TEARY GOODBYE Bachelorette Katie Thurston sobs eliminating Andrew Spencer but REGRETS choice & begs for him to stay- which he refuses Updated: 22:56 ET, Jul 19 2021 Invalid Date, BACHELORETTE Katie Thurston sobbed as she eliminated Andrew Spencer but later REGRETTED her choice and begged the fan-favorite to stay. Despite chasing down the 26-year-old through the hotel as he exited the show, Katie, 30, could not convince her suitor to stay after he admitted to feeling “displaced” by her dismissal. 5 5 Andrew Spencer cried as he was eliminated at the latest rose ceremony on tonight's episodeCredit: ABC After eliminating the footballer at the rose ceremony, Katie asked to walk him out.