remedy for a very serious situation, while she says, i can t find that here but let me go ahead and look at these are the things. as you say, she makes it up as she goes along, the 11th circuit has no tolerance for that. i will tell you as a former 11 circuit appellate chief in my old u.s. attorney s office before i became u.s. attorney, one thing that we are known for this circuit is the collegiality which which the court conduct itself. this opinion might read as very understated to people who have not practiced in the circuit or to the folks that are laypeople, but it reads loud and clear that anyone who has ever been in front of a panel in this court, it is a real sound bench slap at this judge telling her that she has done frank, removing her discretion and directing her to end this case now. i guess i ve read enough opinions to know that this was a pretty insulting opinion, properly so. glenn kirschner in the next segment we will discuss with
jurisdiction, that is the plaintive has some kind of constitutional right that has been tallow sly disregarded by the government. that is when you would get in equitable remedy at all, this very unusual remedy for a serious situation. well, she says, i could not find that here. but let me go ahead and look at these other things. as you say, she makes it up as she goes along. the 11th circuit has no tolerance for that, and i will tell you as a former 11 circuit chief in my old u.s. attorney s office, before i came u.s. attorney, one thing we are known for in this target is the collegiality in which the court conducts itself. this opinion might read as very understated to people have not practiced in the circuit or to folks who are laypeople, but it reads loud and clear that anyone who s ever been in front of a panel in this court, it is a real, sound bench slap at this judge, telling her that she has done wrong, removing her discretion, and directing