Case has become a homicide . Correct. That solved one mystery but caused another. Why would anyone want to kill him . Maybe it some h something to maybe it had something to do with a woman in his life . Hed broken off his engagement with one. I just found out those this morning. Now im a suspect. And there was somebody else. I was lonely. Just needed someone to talk to. Reporter did it also get a little steamy, mary . Yes. Passion and a secret that the wrong person discovered. Her face looked like shed seen a ghost. She said sheriff stay with me. You have a phone call i think you need to take. Im lester holt. This is dateline. Heres dennis murphy. Narrator winter comes every and will stays late in far western new york. The farmpoland tilled by amish farmlands tilled by amish and dutch families are encased in ice and snow for months at a time. In this place of frozen stillness, the hottest of passions boiling jealousy came to call one day. Tiny climber, 1,700 residents in the southwest
Case has become a homicide . Correct. That solved one mystery but caused another. Why would anyone want to kill him . Maybe it some h something to maybe it had something to do with a woman in his life . Hed broken off his engagement with one. I just found out those this morning. Now im a suspect. And there was somebody else. I was lonely. Just needed someone to talk to. Reporter did it also get a little steamy, mary . Yes. Passion and a secret that the wrong person discovered. Her face looked like shed seen a ghost. She said sheriff stay with me. You have a phone call i think you need to take. Im lester holt. This is dateline. Heres dennis murphy. Narrator winter comes every and will stays late in far western new york. The farmpoland tilled by amish farmlands tilled by amish and dutch families are encased in ice and snow for months at a time. In this place of frozen stillness, the hottest of passions boiling jealousy came to call one day. Tiny climber, 1,700 residents in the southwest
His three girls. Caitlyn was a star volleyball player and allamerican, and knew without a doubt when her father was in the stands on game days. You could hear him . I could. Yeah. Everyone could. Reporter her dad was in a longterm relationship with a single mom named kimberly roush. He had three daughters, and his two boys. And a lot of our time was spent being involved in their sporting events. Reporter theyd been on againoff again for years. But no sooner had they decided to take one of their periodic romantic timeouts from one another then theyd rubberband back together. Boyfriends like keith are hard to find. Saw him, pull the car over take me out of the car and dance alongside of the road. Being with him was amazing. Reporter now that his girls were grown, keith reed of at long last finding his special place, getting comfortable. He bought a big house in town. A sign that the superintendent wasnt just using clymer as a career stepping stone. He found where he wanted to be finally
Him . Maybe it had something to do with a woman in his life. Hed broken off his engagement with one. Now i feel like im a suspect. And there was somebody else nobody knew about. I was lonely. Just needed someone to talk to. Did you also get a little steamy . Yes. Passion, and a secret that the wrong person discovered. Her face looked like shed seen a ghost. And she said sheriff, you have a phone call i think you need to take. Im lester holt, and this is dateline. Heres dennis murphy. Winter comes early and stays late in far western new york. The farmlands near cha tau what lake. And in this place of frozen stillness, the place of hottest passions and jealousy came to call. And 1700 residents are still shaking at the shock of it all. Joe is the longtime sheriff. My 35 years in Law Enforcement. Can you ever remember a homicide in climber . Never. It began quite simply. The new superintendent in school went missing in 2012. Keith reid, 51 years old, was a longtime educator who landed in t