delux jenina clubs, if you would, is our goal. you relieved with a unilateral division of russia to invade ukraine and aggressive he possible to ensure this wall concludes as soon as possible to do everything to ensure gentlemen of ukraine will survive. russia will never win, preserve peace on the rest of the continent of europe, and avoid any escalation to suggest when far for this war to come to an end. we've adopted unprecedented sanctions. won't cover you ab ramos to not make it difficult, but again, always to finance the war in russia to support the ukraine of we've mobilized military financial humanitarian resources like never before. and we need to step these efforts up here to ensure we have an effective response when it comes to food security. and we will continue to spot this newly so that just less can speak. we will fight again by the pricing at the impunity for the crime of said have been committed in ukraine. whatever's we are not though. hello, miss russia. we are fighting in europe to maintain the sovereignty and territorial its integrity of ukraine for the return of peace to our continent, telephone, and it's up to ukraine, only, only legal to decide on negotiating conditions with rational code of our duty. that is a good our duty is to be by ukraine sides to obtain a ceasefire and then peace. so, and then we will be around when it comes to rebuilding ukraine. as part of europe always dance are gone. a 1000000000 also because when the piece returns to european soil, clearly we will have to build new security balances. duvall and our son together. no german severely don't us. we must never given me to the official. the temptation all the doors off to humiliation or a desire for revenge because we learn how much that has ravaged as owed to peace in the past. they do say this, we're so in the name of this freedom, an august of this hope so. so 1st it will younger booking at we have your address it this task this, it will everclear unparalleled law of your new brother, democracy that you have undertaken. and he bought it in your own words. good hovel, who's ad you've all contributed to this work, which is now an obligation for us. so as you say is what we have today is not the en route to me. is a kind of the semi colon it. so is a pause. i put it on to the commissioner in this process, which we will take forward. your janet hours through the president of the open commission has promised to attentively steady each and every one of your proposals . and i would like to thank the lord and we have another meeting together in september. as you have heard the, the president, you can say to the new one on behalf of the president of the counselor at the mercy european union. and not as reporting the french president, italy, i promised that this will not be a mere formality bush. this libya will be a process on which i am. how is it will sure would like to add a strong or concrete proposal and that will benefit little people of europe. that like is this conference must not stop here. maguvvin, you would not be. i repeat and convince milwaukee or not he le gift cannot lavender conviction, as is reinforced by all this rounding circumstance with my conviction is that chrisy should not turn is away from our agenda. many of your proposals out can be an adopted without institutional reform, but they remind us of the importance of agenda to protect us from climate by diversity of health and low quality of our food is a fair and more inclusive europe legality. the europe of equality between men and when are they, the more europe formal, able to defend, it was only been ordered if a view of the solidarity that the defense is of values. every way to do many very concrete republicans honestly by you and we wish to ensure that we draw all the necessary conclusions from this in our future meetings at the council. and i was giving myself to that there are also able to add demands with address. in particular, one easily foresee the interest only to building up the leash and effectiveness of europe without which our democracy cannot be legitimate. so those are bad. and so these little so good imperative are the lessons that we draw collectively from the crises that we have just been through that we are still going through independence and fresh look. nathan, also be a lot here, appear in independence and sovereignty. this is what donna, you to soft get covered through the pre daughter destiny, that hops the horses. these are the only of them in all of the crisis that we have been through. a cabella euro has been putting itself together to citizen, others and weakens of all he asada, vic, the president, the president napoleon are reminded by your proposals after your gender set out so that people don't stop by our european leaders of a strategic independence. the left cy, agenda on the old financial crisis. we went through 10 years ago. the pandemic or the in ukraine show our weaknesses are a civic, this is for and j bond availability mcgee, the lack of the ability to respond just quickly analysis on the star. so a, europe, fish was most of its own destiny and free in its choices over the world. we want to be a problem, but not to be dependent. so we need to remain open without being dependent on others. that should you pause you is a condition for continuing our european project and our democracy, madison, it goes on this x correspond you had outlined some awfully avenues velocity would follow the manipulator at the areas which would have to work for the next week or month when it comes to defense to, to invent or to get them. all right, enter fi ok. abilities. little and really a little develop with industrial sectors that we need to have him, your port prepare for our potential future areas of conflict it see in the area in space field in your world, been the fuss, at least to protect and malice, those countries on the border of the european union who are faced with, with a new challenge with a new threat which has transformed as available. we'll see, this is our duty and the get a little nazi. all the you on it are saying today will become a dead letter. if in the next few weeks and months, we are not able to render our, your capacity, credible, or other capacity, our ability to defend ourselves, macklefresh oriented in particular on our i'm at eastern frank will advantage of it more quickly when it comes to the environment. you frankly said it was the