Thank you for all your votes, we have a WINNER of the best pies in Ocean County.
There was a top 5 - Emery s Farm, Sand Castle Diner, Lucille s, Costco, and Mueller s Bakery.
Get our free mobile app
Lots of votes came in and we have a WINNER. Congratulations to Emery s Farm in New Egypt. If you ve never tried the pies at Emery s, they are superb. My family always asks for me to grab a pie on my way to Pennsylvania, they know good pies.
I was talking to Linda from Brick in BJ s in Toms River and we were talking about pies. I thought this would be a great article. Where are the best pies in Ocean County? Linda was telling me that the pies at BJ s and Costco are the biggest and the best. I had to try a pie from Costco and Linda was right, delicious.