guess with this kind of majority, evenif guess with this kind of majority, even if some of those who abstained on the second reading, might want to vote against the programme motion, probably the government is still going to survive. in the end, a better day for mr sunak than perhaps some were anticipating. as in truth, often ends up being the case in these occasions, that being said, these occasions, that being said, the government will have used up quite a lot of political capital getting this result and they will be arguments down the track about some of the detail of this bill. let’s of the detail of this bill. let's take a look — of the detail of this bill. let's take a look at _ of the detail of this bill. let's take a look at some - of the detail of this bill. let's take a look at some of - of the detail of this bill. let's take a look at some of the i of the detail of this bill. let's i take a look at some of the legal arguments down the track. we can speak to an immigration lawyer. just your immediate reaction to what has just happened and what are the potential legal battles ahead now. we still have a fair bit to go and the legal— we still have a fair bit to go and the legal battles will be in the house — the legal battles will be in the house of lords potentially, knocking in that _ house of lords potentially, knocking in that and _ house of lords potentially, knocking in that and saying they will have to amend _ in that and saying they will have to amend courses in there. that will be the biggest — amend courses in there. that will be the biggest challenge, trying to get it through there and we have seen time _ it through there and we have seen time and — it through there and we have seen time and time again that the house of lords_ time and time again that the house of lords can — time and time again that the house of lords can push bills back and get them _ of lords can push bills back and get them amended. the nature of the bill changes— them amended. the nature of the bill changes but it is a better day for rishi _ changes but it is a better day for rishi sunak than what was touted. the rebels — rishi sunak than what was touted. the rebels sort of fizzled out at the end — the rebels sort of fizzled out at the end despite saying they had great _ the end despite saying they had great numbers. didn't look like it in the _ great numbers. didn't look like it in the vote — great numbers. didn't look like it in the vote and it looks like the party— in the vote and it looks like the party has — in the vote and it looks like the party has backed rishi sunak and back the — party has backed rishi sunak and back the general policy, because if it didn't _ back the general policy, because if it didn't come it would have been a calamity— it didn't come it would have been a calamity considering they are all in agreement with the policy going through— agreement with the policy going through and yet the vote would have .one through and yet the vote would have gone against it. the party has spoken. — gone against it. the party has spoken, the conservative party, that this is— spoken, the conservative party, that this is what— spoken, the conservative party, that this is what they want, albeit there is some _ this is what they want, albeit there is some descent. legally there is still a _ is some descent. legally there is still a long — is some descent. legally there is still a long way to go and especially from the people who think actually— especially from the people who think actually government shouldn't be allowed _ actually government shouldn't be allowed to ignore court decisions and should not be allowed to override _ and should not be allowed to override and change the facts as they are — override and change the facts as the are. ., , ., ., ., they are. lots of legal wrangling ahead. thank _ they are. lots of legal wrangling ahead. thank you _ they are. lots of legal wrangling ahead. thank you for _ they are. lots of legal wrangling ahead. thank you for that. - they are. lots of legal wrangling ahead. thank you for that. let's| they are. lots of legal wrangling . ahead. thank you for that. let's get political commentatorjoe phillips, your thoughts. i’m political commentatorjoe phillips, yourthoughts— political commentatorjoe phillips, your thoughts. i'm sure the premise the will your thoughts. i'm sure the premise they will have _ your thoughts. i'm sure the premise they will have a _ your thoughts. i'm sure the premise they will have a better _ your thoughts. i'm sure the premise they will have a better night - your thoughts. i'm sure the premise they will have a better night sleep i they will have a better night sleep and will have had had it gone the other way. yes, is not an 80 seat majority, it is half the actual majority, it is half the actual majority but in actual fact, it means this is the second time that he has seen off this noisy, attention seeking, headline grabbing grumps that have been around since the dinosaurs. we have had this before with the windsor framework about northern ireland and he managed to get that through. with the same sort of arguments and the same people shouting and wailing and saying they wouldn't support it. but may be common sense has prevailed because for the last couple of weeks, it has honestly looked as though the lunatics had taken over the asylum. the thought that there would be another leadership election or a snap general election on a country on its knees with an economy stagnating and all the other problem that we have got, so this is good news for him but asjohn and vicki young have said, he still has to get through the commons and through the lords. it's kicked into the long grass until the new year. yes, new ear will grass until the new year. yes, new year will be — grass until the new year. yes, new year will be interesting. _ grass until the new year. yes, new year will be interesting. thank- grass until the new year. yes, new year will be interesting. thank you | year will be interesting. thank you for that. we will go straight back to vicki young who is standing by with some immediate reaction. who with some immediate reaction. who have ou with some immediate reaction. who have you got — with some immediate reaction. mew have you got there? with some immediate reaction. hisurv have you got there? first let's have a reaction. a majority of 44 what do you make of it? a reaction. a ma'ority of 44 what do you make of in— a reaction. a ma'ority of 44 what do you make of it? ma'ority of 44 which was more than — you make of