only have to move out of fossil fuel. in fact, the war it requires a lot of us as well. this actually feeds our climate agenda. he met what else the need to be an independent and 2 at yahoo. fresh faces responsibilities did not all ukraine and the desire to earth can before i get out of i dependency on russian fossil fuel. when we leave this, we to move on further and faster on climate change really to invest in their nuclear energy. renewable energy is we need to be energy efficient to do that. facility now uses all of the clean air health on the old bit. your printer to the face, the hike in prices. he saw gluten need to come in and out of an environmental power without the gold of achieving carbon, eternal tonic, vanessa, and also we have to only regain our food air sovereignty. vio destabilized by the war in ukraine. roy reno's food supply chain to disrupt it. so we have to ensure that we have the capacity to produce enough food to defend our own of food security in food 17. but we also need to define him re evaluated strategies. i be the rest of the world. if we want to avoid famine and geopolitical instability on our borders and inter tragedy throughout the year, the bit throughout the mediterranean base base and that is our duty as your opinions on golf demo cut and also democrat augmented panel was us. yeah. information independence. this is something that you stressful, rightly in the position of forwarding, you have some viable began to show us what we really are, where you, which is the more about the citizens and democratic power. and this is something that makes us unique in the world. the citizens power is something that we have lately to keep alive, defending the freedom and integrity issue of the information. what is exchanged in our territory also on our soil defending the integrity of our democratic processes . and defending throughout european territory, democracy and the rule of law. this is what we realize. so all the more from the heroic combined val, ukrainian, frances, how social us be carries, or timothy is that is or, and freedom is. so we have to rebuild these through, you know, time did more dalton. okay, i'd be independent in sovereignty, but not for libya. de, preconditions of our freedom does him gossamer analytics to surrender. the next main point i want to stress is the need for effective us. the ability to respond to crises with strength, alpha, and speed onto the mac, and do this decisively as democracies. do remember, just 2 years ago got unknown just a year ago. then bought a thought on was what we're hearing. you know, 6, pretty excited january company pre so, so dory deaf boy, mama, we had some people saying that they might be better if we were an author italian power in order to respond to the pan dellinger's it the chinese russians are going to be had to impose vaccination really, but why did the silly oh paul societies, democratic exit transparent, global wellness process. hillsboro, oregon turner up in our national parliaments and in the european parliament just that european engagement in that context was able to become a healthy power without self executed. if treaties with it, without a texas her guiding the way we were able to build a resume for has a unique her novel response in face of the panorama area. finding together as i saw it, democracy and effectiveness. a polish one of her sort of excel or does not managing to produce a vaccine on our soil, becoming a seal. shut me biggest vaccine now manufacturing air says it's sort of out of the wild, big spot off a while of painting at borders electronically exporting. and showing vaccine solidarity, that's what your appears let is the little bit michigan prouder a urico democracy called open and free science land of effectiveness. these things go to get all who do forgotten readers for me. so this is the choice that we have to do on your continue. and if i don't back over the last 15 years i selected economic you faced with the economics financial crisis. we were too slow to respond, legless portugal to many others increase. we suffered the consequences, some of them we were divided that we wanted were relapsed in on national responsibilities. so we didn't come up with a collective response and media library did not, but didn't i personally, we weren't working together to cope with crisis if we had imported from across the atlantic from us for me. what the very things, but the response of the european central bank with the famous saying whatever it takes you get it all merged on, also bomb our, you'd argue those words pronounced by marrow dragon, whatever it takes. and in the face of the pandemic. and now in the face of war, we have shown that we can be different dipoles gimme a legacy. confronted with append, unable to handle the with unique decision horn, in june 2020, to greater in your budget, a borrower response, and a novel response for europe. borrowing money on the financial market in order to invest in priorities and in the face of war. for the 1st time, we decided to mobilize ethier police facility to help defend itself and to fight in a way that we have never done before. so let us be proud of these choices that we have taken to be effectively without which in a value we wouldn't be here to day. if you don't get a consult, disgustingly together. so this strength with a representative. yes, i think around her clothes with no busy you know, busy, so weekly, challenging faces with is to be on thought, just as effective. so please in kind of get lucy and without a crisis, dakota. so we have to decide quickly as our films to get those all off investing mclee or songs or in the right things, not leaving any one behind. that is what it is to be european. so you for lot, for faced with this. we also have to reform, i will text you over to our model that is clear and it was and forced to say to day that one of villa over the avenues for history, for in order for you to convene a convention to revise the future surgeon, it will be your you bet law a, b is a proposal by the european parliament and i approve it. he said rob, i am in favor of this other yeoman. no, it would mean that we would have to work hard on the basis of all your work and all your proposal is to define clearly what our executives are because you have to your spot on the start of convention, a constitutional but you convention to know where you're going before the earl of frog money