homes to pay for care under these plans, and there are three important points. i have already taken intervention from the minister. 0k, intervention from the minister. ok, i will take an intervention from the minister if he explains how you pay. i will take the intervention. i will take the intervention. i will take the intervention on the basis that he answers the question from myself and my right honourable friend the memberfrom my right honourable friend the member from the my right honourable friend the memberfrom the run my right honourable friend the member from the run there, my right honourable friend the memberfrom the run there, if my right honourable friend the member from the run there, if you can answer the question, how on earth do you pay when your house is worth less? let s have the answer! i am surprised that the honourable lady recognise the point i made about lady recognise the point i made about geographic impact that i made, but the about geographic impact that
but not in mansfield, not in middlesbrough, not in south ribble or thirsk either! 95%, middlesbrough, not in south ribble orthirsk either! 95%, 95% middlesbrough, not in south ribble or thirsk either! 95%, 95% of the revenue that the government plans to raise from this tax bombshell comes from employment. what a contrast. let me just make this point. what a contrast. yesterday, amazon reported an additional £1.9 billion worth of sales, but they are only paying £3.8 million more in corporation tax. yet with the changes announced yesterday, a graduate on a typical entry level salary will now pay a marginal tax rate of almost 50%, and not a word from the chancellor or his ministers about any of this. politics is about choices, and there are other ways to raise this money. the chancellor once the country to believe that this. sales on property, on financial assets like stocks and shares, there are no
resolution foundation has described the change is generationally unfair. pauljohnson has said is remains the case that pensioners will pay nothing for this package, overwhelmingly to be paid by working age people. there are many ways this could have been made progressive. 0ne could have been made progressive. one of the ways is to look at the 0ne of the ways is to look at the upper one of the ways is to look at the upper threshold for national insurance, but which has not been addressed insurance, but which has not been addressed by this, and it now means that the addressed by this, and it now means that the young graduates will have a marginal that the young graduates will have a marginal tax rate higher than a rich conservative earning on the benches across conservative earning on the benches across the conservative earning on the benches across the way. an excellent point. and for young people who have struggled this year, her going out is the world of work, this is a real
second, that everything in scotland is perfect, but we are making good progress and we intend to make more. the social care funding announced by the government may amount on the end to as little as 20% raised by this tax hike, not even for a few years. the british association of social workers have said this raises more questions than answers, and they feel they need something for services right now. not at some point in the future. early analysis demonstrates the sheen is orally coming off this policy. in contrast, the snp has used its time in government to introduce health and social care integration, self directed support, and the carers act, we have a self and social care partnerships on the ground working way to deliver more integrated services to our constituents, free personal care has been available in scotland for adults aged 65 and over since 2002, extended in 2019 to people of all ages who require it. the scottish government s programme for government s programme for governm
taxation taxation, and if you look at taxation and the amounts involved here. taxation and the amounts involved here. there taxation and the amounts involved here, there are only three taxes that you here, there are only three taxes that you could look at. about two thirds that you could look at. about two thirds of that you could look at. about two thirds of all tax is raised through inconie thirds of all tax is raised through income tax, national insurance and vat. income tax, national insurance and vat. and income tax, national insurance and vat, and then you ask yourself what criteria vat, and then you ask yourself what criteria we vat, and then you ask yourself what criteria we are going to apply to the tax criteria we are going to apply to the tax measures to test whether they are the tax measures to test whether they are the right ones or not. i say there they are the right ones or not. i say there are two, one being that we should say there are two,