pat finally decided to take matters into their own hands, appealing directly to the community for help. we made pretty much election-style signs that said, justice for heather, and we sold them. we just wanted to keep the word going. it was like, if they re not gonna do it, we re gonna do it. then something happened that no one expected. there had been an arrest. only it wasn t of heather s killer. it was of the sheriff himself. i was actually dumbfounded at first. sheriff kyle overmyer was caught stealing prescription pain pills held in county custody. your sheriff had a drug problem. he did. and he was supporting his habit by pilfering money from a county fund. sheriff overmyer eventually pleaded guilty and was sentenced to four years in prison. to jen, it was yet another indication of a sheriff s office in disarray. it all made sense of why we weren t getting any answers. that turned out to be just the beginning. soon, detective