achieve . they can be very expensive, if you have been able to get the right deal. none of that should be used as a smokescreen to get away from the real issue, which is the cost of living being absolutely extreme. energy bills are a huge part of that. the government hasn t done enough. you can they can say that they have done enough. lenders are all money than payback over five years. it s completely unrealistic, and doesn t meet the scale of the challenge. what we want to do real support six, hundred pounds forth that s the scale of what is required. whatever the long term energy strategy that the government unveils, it can t get away from the fact they have to take let s get a voice from ukraine, shall we? alona shkrum this curly in paris after having met with the french president, she misses now. thanks for being on the