acknowledge we are using too much coal, we are going to stop it by 2038. i ve coal, we are going to stop it by 2038. i vejust coal, we are going to stop it by 2038. i ve just interviewed a candidate for the greens, she said thatis candidate for the greens, she said that is not good enough. it needs to happen in 2030. earlier in the day, interviewed a woman from greta thornburg s movement, she said none of the parties are getting on with it enough. this needs to happen sooner still. it enough. this needs to happen soonerstill. no it enough. this needs to happen sooner still. no one is disputing that germany needs to get itself of coal, the question is about the timing. how quickly can germany do this without jeopardising jobs timing. how quickly can germany do this withoutjeopardising jobs and established industries question mark the parties to have different answers on that. we the parties to have different answers on that. the parties to have different answers on that. ~ . , , answer