to be conscious it is operating as a team and delivering that would see us continue to win elections and at this moment we need to reflect on what this moment we need to reflect on what is this moment we need to reflect on what is working and not working. in terms what is working and not working. in terms of what is working and not working. in terms of policies i would take forward terms of policies i would take forward. my starting position is that we forward. my starting position is that we need to turbo charge the scottish that we need to turbo charge the scottish economy. growth in the last quarter scottish economy. growth in the last quarter was scottish economy. growth in the last quarter was 0.1%. we need to support or small quarter was 0.1%. we need to support or small businesses, and also scotland s key industries. if you take scotland s key industries. if you take the scotland s key industries. if you take the renewables industries and our green take the
disproportionate impact on the scottish disproportionate impact on the scottish economy. gf disproportionate impact on the scottish economy. disproportionate impact on the scottish economy. of course, saying it is easier than scottish economy. of course, saying it is easier than doing scottish economy. of course, saying it is easier than doing it. they are already tearing down the set here but this time at least the candidates did not tear each other apart. it was less fiery than previous debates and there was probably more focus on policy, and as we saw, some tough questions from some frustrated members of the audience, a reminder that the leader of the scottish national party, whoever is going to be, has to really do two things. on the one hand, make that case and argue for independence, and on the other hand govern competently. and these candidates disagree on quite a lot. but they know that you cannot really disentangle those two tasks. james, many thanks for the report on
and ash regan, a former minister, answered questions from a live audience about health care, the economy and the question of scottish independence. our scotland editor james cook was watching. enter the lion s done, these three have been debating each other on tv and in town halls for the past fortnight. now for the first time they were face to face with a live studio audience. they were face to face with a live studio audience. what do you say to eo - le studio audience. what do you say to people spending studio audience. what do you say to people spending their studio audience. what do you say to people spending their life studio audience. what do you say to people spending their life savings i people spending their life savings on private surgery because of the length of nhs waiting lists in scotland? , , ., , scotland? firstly, can i apologise to ou scotland? firstly, can i apologise to you because scotland? firstly, can i apologise to you because you scotland? firstly,
wind? i believe it will and for me it is urgent. because wind? i believe it will and for me it is urgent. because of- wind? i believe it will and for me it is urgent. because of things i wind? i believe it will and for me | it is urgent. because of things like brexit it is urgent. because of things like brexit which it is urgent. because of things like brexit which has it is urgent. because of things like brexit which has had it is urgent. because of things like brexit which has had a brexit which has had a disproportionate - brexit which has had a. disproportionate impact brexit which has had a i disproportionate impact on brexit which has had a - disproportionate impact on the scottish disproportionate impact on the scottish economy, disproportionate impact on the scottish economy, because i disproportionate impact on the scottish economy, because ofi disproportionate impact on the i scottish economy, because of the energy scottish economy, because of the energy crisis
work under devolution, if we want a better scotland, if we want to - work under devolution, if we want a better scotland, if we want to solve j better scotland, if we want to solve these better scotland, if we want to solve these challenges, better scotland, if we want to solve these challenges, if better scotland, if we want to solve these challenges, if we better scotland, if we want to solve these challenges, if we want - better scotland, if we want to solve these challenges, if we want to - better scotland, if we want to solve these challenges, if we want to put| these challenges, if we want to put more these challenges, if we want to put more money these challenges, if we want to put more money and these challenges, if we want to put more money and investment - these challenges, if we want to put more money and investment into l these challenges, if we want to put l more money and investment into the nhs, more money and investment into the nhs, if more money and inv