i gather. so you, if it was a very strong remit, ester show a strong framework, the more policy it on. very push and from it. so was on the, in the coming weeks with her lab, we were, can drill or see you like repair the ground seeker different agreement on all sides . i am in favor of is institutional reform. your that i wanted a little, i would like us to be able to discuss this with the necessary and carriage at the next european council. sushi hebrews, all that will seriously disability will mean making progress to that at the other. so making a filter filter revolt and then moving forward, dont making more use of qualified majority voting are for our main nurse public policy. we look like continued he but me should also continue to lately program little brucely and to define ways of showing more solidarity, terrifying our aims and objectives and objectives for all our institutional setting objectives that will help us to keep your up together and also growth for employment, a climate objective assault on those as you saw a place where they both. yeah. this any out rules by designed tentacles of this and were based on re objectives, which now need to be a supplemental in the face of the air history challenges that we face for now for the employment, a lender cottage grove, cabin neutrality, objective disposition, social justice to of little girl, these objectives must be at the heart of the aims of our institution. oh, fun. they thought me it will not. yes it did them all. finally of you, it's opening up live. okay. plenty of these for these reforms. they're also the mac nines, the providing legitimacy to democratic control that the committee deepening this unprecedented democratic adventure and continue these democratic innovations to cover as we have done with them that through your work, i'd like to get you to the thank and i got the president and asked for having already taken a clear commitment to that and just a few moments ago. but we no longer to go further. now like the dizziness are election, law rules are rules to appoint our representatives are monitoring rules for our rights of initiative for the right village to 3 european parliament. all of that should be at the heart of this future convention. look what they possibly mom. i firmly believe my voice. what is it that we can undertake this, this work? and i think we can be affected to says objective. i think he couldn't do that. so sure of you're sticking to these of environmental economics, myself and other goals mean that we will be effective and this will be a way of keeping our europe together. because without these objectives, it will no longer be able to persuade them are citizens. that all the european union protects them and enables us to move full little. now obviously not everyone will necessarily solace, agree, but we shouldn't worry about differences. you please have always been fertile for the european union, and they exist have never been excluded or a part of what we do and they exist on the euro, shang, and etc. but i've been struck in the tension on recent years, something on the count as to how the will to stick together. b, one as a union of 27 means that we know from you forward and stick together membership. the thing on the law we, the heads of state and government office, for example, never managed to meet such as the euro group. it's still, you know, we are the only co owners who can't meet as kind of a building. we have to invite the whole stretching. we're worried about being more ambitious. it's always the same thing from the euro to shannon. and we are wrong on that, said the colonel. god next creeper, these epitome, this group, pregnancy doesn't exclude any one of the what it does is enabled a lot of those who want to learn faster to bring the others with them in their slipstream. really ski. rather than make came filling some kid yell risk on and holding back to the shop. i know that there are concerns. what if it was on the, when it comes to differing speeds, but they already exist. we need to converge them. we shouldn't be excluding disease, but we also, the daphne shouldn't let the skeptics and those who are most hesitant hold us back when he to ensure that you can a furnace. so as a power. and this differentiation open to all of us, which is faithful to our history body and body ambitions launched by our founding fathers, by jack the law for europe are important, and this is a condition for us to be ambitious and affected. although both union is uniquely he de hoping to conclude until lucas fixed is let me go back and say i to it a context and i wanted, i know that my proposals wouldn't be complete if i didn't respond to this point that emerged from your proposals. now the war in your korean was one and the legitimate your spirit aspirations in the crane c, r like those of georgia and lol. dover who want to also want to join the european union. mean, we have to rethink them in our geography and the organization of our continent. and so like i care for the vic here of all work that gives you mix with the same sincerity that you've conducted your work. i want to say that sunken bar is ukraine because of its struggle. no, cuz it's currency is more ready to go. the not so hot the not for me a member of your, of our family. i me, mims, soon we are god your the moon is that you did good even if we will give it to give it the status of candidate country that you will to morrow let is you, i hope when refuel towards accession rapidly, you sell to us. but perfect, even if we were to do that, we all know, look only to, well me don't let is it the pro process shells for accession would take it several years the years. in truth, it would probably take several decade cheaper. did you and that so that's good. this is your, is the true subsidiary contact. unless we don't, we decide to lower the standards for succession, 40 and rethink the unity of all europe. and this also partially the principles that we hold. so you're good. let's be clear up in the european union evil. don't think i'll so he'd given it's level of integration and ambition them cannot tell you in the short term. no. oh, the only way in which the european continent can be structured, the better going see don't, don't get several countries. for example, the western europe. it's all kinds who are involved in gauged me, accession process focus and that needs to continue. their vocation is