In a series of Instagram Stories, which are archived in a highlight called Falco/Freehold, Rosenthal and his followers theorized that parts of the original pizza pie had been burned, leading Falco to jigger the best slices from multiple pies into two more photogenic pizzas for his Instagram photo. Rosenthal called it some Chuck E Cheese trickery.
So what was going on here?
New Times reached out to both the Freehold and Falco, with no success. Through a spokesperson, the team at Freehold Miami declined to comment. Falco did not respond to an email asking if the photo does, in fact, depict slices from multiple pizzas and if so, why.