to play by those rules i mean if only because. if punitive tariffs on tiles is also a protectionist measure but it keeps people in jobs in germany and helps push for better production and environmental standards. your bird seed you know if we produce here in germany we're expected to comply with laws that are relevant in germany and we did so we exercise control over things like environmental aspects of course we don't have that for products coming from abroad to home and then there's the issue of white versus value he says because it really makes sense to transport these products of assumption long distances. without punitive tariffs european tile makers wouldn't hold out long under the pressure exerted by their chinese counterparts. if the e.u.