i heard this god awful scream. was this an accident? there was absolutely no allegation of evil intent. or something else? i m with more to her dead than i am alive. hello, and welcome to dateline. to outsiders, every marriage is a mystery. some who knew the couple in our story sought to people in love, others a marriage in trouble. but, all agree this husband and wife did have one thing going for them, they both loved hunting. they were also both excellent shots, so good they rarely missed whatever the target. here s keith moore with as darkness fell. twilight, the day going fast now, the meadow, a while in blackwood. what did she know, now as she studied, herself was it hours ago on did she know already back at the camp in the morning? where was it later, much later that they showed her the evidence, and darkness that swallowed them all. they call it the rock, this gorgeous island with this fishing and cove and mile after mile of woods. a place to fall in lo
gone far? it s inappropriate, doesn t make him a murder. you have a wolf in sheep s clothing. sinister minister. the man of the cloth, inspired from the pulpit. we went away feeling that you had heard something. marrying the faithful. he officiated over my son and daughter in law s wedding. counsel the trouble. he is so good at understanding how to comfort other people. but one of the ministers is expected to have gotten it all. i believe it was all fraud. the minister? will the minister roll. i think he was hiding behind that hat. but whether a stranger in crown circle robes carrying out the devil s business. i believe he plays on the vulnerable people. laying hands where he shouldn t. minister into more than a sole. he would basically council his way right into their bedrooms. just who was the reverend arthur burton sherman? reverend sherman, a.b. to his friends. was a small town methodist priest or in small town, pennsylvania. he
I love you. I cant wait to see you. It was like Somebody Just put a hole right through your heart. Last, lives, a adultery. Was there more . There was blood everywhere. There was something fishy. If you have a pattern of behavior. Yes. Wives that turn up suspiciously dead . Yes. How far had this man had gone far . Its inappropriate, doesnt make him a murder. You have a wolf in sheeps clothing. Sinister minister. The man of the cloth, inspired from the pulpit. We went away feeling that you had learned something. Marrying the faithful. He officiated over my son and daughter in laws wedding. Counsel the trouble. He is so good at understanding how to comfort other people. But one of the ministers is expected to have gotten it all. Believe it was all fraud. The Minister Role . The Minister Role. I think he was hiding behind that hat. But whether a stranger in crown circle robes carrying out the devils business. I believe he plays on the vulnerable people. Laying hands where he shouldnt. Min
was criminal negligence causing death, a big, difference a very big difference. and it was like there was a disconnect in some way between the charges, and in charge of public opinion. or the criminal, code there is no allegation of evil intent. yes, really, agreed attorney in the criminal negligence charge, it was the charge in the simplest terms, that mary beth was criminally irresponsible when she squeezed the trigger and the dark that awful night. trigger and the dark that awful night. in fact, a maximum life sentence. it was big news, where mary beth in-laws made their somber presence known. but the pilgrimage to the lonely brush where mary beth s bullet found her mark. and went on september 13th, 2010, four years to the week after the incident in the brush,
the daughter samantha was terrified. she called the police. frantic that her mother would become the third late misses a.b. schirmer. investigators agreed. and decided they couldn t wait any longer to arrest the former pastor. with what they saw as another potential women at risk, they decided to make their move. on september 13th, 2010, detective wagner knocked on the front door of cynthia s house. cindy came to the door and i asked where mr. schirmer was, and she said, he was in the kitchen. and as i started to approach into the kitchen area, he went out the back door and ran right into the he was trying to make a getaway,? it appears so. but, a.b. schumer did not resist. he was cuffed and read his rights. charged with the murder of his second wife, betty. the deepest secrets of the reverend schirmer we are about to be revealed to all. he would stand trial and a case that would leave a small pennsylvania town abuzz with