scheduled to get kavanaugh confirmed. arthel: amber, breaking news editor of the daily caller, there. thank you. eric: the fox news report that former fbi lawyer lisa page testified behind closed doors that investigators could not find proof of collusion before special counsel mueller was appointed back in april of last year. her testimony before congress the other week, former federal prosecutor stephen muller joins us, law professor at the university of memphis and a criminal defense attorney. steve, what do you make of the fact that ms. page allegedly claims that in may of 2017, months after the fbi investigation began, the fbi down possible collusion, they claim? well, it s certainly indicative of what the state of play was at start of the mueller investigation. i m noter the by shock by it terribly shocked by it.