union people who received the top offs to the pensions. it was totally unfair. totally at the discretion of the auto task force group. stuart: earlier today we had a guest showing government e-mails they had unearthed, they put them out there, and it seemed to show that the treasury had a direct hand in saying, no, you guys don t get it, the union does. it was the treasury that pulled the trigger, so to speak. what do you make of this? guest: well, we absolutely believe that and we have asserted that for a long time act, it is interesting, irs our know what one of the e-mails says and it mentioned pointedly, that the proposal obviously the treasury was putting forward was going to get rubber stamped by g.m. the treasury continues to stand