it? ma'ority of 44 which was more than i — you make of it? majority of 44 which was more than i was _ you make of it? majority of 44 which was more than i was expecting - you make of it? majority of 44 which was more than i was expecting so i you make of it? majority of 44 which l was more than i was expecting so and chuffed _ was more than i was expecting so and chuffed the _ was more than i was expecting so and chuffed the prime minister has got his second — chuffed the prime minister has got his second reading through. i'm pleased — his second reading through. i'm pleased we are heading in the right direction _ pleased we are heading in the right direction. it's part of a package of measures. — direction. it's part of a package of measures, is not stand—alone, we have _ measures, is not stand—alone, we have reduced the small boats crossing _ have reduced the small boats crossing by a third at a time when it is going — crossing by a third at a time when it is going up between the third and 100% _ it is going up between the third and 100% in _ it is going up between the third and 100% in the rest of europe but this movie _ 100% in the rest of europe but this movie carr— 100% in the rest of europe but this movie can do and rwanda is not the be all— movie can do and rwanda is not the be all and _ movie can do and rwanda is not the be all and end all but it's a valuable _ be all and end all but it's a valuable part of that, getting those small— valuable part of that, getting those small boats, stopping the illegal trade _ small boats, stopping the illegal trade in — small boats, stopping the illegal trade in small boats.— small boats, stopping the illegal trade in small boats. some of your colleagues — trade in small boats. some of your colleagues decided _ trade in small boats. some of your colleagues decided to _ trade in small boats. some of your colleagues decided to abstain - trade in small boats. some of your colleagues decided to abstain at i colleagues decided to abstain at this point, they said they didn't want to back the bill but they really took a step back from opposing it completely, but they are saying this to want changes. they want it to be more watertight legally, they want to stop appeals effectively for those who have been threatened with deportation. what would your measured speed to them? we had to row together and come together~ — we had to row together and come together~ i— we had to row together and come together. i mean most of those groups. — together. i mean most of those groups, some of my colleagues in those _ groups, some of my colleagues in those groups were abstain. you are getting _ those groups were abstain. you are getting into narrow legal definitions under what circumstances you are _ definitions under what circumstances you are allowed to appeal. if we can realistically— you are allowed to appeal. if we can realistically and within the law and ethics _ realistically and within the law and ethics ensure that the system cannot be gamed _ ethics ensure that the system cannot be gamed in the way that it has been very badly_ be gamed in the way that it has been very badly gamed, this is not about denying _ very badly gamed, this is not about denying justice, very badly gamed, this is not about denyingjustice, it's very badly gamed, this is not about denying justice, it's about preventing people and their lawyers from abusing a processes and the system _ from abusing a processes and the system. it's probably about giving those _ system. it's probably about giving those folks reassurance. i would like the — those folks reassurance. i would like the on — those folks reassurance. i would like the on the echr staff. would ou like like the on the echr staff. would you like to _ like the on the echr staff. would you like to leave _ like the on the echr staff. would you like to leave or _ like the on the echr staff. would you like to leave or stay - like the on the echr staff. would you like to leave or stay in? - like the on the echr staff. would you like to leave or stay in? i'm l you like to leave or stay in? i'm half german, _ you like to leave or stay in? i'm half german, my _ you like to leave or stay in? i'm half german, my mum came here as a refugee _ half german, my mum came here as a refugee after — half german, my mum came here as a refugee after her mother was killed lry refugee after her mother was killed by the _ refugee after her mother was killed by the soviets. 0ur rights in this country— by the soviets. 0ur rights in this country have little to do with the european — country have little to do with the european union and have everything to do— european union and have everything to do with _ european union and have everything to do with the magna carta, the glorious — to do with the magna carta, the glorious revolution, the bill of rights — glorious revolution, the bill of rights. 0ur glorious revolution, the bill of rights. our history is what gives us our rights — rights. our history is what gives us our rights so — rights. our history is what gives us our rights so i'm pretty relaxed about _ our rights so i'm pretty relaxed about echr but i respect one nation colleagues care about this and i care about keeping us as a big family. — care about keeping us as a big family. so— care about keeping us as a big family, so i want us to stay together~ _ family, so i want us to stay together. me personally, ithink we can have _ together. me personally, ithink we can have a — together. me personally, ithink we can have a tougher line on the echr and the _ can have a tougher line on the echr and the idea you can get some bulgarian— and the idea you can get some bulgarianjudge striking down the law is— bulgarianjudge striking down the law is made in a sovereign parliament, no. do law is made in a sovereign parliament, no.