Of thinking about this proposal thats on the table. Lets thank beth. [applause] and thank all of you for your terrific questions which made for an enlightening discussion and as i said before that this book is on sale outside. Please help yourselves. [applause] [inaudible conversations] im very honored to have a chance to be with you today and to be able to moderate our Wonderful Program on the Death Penalty. I am Michael Gerhardt a constitutional law professor and also i have the honor of being a scholar at the National Constitution center. We have three terrific panels today who are going to be available after the program to be able to sign their books and talking about those books. Although the next panel will start promptly at 2 15. Just to get us started we have on my far left sub122 was judge robert m. Parker and dominant of law into his right ms. Carol steiker the in closest to me is grace and justice on death row widely regarded as one of the nations leading Capital Punishment