President Judge Maria Musti Cook ordered Kevin Nagle, 46, of McSherrystown, to immediately begin completing the remainder of his sentence of one year minus one day to two years minus two days in York County Prison. He had been free on supervised bail pending the outcome of his appeal, which the Pennsylvania Supreme Court refused to hear in December.
The York County District Attorney’s Office, she noted, had asked for a sentence of three to six years in prison. Cook said she gave significant thought to the factors that she’s required to consider at sentencing and did not believe that she had jurisdiction to modify the punishment.