Uninterrupted argument and then that would be questioning in order of with meet and then judge laurier. Mr. Constable, you will begin and you have reserved three minutes for rebuttal. Thank you, your honor, and good morning. May it please the court. And may it please the court. On remand the president filed an amendment complaint raising two claims. First, that the subpoena at issue is an overbroad fishing expedition, and second, that it was issued in bad faith in order to arrest the president. The District Attorney concedes that the Supreme Court has authorized the president to bring these claims in federal court. The only issue then on appeal is whether the allegation of bad faith are possible. The District Court termination they are not to be reversed for several reasons. First, the court stack the deck against the president by asserting that these claims are a disguised attempt to relitigate category and 90. As a distant turn it also concedes they cleanly are not. Second, the court