to the ninth circuit. i think if the ninth circuit were to uphold judge walker s ruling, that case would be heard by the united states supreme court. so this is certainly the beginning of what s going to be a very long legal debate in the principal court system. and has been a very long legal debate already. all right, robert shapiro, thank you. john lewis, stewart gaffney, gentleman, i hope that it bodes well for your lives in the future. thank you for joining us. thank you so much. our pleasure. police arrested the daughter of former new york mayor rudy giuliani, booked her on suspicion of stealing makeup from sephoria. the former new york city mayor with a reputation for getting tough on crime says through a spokesperson that the media should respect his daughter s privacy. carolyn giuliani left the police precinct with her mom and a lawyer. the gals on the view are not happy about the dustup between whoopi goldberg and mikhail salahi. in case you missed it, just last ho