should do lightly but we had enough concerns to suggest it should be retracted, yes. was that unanimous among the panel? yes. fist that unanimous among the panel? yes. , ., yes. at this point it would typically yes. at this point it would typically be yes. at this point it would typically be left yes. at this point it would typically be left to - yes. at this point it would typically be left to editors| yes. at this point it would i typically be left to editors to decide what action to take. that is not what happened. the ro al that is not what happened. the royal college that is not what happened. iia: royal college of that is not what happened. tia: royal college of psychiatrists, the owners of the journal, just said that they were not prepared for that to happen. which, ithink, was prepared for that to happen. which, i think, was concerning because usually you would have expected that to be an editorial decision. so at that point those of us on the panel who had been part