from over 10.5 to under 7.5%. much of that is the auto rescue. much of that as joe and others were talking on the show is the discussion of exports and attention to manufacturing and spa raising the loan limits for small manufacturing companies and we ve seen trade enforcement create jobs. there s a new steel mill in youngstown that wouldn t have been there if we hadn t enforced the tubular steel rules. we re seeing more tire jobs in finley, more steel jobs in lorraine and cleveland so all of that comes together in a way that makes people a good bit more optimistic but still anxious. there s a long discourse among progressives in every election about the white working class. we ve lost the white working class to the democrats. i thought this chart from i believe public religion and