday, be with us, there are discounts on antiques. There are 15 discounts on plantain and saver pharmacies spazmal tablets 15 in pharmacies plantain to you and saver premium sponsor of the National Team represents united by football together stronger. A separate set of Unmanned Aircraft complexes sapsan of the state special service of transport. The viewers of the espresso channel are asked to join the collection of defense funds and technical equipment for our unit. Thank you, glory to ukraine, heroes. Hi its svoboda ranok, an informational project of radio svoboda. Top guests every day. This is the shipping district of kherson. Turn on live. We are somewhere in the vicinity of bakhmut. We tell the main thing. On weekdays at 9 00. Vasyl zimas big broadcast. Two hours of air time. Two hours of your time. Two hours to learn about the war and how the world lives. Two hours to keep up with economic news. And sports news, two hours in the company of favorite presenters, presenters who have become likeminded to many, as well as distinguished guests of the studio, events of the day in two hours, vasyl zimas big broadcast, a project for intelligent and caring people, in the evening at espresso. Premium sponsor of the National Team represents united by football, stronger together. Greetings to all, it is sunday morning, so we will summarize the week in football format. The upl returns, shovkovsky scores 100 points. The audience returned to the stands and talked about how oleksandria was embarrassed, and we, oleksandr vashchuk and andriy malinovskyi, will tell a little more. Hello, andrew. Hello, hello, hello sasha, hello to all our supporters. There is enough, given that last sunday was during the press conference with zelensky, so today we are working with with Double Energy and with double events, so yes, lets try to fit everything into our 45 minute half now, lets move on to the fact that the upl is back and back, lets just say, there were a lot of interesting results in the 18th round, and one of the results, lets say oleksandria shakhtar 0 0, there is a high probability of 99. 9 that it will be. Three in favor of shakhtar. Well, yes, it is already clear that it will be a technical defeat for oleksandria, and by the game itself, of course, the content with which ruslan ratan approached, he liked it, with the way oleksandria nakryla shakhtar almost didnt allow the favorite of this championship, the current champion, to do anything, but of course, this mistake and the unannounced puddle will now cost not only alexandria this point, but also those who are fighting with the miner for the championship. Thats why now oleksandria was responding and getting a result not only for itself, but also for the competitors of shakhtar donetsk, so the fact that now shakhtar, which failed to beat oleksandria, will score three points, of course, it was oleksandria that failed in this way and also dynamo, there kryvbas, polisi, who else is fighting, and yes, kalyuzhny was one of the best on the field, he was nominated for the upl player of the week, and he could have won it if it werent for the army of dynamo fans who voted for vanata about. But we tried to to contact the representatives of alexandria, they said that there is nothing to say so far, except that they issued an official statement, lets then go to this official statement that Ivan Kalyuzhny, this is a statement from alexandria, we inform you that unfortunately, midfielder Ivan Kalyuzhny is not was declared for fc oleksandria in the match against fc shakhtar on february 26, 2024, we apologize to all the fans of the team and the Coaching Staff, this regrettable mistake happened due to the human factor, Ivan Kalyuzhny. A player of our club since 2021 and played for other clubs at various times on loan rights, when the player was entered into the ingame application for the upl systems in the referee report section, the system accepted the player as declared, although he was deregistered on august 29, 2023, which did not allow for a timely response to the entire situation, the sports director has been removed from his duties, the case has been referred to the control and disciplinary committee, which will make a decision on this incident, tomorrow there will be a preliminary meeting of the kdc, and so. What do you think, its still only alexandrias fault, or the fact that the system accepted the player, you can also say that it is, say, a system bug . Well, maybe now you can look for extremes, but in fact alexandria is to blame, because i also contacted several representatives of the clubs, how are these applications made, in fact, it the full full responsibility of the club, we can now blame anyone, and the upl system, and the uaf, and the referees, but its still alexandrias business, its a fault. And the problem of oleksandria, well, you see, the sports director should be removed here, well, if, relatively speaking, shakhtar wins one point against kyiv dynamo, well , they are the last at the finish line of the championship, then who will be responsible, the sports director, too, that dynamo will not get into the champions league, well, its so very strange, because im saying that oleksandria, well, she gave this match possible one of the best, if not the best this season, because they go there, fight for survival and you know at 0 0, maybe this is not the case for the team. Well, alexandria is fine, we understand what the clubs ambitions are, again, we remember the previous season, how ruslan rutan came, when yuriy guru was fired, who did his job perfectly, but there in the team. There are not enough matches, a few points in order to be third, however, they took the Coaching Staff of ruslan ratan for him to make oleksandria bronze, but we we see that oleksandria failed last season, did not even qualify for the eurocup, although it had a huge advantage over vorskla, but the finish was a complete failure, and the start of this season is also a failure for oleksandria, and to a large extent we understand that oleksandria is currently mostly fighting for survival, despite the fact that the ambitions, the composition, and the Coaching Staff are very strong in this team. Well, look, if. A good game by oleksandria there, well, we understand that this means that