so how did this police report from 1985 come to light? >> it came to light through a freedom of information request here at the police department by some people who were inquiring as to a gentleman that i believe i heard you mention earlier, who had been arrested, that they felt mr. kavanaugh may have been with that night. >> yeah. his name is chad ludington. let's listen to him. this is how he described the incident to chris just last hour. watch. >> brett took umbrage at this and threw his beer at the guy. i actually now found out from the report that it wasn't beer. that i had misremembered. brett said [ bleep ] or something to that effect and threw the ice at the guy. and the guy understandably, even though he had been aggressive in his response, found that was a little one step too far.