— law is made in a sovereign parliament, no. law is made in a sovereign oarliament, no. ,, , parliament, no. do you think it is oossible parliament, no. do you think it is possible to _ parliament, no. do you think it is possible to keep _ parliament, no. do you think it is possible to keep the _ parliament, no. do you think it is possible to keep the party - parliament, no. do you think it is l possible to keep the party together on this? i possible to keep the party together on this? ., , on this? i think things will get better. on this? i think things will get better- the — on this? i think things will get better. the more _ on this? i think things will get better. the more that - on this? i think things will get better. the more that we - on this? i think things will get better. the more that we get| on this? i think things will get - better. the more that we get this bill through, the more the labour party— bill through, the more the labour party will— bill through, the more the labour party will come under pressure. you listen _ party will come under pressure. you listen to— party will come under pressure. you listen to all— party will come under pressure. you listen to all the speeches from yvette — listen to all the speeches from yvette cooper onwards, it's alljust political— yvette cooper onwards, it's alljust political platitudes, political point — political platitudes, political point scoring, its attack, attack, attack~ — point scoring, its attack, attack, attack. they have no ideas, no clue and no _ attack. they have no ideas, no clue and no plan — attack. they have no ideas, no clue and no plan behind that so people can have — and no plan behind that so people can have a — and no plan behind that so people can have a choice next year when we have an _ can have a choice next year when we have an election, that we are delivering, trying to deliver and we are delivering on reducing those boats— are delivering on reducing those boats or— are delivering on reducing those boats or that the labour party who frankly— boats or that the labour party who frankly want to open the doors to illegal— frankly want to open the doors to illegal immigration and that is a clear— illegal immigration and that is a clear choice for the british people. there _ clear choice for the british people. there is— clear choice for the british people. there is a — clear choice for the british people. there is a slight problem that your colleagues are grabbing all the attention by fighting this and criticising the prime minister for the bill he has come up with. l’m the bill he has come up with. i'm even more _ the bill he has come up with. i'm even more grateful that you have me on. ., ~' even more grateful that you have me on. ., ,, y ., y even more grateful that you have me on. ., ~' , ., , . even more grateful that you have me on. ., ~' ,, , . ., on. thank you very much. there are many stages — on. thank you very much. there are many stages of _ on. thank you very much. there are many stages of this _ on. thank you very much. there are many stages of this bill— on. thank you very much. there are many stages of this bill still- on. thank you very much. there are many stages of this bill still to - many stages of this bill still to come and then of course, if, once it gets through the house of commons, it then has to go through the house of lords. ., ., it then has to go through the house of lords. ., ,, , ., , it then has to go through the house of lords. ., ~i , ., , . of lords. thank you. getting that immediate _ of lords. thank you. getting that immediate reaction _ of lords. thank you. getting that immediate reaction there. - of lords. thank you. getting that - immediate reaction there. absolutely invaluable. there we have it, rishi sunak lives to fight another day untiljanuary. a win, a voting success in the house of commons in the last 20 minutes or so. i really want to say thank you to all my gas tos who have given immediate reaction and context over the last few minutes, that is sirjohn kerr, my thanks. this is bbc news. rebecca slater. wake boarding. the following year her car skidded on black ice. l following year her car skidded on black ice. , ., ., ., black ice. i ended up with damage to the artery in — black ice. i ended up with damage to the artery in my _ black ice. i ended up with damage to the artery in my arm _ black ice. i ended up with damage to the artery in my arm that _ black ice. i ended up with damage to the artery in my arm that resulted i the artery in my arm that resulted in it being amputated and i had a severe fracture on my ankle. but the accident was — severe fracture on my ankle. but the accident was a _ severe fracture on my ankle. but the accident was a catalyst _ severe fracture on my ankle. but the accident was a catalyst that - severe fracture on my ankle. but the accident was a catalyst that turned . accident was a catalyst that turned rebecca into a world beater. she has competed across the world in strength events and has been awarded the title world strongest woman with a disability. l the title world strongest woman with a disabili . ., ., �* ., �* , a disability. i have won britain's stronaest a disability. i have won britain's strongest disabled _ a disability. i have won britain's strongest disabled woman - a disability. i have won britain's strongest disabled woman two l a disability. i have won britain's - strongest disabled woman two years running. an strongest disabled woman... running. an strongest disabled woman- - -_ running. an strongest disabled woman... , ., , woman... rebecca can live double her body weight- — woman... rebecca can live double her body weight- her— woman... rebecca can live double her body weight. her achievements - woman... rebecca can live double her body weight. her achievements have l body weight. her achievements have inspired her to set up a gym, specially adapted for people with disabilities. this is bbc news. israel says that two soldiers were killed during the operation which led to the bodies being discovered and additional soldiers injured. the discovery of the bodies comes as more images are coming out of the conflict. we received no footage from inside gaza. it shows a un school being blown up by israeli soldiers. take a look. as well as the fighting and combat, this is just one as well as the fighting and combat, this isjust one hospital. the world health organization has said that less than a third of the hospitals in gaza are still functioning. the head of the un agency for palestinian refugees has described the situation as "hell on earth". the un says aid distribution in much of gaza has largely stopped. earlier, i spoke with stephen o'brien, former un under secretary—general for humanitarian affairs and emergency relief coordinator. i asked what he thought of the un voting on a resolution for an immediate humanitarian ceasefire in gaza. i well remember when i was serving that, you know, it's clear that if you ask for a cease fire, the words in the resolution can only bind. and in any event, they're an exhortation. there's no enforceability, there's no power to make it happen. it's a sort of expression of world anger, of an opinion and direction and exhortation, as i say. but it is directed towards member states. there are 193 ful