It is not whether or not we need workers. Our side has been saying consistently said us economy requires the labor of immigrant workers and we should provide an appropriate way for those workers to come into the country, to be here legally and get the rights that they deserve. What i would say is we dont disagree, we are thrilled to hear you say we need these workers come we have been trying to say that for a long time. Lets not bring them in and depress the wages of workers that are currently in that industry. This recognizes that what that bill does and it is attempting to set a slightly higher wage except it doesnt achieve the end result it seeks to achieve. Thank you, that is illuminating. I would like to ask you, this question, so difficult to get people to do these jobs in labor shortages why are we cutting the minimum wage and reducing protections for people to induce them to take the job . Excellent question. Cant remember who spoke to the idea of a free market which has been r