Shadowy have jim harper and michael cannon director of Health Policy studies. Then we have Research Fellow at the center for constitutional studies, trevor and fellow Research Fellow air in paul i am also a Research Fellow and i will be moderating the debate tonight. One first of all nothing that you hear is an endorsement of any particular candidate if we do not take sides one and that is not the mission so we will do our best to avoid that the pet is not what we are trying to tell you first nadarizing minute Opening Statement from each side then there are 10 minutes of moderator questions that i asked in alternating order. Then 10 minutes of questions from the audience and then as the questions not speeches and follow that five minute closing statements from each side. Hopefully we will not run to far off of type but we will do the best that we can. So now i shall turn it over to the affirmative side. Thanks to the colleagues to participating today and dont those of you watching at h
argument on the case involving cory maples. alabama state attorneys then borrowed barred him from appeal because of he defaulted. the supreme court is expected to render a decision before the end of the term lynching. this is about one hour. thank you, mr. chief justice. may it please the court. two factors distinguish this case. first, the state itself had a direct hand in the extraordinary events leading up to the default in this case. a second, the actions of maple s attorneys are not attributable to maples that this court has invoked in determining when conduct can be with a client. it the default at issue in this case is not fairly attributable to cory maples. the decision of the 11th circuit should be reversed. putting that to one side, what if only one of the three notices have been returned it? i think if only one from the of state pro bono council, i think that would be a different case. you have both out of state attorneys, the notices come back marked retur