this is an accidental drowning. there is no good samaritan law in the state of new york. she had no duty to save her drowning fiance. it was 46 degree water. how could she jump in and save him? when you are in the water kayaking you have limited time to react. situations arise. let me say this. if i was, if any regular person was with their fiance maybe they are in shock. wouldn t you try? the problem the prosecutor is going to have they have to prove it beyond a reasonable doubt. just in that report alone, if the causation of the death is the intoxication and not anything she did there could be enough doubt there there are several holes, no pun intended several holes that the prosecutors need to plug. we don t know what is going to happen here. it s not an easy one. do you think it s smart the prosecutor put manslaughter up?