only on the books for about three days all right why was it so short lived i can hazard a guess yeah well the protests of course helped along those lines apparently the government ended up agreeing with the critics in this case you know they said look this really wasn t a good idea in fact they released this statement over the weekend explaining some of their rationale and it says in part taking into account of the general feeling in the population and advice from phone companies the cover of the government notes that the way this decree was implemented disrupts the global sector to the detriment of consumers particularly those of modest means of the same and also listed a number of technical difficulties including the accidental cancellation of some people s internet plans so the implementation of this was a total mess activists of course they see this as a huge victory for those protests that we saw we spoke earlier with giulio juan oshie is the executive director of internet without