who joins us. good to have you. happy st. paddy s day. same to you. i think it s unconstitutional and there are a couple of press debits, supreme court ruling that ind precedent and supreme court rulings that deal with that. one had line item veto. i don t want to get into arcane stuff but there were decisions indicating that bills have to be passed by both houses of congress. it doesn t seem like that s too hard to figure out for most of the colleagues, so i think there is a real constitutional challenge there. by the way, i was entertained that the president today said well, it really didn t matter. back when senator obama was faced to within attempt on the republican side to have 51 votes for the confirmation of judges he said it was a violation of our founding fathers beliefs about how we should behave. my, how times change. neil: this issue and other similar ones regarding how it s crafted, the healthcare