the original challenge on this case. we were actually at the original challenge. liberty university and private individuals, liberty council filed the suit back in march of 2010. we were the very first private lawsuit in the country. i argued at the district court and the federal court of appeals. and in 2011 the court of appeals didn t address our merits of the case. they ruled that the anti-injunction act prohibited them from getting to the merits bee asked the supreme court to review that mountains and liberty s case was the very first day of the three days of oral argument on the anti-injunction. when the court ultimately made its ruling it ruled in our favor and that s where we are now, breathing new life into this case, having the rehearing, directing the court of appeals to now address our issues. if the court thought that there was no merit in our issues, or if they simply did not want to be bothered by obama care again they do have easily denied our petition for rehearing, b