clear, quickly, almost, but we obviously festival context as you're pretty t also need given the new geopolitical context left well to find help, a way to see ability ah, your little to ensure that it's unified and stifle a better without under nathaniel making the intimacy within the european union, more fragile to leak. we have a historic 2nd one, a duty here, not to do things that the way that we've always done and to say the only response is obsession and fictional is to look at that. we need to do that mocking of some is open up a historic and process of reflection given the events that are currently locked, taking place on the construction of our continent community. i don't need thought of. ah, family who can say is always one of common values. it's been abandoned by russia. we only begin melody. stella. we are being shaken by the tides of history. a clever enough liquidity. don't fail. 1989 president francois mitchell. i don't, couldn't. you also get dick said the thing i'll poke said because she wanted gladly . the 3 year old soviet union was falling apart at top with his showing that he wanted to see a confederation of european states. us businesses was perhaps to release precocious . either he been in it including russia, and this next it confederation, which rapidly was sinister, unacceptable. the 4 states, so who had just escaped the soviet yoke is joyce. it but told them it raged, could not get an interesting question which remained. how should we organize europe in a political money issue is to leak, could you a point also, and how can we go further than the european union? it's our historic obligation now to respond to that question which will be dissolved i think i would here today would qualify me what i'm talking about as a european political new community. i mean, this will european organization will enable democratic and not europe here to the low nations who's here to our valid is 1st book to find a new space for political cooperation because of his security analogy for energy, cooperation, and transport, cooperation addressed in infrastructure where people notice president macros speaking out the european of parliament in a strasburg lay aren't quite ambitious plans. he talked about ukraine, talked about european defense at treaty change, the european, the euro group on a and this, this phrase that the, to speak to europe and also a hunting. there are a european expansion with sort of different classes of membership as it were. let's get a brief analysis of this from barbara vessel who is there? what jumped out at you, barbara. this is the reason that some french people during the last selection said they hated the monro mcclung. he knows everything and knows it better. and once you start speaking, you will never end. that is the problem with him. so exhaustively, he set out everything that we need to know and think about the european union at the moment. more sovereignty, more independence thinks that he has demanded from the very beginning of his 1st time in office. but then he also came, as you mentioned, phil of course is to defense and he came to the structural problems of the european union. add this to speed. europe is an old idea that has been talked about for around 20 years and it sort of came and went in and out of fashion. and now he picks it up again saying that probably in order to reorganize the european map in the future, we had need to have a different structure. so, you know, countries like georgia and ukraine mold over and others could sort of be in a 2nd. rang of european countries have a lot of the advantages, but not all of the rights. it is a huge box of problems and ideas and possibilities that emmanuel mac wrong has been opening here. it's going to take everyone in brussels and instruct for quite a while to deal with this. all right, what he's got to 5 years that say, how much sir, how far you get for now? a thank you so much. barbara basil, at the european parliament in strasburg joined now by for brea said. j. as a former nato director of policy planning is now chief executive officer, political consultancy rasmussen, global welcome to the w talk. and so that the top idea that better sprung out at you today from either emmanuel macro or from the european commission president. i think essentially this is what your correspondent was to say. my coin in fact is coming back with the regional idea of multi speed europe. and i would say this is the one biggest he wants to set for himself for the next 5 years. he's not just saying, i think new policy to the european union is reshaping the very geometry of the european union with this multi century union. and he, i believe you formulated that 5 years ago when he was running for president the 1st side. and clearly he's sick now to try to achieve that. let's see if it works. and how could he do that? there was so many things in these, these, the speeches that you just, i mean, even the idea of getting rid of unanimity, this qualified majority voting. i'm presuming you would need a, you'd never see to get that through. well, that's been the problem indeed. but there might be a new momentum around the need to have a qualify. majority voting, at least in some new areas. so i guess somebody speaks of the conference of the future of europe, which clearly are probably going to become new policies. but fundamentally what my course focusing here is interesting but challenging in the sense that he's not suggesting to expand your opinion. and he's just suggesting to have different kind of centers we call the your zone with the heads of state who should be able to meet to discuss your your current c matters. and then the kind of outer center we've the partners like joe g, ukraine who we'd be proud with some of the key policies of the union, but will not be full fledged membership. ok, good talk to you. thank you so much for joining us for being a from other rasmussen global i sent you up. today's will have more. well, here's at the top of the hour and around the clock, of course on the at the d. w article on the website, d, w dot. i've got a in modern life, we're always on the move, whether they're getting around or shipping goods across the modes of transportation are convenient, but they're damaging the environment. how can we make mobility more sustainable? that's what we've talk about today. hello and welcome to eco, india. i'm some of that rick shows have been around.