resuscitation of the domestic industry that s getting the protection, but instead immense consumer cost, retaliation by foreign trading partners, a net loss in american jobs. most importantly here, not even the long term resuscitation of the industry giving protection. dana: let me ask the other scott. i have two scotts on. it is reported that senior staff to the president, cohn, mattis and tillerson are all against this. they are afraid this would harm the global economy and damage relationships with allies. there are obviously people on the other side saying it s already damaging. how do you argue that? is it that china is breaking the rules or that we have a national security problem stp i think it s both, dana. i d be quick to point out those are assertions folks made about cohn s point of view. i haven t heard him speak publicly about it. i have heard wilbur ross. i heard the president say very clearly they want to take action to defend america s steel industry and aluminum in