to be a loss but i do think it shows like i said there is a split among the party and i think that the split shows a split in the population in general and to what extent the s.p.d. can negotiate this i think that is a very much open question christopher newman thank you so much for joining us thank you for. this d.w. news live from berlin still to come commemorating the world war two bombing of dresden tens of thousands lost their lives in the allied attacks seventy three years ago five dollars about its residents today. here in germany a radical solution is on the table to cut down on air pollution and humphrey house will be talking about free public transport feel doesn't sound terribly bad does it all in favor yeah let's see about that but anyway the german government is touting the ideas for an idea at the moment in a beta to get people to leave their cars home perhaps hop on a trade