shakhtar did not complete something, because with that composition, almost the entire team is the National Team of ukraine, right . Venezuela or someone else, and the same, well, there are these expensive brazilian players, but shakhtar is absolutely unimpressive, and well, this match with alexandria confirmed this trend that we saw in the games with marseille. Yes, shakhtar was the first to start the season, played official matches with marseille, despite the fact that we understood what problems marseille had. We understood what coaching changes were made in the club, and as for the composition of the donetsk miner, it is undoubtedly the strongest in ukraine at the moment, there are no questions, taking into account the basis that we see now, and the selection performers, and the rotation that can be applied by the Coaching Staff of the donetsk miner, but still there are nuances again for the coach, we understand that marina pushych has never prepared a team in such a winter offseason, because where he worked in the lower dutch divisions, they play there in winter. Football, but shakhtar had to be prepared from scratch, taking into account that we have an offseason, i mean in the ukrainian championship, that is , winter, and we understood that pushich does not have these skills, so it was still an adventure to put pusichcha in particular and precisely in the middle of the season, that is why we understand that now these problems that we see now at the start of this calendar year, they can actually be said further, that this tendency can even become decisive in the fight for the championship, and for a miner only a champion. Will exist considering what advantage the miner now has in almost all components . Well, from such decisions, which surprised a lot, besides the fact that the unprepared team was physically there, what about the substitutions there after the 81st minute, well, five the substitute just released the players at the same time, why didnt he do something there earlier to remove someone, because we saw that the same Taras Stepanenko already had a very hard time for him after the 60th minute, well, in fact , for Taras Stepanenko, i think that to a large extent can not. To play , if it were not for such a shortage, of this particular performer, in this position, i think that taras would skip this match, so that there would be more or less an alternative for the donetsk miner, but miner we see that again, many acquisitions, acquisitions in the attack, the brazilians, that that shakhtar once used, which more or less bore fruit, now they are also determined to, well , buy these promising brazilians again, instead of just making accents. Maybe there are others, not that philosophy, another vector of football development, specifically the donetsk club, maybe it is worth thinking about the center of the field, because we have already talked about the fact that there is no alternative to taras stepenko in the season, there earlier there was maksym malyshev, but he finished his career as a Football Player a long time ago currently works in the youth team of the donetsk miner, so there is no such direct alternative to stepanenkos replacement, and we understand that the selection and scouting services seem to be working there 24 7, but still. Nothing was done, nothing was done, despite the fact that the miner has a huge budget, including acquisitions , well, the budget can be even bigger if they sell giorgi sodakov, how much is it for 150, maybe more, and giorgi agreed after the game with marseille, which they lost 3 1, well to answer some questions, analyzed the game, which failed, well and of course noted the key factors of this match, we can say that we made a good achievement, we left a rather difficult group in the europa league. And until the last moment we still had a chance to advance to the 1 8 league of europe. After conceding the first ball, when they equalized, we stopped playing our football, many simple mistakes were made, and probably mentally we were not able to readjust to the game and take it under our control, so at such a level mistakes are not. Not forgiven, and very difficult to play with by such teams, just when they, when still 70 thousand are chasing them, thats why i can probably congratulate marseille, a welldeserved victory, the goals remain the same, this is the championship of ukraine, a victory in the championship and a victory in the cup, well , yes, we know that became a velodrome it is a fan that always passes there, but i was surprised that the stadium was almost full with those unsuccessful results of marseille and. This factor, well, maybe it was the key for many young shakhtar players, well , marseille actually has loyal fans, i think , what after all, the key factor was the change of the coach, because. Gatouz was literally hated by almost all the Football Players of marseille, they understood that he was not the coach they needed, and we see that immediately marseille changed with the arrival of a new coach, and we see that he wins the third victory in a row, but the day before marseille won again very easily in the french championship, that is , there the substitution brought fruit for shakhtar, we see that at first it was emotional, maybe so , and a lot at once, well, we immediately remember which they picked up, well, lets say this, the control shakhtaryuzmi, who picked up that the super coach, the super vision, that shakhtar will finally be the strongest in history and so on, these messages went, which somehow look artificial, as for me, who have been cheering there since childhood, rudely speaking for shakhtar, so when they tell such things, well , it even makes me laugh somewhere, well, we will move on, today there will be a kryvbasshakhtar match, we will announce it in the next part of the program, and now i want to move on to the fact that the competitor, the eternal competitor of the miner dynamo kyiv, all players dynamo say what they perceive. Championship, well, in principle, they believe that shakhtar is the main competitor, the others are polissya, kryvbas, dnipro1, not so, and we confirm dynamo with shevkovsky in the next round, well, we guessed, because this series is already six matches in a row, oleksandr shovkovskii , who leads