it s now time for a panel discussion comparing the two books from exploring their place in medical literature in their impact have moderated by david baldacci. we ventured is panel has appeared dalia litwack, contributing editor at newsweek and senior editor at slate where she writes this supreme court dispatch and jurisprudence that has been a guest columnist for the new york times op-ed page. and also, rosenbaum, the john wellen distinguished lecturer in law and director of the four mama, culture and society in law school in himself the author of several high regard novels. i ll turn it over to david at this point. i want to add my congratulations to john. i was one of those literary minded astute judges who picked the compassion of a book that was not deserving of the word. it was a stiff competition, but the judges agreed and we went over the books in detail at john s book rose several obvious that. it was a book that was an only reasonable terrifically entertaining