Steep the sun will be blocked as it moves across the sky the neighbors behind you yap of two many times the capitalization of one floor addition will have a significant shadowy understand the project sponsor has agreed and i assume as part of the case report to make 9 second floor even with the dr requesters building mr. Lindsey. That plan has not been simpleminded. Well have to take dr but i want to say the architect present of yeah. Hi dr requesters have talked about the phelps of the building it has no real Significant Impact either way although they get a little bit of a separation between their yards and the one story addition but there is a structural reason why that is different to do maybe you could explain that. It has to it nooechlz a steven it has a lot to do with the water that anything rats through the hill it has been augmented when the client bought the building a wall was placed through there but it runs to the year a lot of times theres active waters coming through the
Proud to be a fourth generation san franciscan this renovation is going to allow our family to be good members of San Francisco as my family i believe has been the core of that dispute with our neighbor is to move the extension to the other side of the yard as mr. Syncot said the challenge we purchased the home we made a significant investment in the seismic and foundational work by moving will force us to upgrade much of the investment we want to meet all the important in the city of San Francisco we finally made a number of attempts to reach a compromise we met them with 5 times most recently to bring in the back of the homes awe like that on the is it correct story with his home as well as changes those were rejected i ask for your support many our remodel and deny the request for dr. The architects are available for any questions you may have about design. Thank you is there any Public Comment . In support of project sponsor okay dr requester you have a 2 minute rebuttal. Thank you
Thank you. Project sponsor you have two minutes. Thank you i want to point out that the grade between those two buildings that was mentioned by the project sponsor is only been measured from the rear yard he didnt mention theres a difference of two feet so the impact of the higher building is really again much less than presented i can show you the additional shadows this is a view of the area this shows the shadows how long how long theyre coming from the south and east theyre coming from this area theyre already blocking that area and again, we are expending out to the same legislated that the adjacent properties all right. Are i appreciate our time but no reason to find exemplary and extraordinary circumstances if you wish the architects are here. With that, the public portion is closed. Commissioner antonini. Yeah. I visited the site yesterday and got a a chance it was overcast but i would doubt the impact of the Property Building could have much of a effect only shadows its only 1
As is neighbor i dont wish to get involved with those kinds of issues but the San Francisco residential guidelines should prevail. Thank you. Is there any additional Public Comment. Hello, im isabel im a High School Junior and the daughter of the folks all i want to say those neighbors they moved in we were welcoming to them and want them to enjoy their house and the expansion all we are asking to move it over to minimize the impact it has on the neighbors thats it the only reason so we can keep as karina said before keep the relationship we had before thats my one request thank you. Is there any additional Public Comment seeing h seeing none, project sponsor your team has 5 minutes. Hello, im david im here on behavior on behalf of brian who are the project sponsors and want to point out that the dr requester has not notified that i extraordinarily facts and circumstances after 5 meetings with the neighbors some compromises were made changes to the project to try to accommodate some of
Residential guidelines he quote to me the residential guidelines address the common guidelines of residential design all permits must imply with the residential Design Guidelines and they having must comply with the principle one principle says place the this on the site to respond to the topographic i didnt those quotations suggested to him that the microphone might negotiate an young and old model we presented our they have in issue with the design in spite of wavrn the sponsors the lot exceeding 20 percent that might require additional Environmental Review our 3d model graefg utilizes the center image of the forms of envelopes the existing at the top and the permit application at the bottom and our compromise in the middle it casts shadows into the cigarette butt as you can see from our exits the envelope is the same square feet and accomplishes the same program as their preapplication plan on loots that looerl step down the hill it should minimize the impact open the downhill princ