agency that republicans and democrats agree to be the ultimate authority is the congressional budget office. they looked at this question and they found that raising the top, the rates on the top 2% will have virtually no impact on gdp and virtually no impact on job formation, the republicans in congress didn t like that study. so they asked the crs. congressional research service to review the data and come up with conclusions and guess what, they looked at this and said the same thing, almost no impact on job creation, no impact on gdp formation, almost all of the economists seem to be unanimous about this, that the obama plan. let me finish the point. the obama plan finishes the rate on the top 2% will have virtually no impact on job formation. i resemble your remark about facts and opinions, we have both on this show. let s hear the data. brenda: gary b, you go right to it. you know, julian has his study and you know, the other side has another study, ernst
cheat on and the reason it is it bad. economy growing at 2.4 percent. it would not stimulate the commempt i like the bus tax cutos the top two percent than the valuattedad tax. all of the economic data said if you let them expire you will have no impact on job creation and no impact on gdp formation. and no impact on reducing the deficit by the way. we are talking about that? it is it tracey what do you think? hold on, guys. tracey, this means businesses are off of the hook. i love it but i know we would tack it on to the other taxes . add that to the pile. if we get rid of everything else and focus on this it could work briviantly. it would be hard to wrap tup. john, last word to try to