phenomena. they call him the evidence whisper. hello. the college student vanished after a night out clubbing. nancy thought she was out sleeping with friends. it would take years for detectives to uncover the truth buried in a pile of lies but could they find lynsie. here is the night lynsie disappears. reporter: sometimes the facts are as clear as the southern california skies. other times you have to know where to look to see the truth. this man has made a career of noticing what others do not. what s his reputation? meticulous investigator. pouring over the volume of evidence and finding things that other investigators did not find. the evidence whisperer? yep. reporter: does this man acts guilty or does he know more than what he s saying? what about this man, can you believe the story he s telling. i was supposed to pick her up twice, she was so out of character and did not show up either day. reporter: the evidence whisperer were not present o
reporter: they were working the case. they brought in the usual suspects like the boyfriend. when you guys were dating, she hasn t been dating anyone else to your knowledge? no. reporter: his name was matthew ramirez. when i went to her house on thursday reporter: as can happen with young romance, what was off was soon back on. lynsie and matt were back together in time for the weekend. but not in time to make plans for that friday night. i told her, have fun, be careful. she said, okay. reporter: then in came the last person known to have seen her. chris mcamus, 21 years old, out of school. lynsie had met him through friends four months prior. it turned out he never drove lynsie to andrea s house for a leapover. chris said that was a lie lynsie
friends about four months prior. and it turned out he never drove lynsie to andree kra s house for a sleepover. chris said that was a lie lynsie made up for her mother. the real plan was to go clubbing all night in san diego. she goes, don t tell my mom that we re going to san diego, because my mom won t let us go or won t let me go or something hike that. and definitely don t tell her that we re clubbing. chris told police that when their night of clubbing went bust they went home earlier than expected. he dropped off the other girls and headed to lynsie s house. chris said it was after 4:00 in the morning when he finally got to lynsie s neighborhood. lynsie was worried that her mom might hear his truck pull up at that hour, so chris says lynsie asked to be dropped off here at the corner. that sounded strange to police, until they heard from friends that she had asked to be dropped off here.
would one day just come home. you thought that one day she would walk back through the door? yes. she believed it because she wanted to, and, because over the years, several people had told her they d seen lynsie. they never saw the front of her face. they always saw the back of her, and i held onto every word they said. her friend kim remembers how hard it was on nancy, thinking lynsie had just left her. she went through the period of being angry at her and thought maybe she is. maybe she did leave me. and she threw some of her pictures out and clothes out. she threw lynsie s stuff away? she did because she was so angry and thought how could she do that?
and i think that was a little bit of nancy. the pd was working the case. they brought in the usual suspects, like the boyfriend. when you guys were dating, she hasn t been dating anyone else. no. his name was matthew ramirez. he was at college with lynsie. they d been off and on a little bit. but then. she was like, i want to break up. what was off was soon back on. lynsie and matt were back together in time for the weekend, but not in time to make plans for that friday night. maybe i ll go to san diego. i told her, have fun, be careful, okay? she goes, okay. then, in came the last person known to have seen her. chris mcamis, 21 years old, out of school. he told the cops he was unemployed. lynsie had met him through