the vast majority of people that they did not get a tax cut. it was just not significant enough for them to really feel it. in fact, something like a quarter of people thought their taxes went up. so, the perceptions of this bill are going to be very hard to surmount, even if people see a small lift in their paychecks, they may not notice it. thank you. david, good to have you, sir. thank you, come back. we have a republican congresswoman from new york state standing by. this is what she said about the same tax bill back in november before she made up her mind on her vote. all eight of my counties are in the top 36 highest property taxes in the nation. it s problematic when you have high tax states like new york. about 20 minutes ago, she voted yes. we ll ask her what changed her mind. plus, why voters are giving trump credit for the economy but not not the republican party. this holiday, the real gift isn t what s inside the box.