independent treasury officials have costed labour s policies and they amount to a £2000 tax rights for working family. it looks like now the chief treasury civil servant actually wrote to labour at two days ago saying the conservative assessment of their tax plan should not be presented as having been produced by the civil service. the debate sought the labour leader sir keir starmer challenged over hospital waiting lists among other things. with a rant out of the highlights from that debate, this is our political correspondent ian watson. the first debate of the campaign was a head to head clash between the prime minister and the man who wanted to replace him. if you re still wondering about the key messages they want to hammer home at this election, wonder no longer. this election is all about a choice more of the chaos and division we ve seen for the last 14 years, or turning the page and rebuilding with labour. no one knows what labour would actually do. but you know
very clear they were speaking about. it is not very clear what anybody is actually going very clear what anybody is actually going to very clear what anybody is actually going to do. it is really not. towns like this, going to do. it is really not. towns like this, we going to do. it is really not. towns like this, we are all run down. we have like this, we are all run down. we have lost like this, we are all run down. we have lost our like this, we are all run down. we have lost our industry. that times have have lost our industry. that times have changed. we can t go back in time have changed. we can t go back in time. ~ ., ., have changed. we can t go back in time. . ., ., ,., have changed. we can t go back in time. . ., ., y., ., have changed. we can t go back in time. ., ., ., time. who do you think performed the best of the two? time. who do you think performed the best of the two? you time. who do you think performed the best of the two? you are time. who