Intern chief of police the office of citizens complaints joyce hicks you. Well to the monday, december 21, 2016, thank you for being here ill start off by welcoming our newest supervisor commissioner hwang well get to hear from you it is great to have you here and change a little bit of the order of agenda so if youre following along ill move up items 4 and 5 up to after 2 the consent calendar is well go in order one, 2, 4, and 5 and then sergeant, next line item. Item one presentation of certificate presentation of the California Department of alcohol abc significant Achievement Award to the abc liaison unit alu. Hello and thank you for allowing us a few minutes im the acting director the alcoholic beverage for the state and here to acknowledge the work of the San Francisco Police Department and ill ask them to please come up here we definitely want to acknowledge their hard work we develop programs i to paint the picture two hundred agents on the street and manage 90 thousand liquor
Chair has called the meeting to order please turn off the Electronic Devices and please rise for the pledge of allegiance and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under god, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Commissioner hillis id like to call roll. Please do commissioner president loftus commissioner Vice President turman commissioner marshall commissioner dejesus commissioner mazzucco commissioner melara commissioner hwang commissioner president loftus we have quorum and also with us the intern chief of police the office of citizens complaints joyce hicks you. Well to the monday, december 21, 2016, thank you for being here ill start off by welcoming our newest supervisor commissioner hwang well get to hear from you it is great to have you here and change a little bit of the order of agenda so if youre following along ill move up items 4 and 5 up to after 2 the consent calendar is well go in order one, 2, 4, and 5 and then sergeant, next line item. Item one pre
With the equipment in the room and please rise for the pledge of allegiance and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under god, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Commissioners commissioner Vice President turman id like to call roll. Sure. Commissioner president loftus is accused commissioner Vice President turman commissioner marshall commissioner dejesus is excused commissioner mazzucco commissioner serlina commissioner hing commissioner Vice President turman we have quorum and also with us the intern chief of police that chief chaplin and office of citizens complaints. Thank you. Good evening ladies and gentlemen, and people of the public director intern chief chaplin and my follow commissioners welcome to the wednesday, january 4, 2017, Police Commission meeting the first meeting of the year i dont see any particular changes we need to make to the agenda so well take it from the top and our fbis ill turning the mike over to former Commission President commiss
And we are focusing on the opportunities. Thank you. Chief do you have a comment. Just a question youre talking about manuals you guys have are those manuals available from any staff. Sure. Sure. Commissioner Vice President turman. Commissioner hing and i wanted to follow up on commissioner Vice President turmans question to mr. Balthazar when we asked you about the training and theres alluded to a second ago as well does it pertain to recommendation one. Uhhuh. It sounds like this is ongoing training the training includes at least includes a discussion of what preponderance of the evidence means in addition to witness credibility assessment. Yes. Thats correct. Is that in the form. Id like to look at that training material looks like. Are you saying preponderance of the evidence after that the evidence is in including the witness credibility. When we conclude our investigation we have to make a determination as to each the allegations against the officers well look at the evidence to
And we are focusing on the opportunities. Thank you. Chief do you have a comment. Just a question youre talking about manuals you guys have are those manuals available from any staff. Sure. Sure. Commissioner Vice President turman. Commissioner hing and i wanted to follow up on commissioner Vice President turmans question to mr. Balthazar when we asked you about the training and theres alluded to a second ago as well does it pertain to recommendation one. Uhhuh. It sounds like this is ongoing training the training includes at least includes a discussion of what preponderance of the evidence means in addition to witness credibility assessment. Yes. Thats correct. Is that in the form. Id like to look at that training material looks like. Are you saying preponderance of the evidence after that the evidence is in including the witness credibility. When we conclude our investigation we have to make a determination as to each the allegations against the officers well look at the evidence to