That they went on throughout 2016, werent a lot of them but there were conversations. Cant be sure of the exact dates but the president can remember having conversations with him about it. Throughout 2016 . Yeah, probably up to could be up to as far as october, november. Our answer is cover until election so any time during that period they could have talked about it. Well the finaling of the negotiations is essential in the Ongoing Investigation by special counsel Robert Mueller. And yesterday giuliani acknowledged that trump told mueller about the talks with russia. Take a look. Said the president is not sure when talks ended. Im guessing you had to answer this question in written form by mr. Mueller. That is where we ended it. That is such a key line. In other words the president s response to Robert Mueller in written form, that is the first indication we got of any of the written responses, including that he was negotiating for getting that hotel built in moscow right up until the