I also at times asked you to be creative and come up often we have a lot of attorneys that do exactly what we asked them to do and then if we dont tell them to do some and they dont provide us with everything we you ashley took on projects and use them your creativity to make things happen to appreciate you going the distance with us on a lot of our Charter Amendment and yes, we did not make your life very easy but hopefully it was interesting and i was filling in your work and your work with us was great. Thank you that you supervisor avalos. Supervisor farrell. On e might collect it its been awesome working good i want to say thanks for all the work hard work you put into. Even amazing asset were going to miss you thank you. Supervisor mar its been such a pleasure to work with you and you deserve your retirement thank you so much and enjoyed so much, tom thank you very much. Seeing no names on the roster we will go to our imperative item. On behalf of supervisor cohen and imperative